How Christian Denominations View One Another (AQA A-Level Religious Studies): Revision Notes
How Christian Denominations View One Another
Understanding toleration and dialogue
Toleration means allowing something even though you disagree with it. This concept is important when studying how Christian denominations relate to each other. Toleration involves making a negative judgement about what is tolerated, whilst recognising that being intolerant would be worse.
Before examining how denominations view each other, it's worth noting that some Christian thinkers, like Karl Rahner, developed concepts about how Christianity relates to other faiths. Rahner's idea of 'anonymous Christianity' suggested that people outside explicit Christianity might still live in God's grace and attain salvation by following their conscience. This principle of charitable interpretation has influenced how some Christians approach dialogue not just with other religions, but also with other Christian traditions.
Historical background
Christianity has never experienced complete uniformity in belief and practice. Even the letters of Paul in the New Testament reveal early disagreements within Christian communities, particularly regarding how Jews and Gentiles could unite within the Church. By the end of the first century, at least 40 individual Christian communities existed.
The early Church centres
By the fourth century, five main Church centres had emerged: Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch and Jerusalem. Christianity developed differently in each location, leading to disputes over doctrine. When Emperor Constantine converted to Christianity in 312CE, the Edict of Milan (313CE) ended Christian persecution. Constantine later made Christianity the empire's official religion and sought doctrinal uniformity.
In 325CE, Constantine convened the Council of Nicea in Turkey. This council produced the Nicene Creed, an agreed statement of faith. From this point, those who disagreed with official creeds were labelled heretics and often persecuted. Six further ecumenical Church councils over the next 450 years continued debating and defining doctrine.
The Great Schism (1054)
A major split occurred in 1054 between Eastern and Western Christianity. Several long-term disputes caused this division:
- The exact nature of the Holy Spirit
- The wording of the Creed
- Use of leavened versus unleavened bread in Holy Communion
- Power struggles between the bishops of Rome and Constantinople
The Patriarch of Rome (the Pope) claimed authority over the whole Church, whilst the Patriarch of Constantinople claimed his See was 'first among equals'. In 1054, mutual excommunications marked the formal split. The Western Church became known as the Catholic Church, whilst the Eastern Churches became the Orthodox Churches.
The Reformation (16th century)
The sixteenth-century Reformation split Western Christianity into Catholics and Protestants, with each group persecuting the other. The Church of England separated from Rome and papal authority but remained Catholic in theology, whilst being influenced by Reformation ideas.
Further splits followed. Free Churches, Methodists, Baptists and others eventually became independent denominations, often facing legal restrictions.
Modern denominational landscape
Today, three broad divisions exist:
- Orthodox (Eastern Churches)
- Roman Catholic (Western Church under papal authority)
- Protestant (Reformed Churches emphasising scripture)
The Anglican Churches, including the Church of England, sit between Catholic and Protestant traditions, incorporating elements from each.
Within these divisions, there are many denominations. The World Council of Churches has 349 member denominations, plus numerous independent evangelical churches, non-denominational 'mega-churches' and small house churches operating autonomously.
Reasons for divisions within Christianity
Six main areas explain separations between Churches:
1. Issues of authority
- Should one leader hold authority, should all leaders be equal, or should there be no hierarchical leadership?
- Should scripture be the source of authority, or should authority rest with individual believers and their relationship with God?
2. Particular traditions or practices
Different denominations emphasise different practices. For example, Baptists emphasise adult baptism as a reminder of Jesus' baptism, whereas Catholic and Orthodox Churches practise sacramental infant baptism.
3. Church governance and organisation
Some denominations allow local congregations to make their own decisions, whilst others have centralised governance through rules and laws.
4. Interpretations of scripture
Some denominations read the Bible literally as the inerrant word of God. Others view it as written by fallible human authors who were inspired by the Holy Spirit.
5. Inspiration and worship style
The Pentecostal movement emphasises 'gifts of the Spirit' in informal, loosely structured worship. Catholic worship is usually formal, structured and focused on the sacrament of Holy Communion.
6. Acceptance of creeds
From the fourth century onwards, accepting official creeds separated orthodox believers from heretics.
The word 'orthodox' with a lowercase 'o' means 'right-believing'. When written with an uppercase 'O', it refers to the Eastern Churches.
Exam tip: Be prepared to explain specific examples of how these six factors have led to denominational divisions.
How Christian denominations view each other
Different denominations have different doctrinal emphases, affecting how they view other Churches. Individual members may hold personal views that differ from their denomination's institutional position.
The Roman Catholic Church
The Catholic Church emphasises maintaining continuity with the original Church established by Jesus and the apostles. Several key concepts underpin this view:
Apostolic Succession means authority from Jesus, given to the apostles, passes from one generation to the next through the physical laying on of hands at ordination. This creates an unbroken chain linking modern clergy to the first apostles.
Continuity is maintained through:
- Holding the same core beliefs expressed in the ancient creeds
- Using the same rituals from the earliest days of the Church, particularly the sacraments of Baptism and Holy Communion
- Passing traditions from one generation to another
The Catholic Church views itself as the Body of Christ and a single spiritual entity. People either belong to this body or they are separated from it. Those separated may possess admirable qualities and seek to follow Christ, but they remain cut off from the authentic source of Christian teaching and sacraments.
This represents a closed inclusivist position. Other Christians reflect aspects of the Christian faith, but they lack the continuity and authority of Catholicism.
Pope John Paul II's 1995 encyclical Ut Unum Sint ('That they may be one') demonstrates this approach. Non-Catholics are called 'separated brethren'. Catholic theologians can and should engage in dialogue with them in charity and humility, but must always stand firm in Church teaching. The document states:
The unity willed by God can be attained only by the adherence of all to the content of revealed faith in its entirety. In matters of faith, compromise is in contradiction with God who is Truth.
Key concept: The Catholic Church recognises other denominations as Christian but believes they lack full authority and authentic sacramental life.
Protestant evangelical Churches
Protestant evangelical theology stems from Martin Luther's Reformation teachings. Three Latin phrases summarise core Protestant principles:
- Sola gratia (by grace alone) - salvation comes only through God's grace
- Sola fides (by faith alone) - salvation comes through faith, not works
- Sola scriptura (by scripture alone) - everything Christians need to know is found in the Bible
Luther also taught the priesthood of all believers - individual Christians can communicate directly with God without priestly mediation.
From this perspective, individuals can read and understand scripture for themselves under the Holy Spirit's inspiration, without requiring authoritative Church interpretation. Salvation is God's undeserved grace, unrelated to ritual observance. Faith means personal commitment to God in Christ, informed by scripture. The emphasis falls on faith rather than obedience to tradition or participation in sacraments.
Protestant evangelical Churches judge other Christians by:
- How they apply New Testament principles
- Whether individual members declare commitment to Christ as their personal saviour
They view Churches teaching that specific actions and worship forms are necessary as failing to follow scripture.
Protestant evangelicals prefer self-governing communities without central or national authority structures, based on the New Testament book of Acts, which portrays autonomous, self-contained early Churches. They therefore see the hierarchical authority structures of the Church of England, Roman Catholic Church and Orthodox Churches (with bishops, priests, deacons and central governance) as unbiblical and erroneous.
For Protestant evangelicals, authentic faith requires personal conviction and commitment. Those not making this commitment remain outside the Church and cannot achieve salvation. This is an exclusivist position. Protestant evangelicals don't actively exclude people, but believe those not committed to Christ have excluded themselves from salvation.
Exam tip: Be clear about the difference between exclusivism (only one path to salvation) and inclusivism (recognition of truth in other traditions whilst maintaining one's own as superior).
The Church of England
After separating from papal authority in the 1530s, the Church of England remained Catholic in theology. Reformation (especially Calvinist) influence grew during subsequent troubled years. By the Elizabethan Settlement (1559), the Church of England was officially described as 'Catholic and Reformed'.
Over centuries, the Church of England has held various views. Today, evangelicals, Anglo-Catholics and Pentecostal communities all exist within the Church of England.
This diversity makes it difficult to identify one single view regarding other Churches. The official position is non-committal: it recognises other Churches, acknowledging differences in worship, ministry forms, decision-making structures and how they work in the world. The Church of England generally admits that no Church, including itself, is perfect.
This willingness to work with other Churches towards agreement has led to numerous bilateral conversations and formal agreements:
- Anglican-Roman Catholic International Commission (ARCIC) from 1969 onwards
- Porvoo Agreement with Lutheran Churches (1996)
- Reuilly Declaration with French Protestant Churches (2001)
The Church of England's position cannot be defined as one agreed view. However, the engagement it undertakes with other Churches and its unwillingness to exclude other Christians from salvation's possibility can be described as inclusivist.
Worked Example: The Church of England's Inclusive Approach
The Church of England is internally divided over ordaining women, yet works closely with both the Roman Catholic Church (which excludes women from priesthood) and the Methodist Church (which accepts women's ordination at all ministry levels). This demonstrates its willingness to maintain relationships despite significant theological differences.
Key concept: The Church of England's 'broad church' approach allows diverse theological positions within one institution.
Ecumenism
Ecumenism describes initiatives to develop relationships between Christian Churches to promote Christian unity. The term comes from the Greek word meaning 'the whole inhabited world'.
The Ecumenical Movement originated in the early twentieth century. Its work is most clearly seen in the World Council of Churches. The movement's general emphasis is not to deny or explain away differences between Christian denominations, but to recognise shared ground and opportunities to work together.
The World Council of Churches takes a practical rather than theological approach. This differs significantly from Orthodox and Catholic approaches, which start from the idea that the Church is Christ's Body, expressed through sacraments and assent to Church creeds.
Catholic participation in ecumenism
The Roman Catholic Church has not applied for World Council of Churches membership. Nevertheless, it engages in formal conversations with other Churches:
- ARCIC conversations with the Church of England
- Dialogue with Lutheran Churches since 1964
- Ongoing dialogue with Orthodox Churches
These conversations focus on understanding theological and doctrinal issues over which Churches have historically disagreed, seeking common ground.
Exam tip: Be prepared to evaluate whether ecumenical dialogue has been successful in promoting Christian unity, considering both achievements and ongoing challenges.
Remember!
Key Points to Remember:
-
Christianity has never been uniform - divisions existed from the earliest days and continue today through Orthodox, Catholic and Protestant traditions.
-
Six main factors cause divisions: authority structures, particular traditions, church governance, scripture interpretation, worship styles, and acceptance of creeds.
-
Different approaches to other denominations: Roman Catholics take a closed inclusivist position (separated brethren), Protestant evangelicals an exclusivist position (personal commitment required), and the Church of England an inclusivist position (broad church approach).
-
Key movements: The Great Schism (1054) split East and West; the Reformation (16th century) divided Western Christianity into Catholic and Protestant.
-
Ecumenism seeks Christian unity through practical cooperation and theological dialogue, exemplified by the World Council of Churches and bilateral agreements like ARCIC.