The Presidential Election Result of 4 November 2008 (Edexcel A-Level History): Revision Notes
The Presidential Election Result of 4 November 2008
Obama's decisive victory
On 4 November 2008, Barack Obama achieved a clear and historic victory in the United States presidential election, becoming the 44th president. At 11:00pm that evening, John McCain conceded defeat, marking the end of a hard-fought campaign.
The election results demonstrated Obama's overwhelming success:
- Popular vote: Obama received 69,499,428 votes (52.86 percent of the total)
- Electoral college: Obama won 365 electoral college votes (67.8 percent)
- McCain's performance: The Republican candidate secured 59,950,323 votes (45.60 percent) and 173 electoral college votes
- Third-place candidate: Ralph Nader (Independent) polled 739,278 votes (0.56 percent) but won no electoral college votes
Obama's victory was particularly significant as he became the first Democrat to win a majority of the popular vote since Jimmy Carter in 1976. This demonstrated a clear shift in American political sentiment and marked a historic moment in US history.
Factors contributing to Obama's victory
Personal qualities and the message of change
Obama's campaign benefited enormously from his personal qualities and exceptional speaking skills. At 47 years old, he positioned himself as representing a new generation of political leadership, particularly when compared to McCain, who at 72 was the oldest candidate ever to run for a major political party.
The central theme of Obama's campaign was change. This message resonated powerfully with American voters who were weary of President George W Bush's unpopular administration. Two major issues dominated the political landscape and worked against McCain:
Key Issues That Shaped the Election:
- The Iraq War: Public dislike of the ongoing conflict and its aftermath created significant problems for the Republican campaign
- The economic crisis: The 2008 financial crisis severely damaged Republican credibility on economic management
These factors created an environment where Obama's message of change found particularly receptive audiences.
Obama successfully presented himself as a wholesome family man with two young daughters, creating an appealing image that contrasted sharply with McCain's portrayal as "yesterday's man" who was linked to the outgoing Bush administration.
The Bradley Effect did not materialise
Obama did not suffer from the Bradley Effect, a phenomenon where white voters tell pollsters they will support an ethnic minority candidate but then vote for the white candidate on polling day. This effect is named after Tom Bradley, the black mayor of Los Angeles, who experienced this pattern in his 1989 gubernatorial race in Virginia when black candidate Douglas Wilder saw his 15 percentage point lead shrink to a victory margin of just 6,000 votes.
The absence of the Bradley Effect in 2008 suggested that American society had progressed in terms of racial attitudes and willingness to vote for a black candidate. This was a significant indicator of changing social dynamics in the United States.
Demographic breakdown of support
Obama built a broad coalition of support across different demographic groups:
White voters:
- 44 percent of white voters overall supported Obama
- 54 percent of white voters under 30 years old backed him, confirming his appeal to younger generations
Black American voters:
- Obama won 95 percent of the black American vote
- This represented an increase from 84 percent who had voted for Democrat John Kerry in 2004
- This overwhelming support reflected both racial solidarity and genuine enthusiasm for Obama's candidacy
Latino voters:
- 65 percent of Latino voters supported Obama
- This was 13 percent higher than Kerry's performance in 2004
- This increase demonstrated Obama's ability to build support among Hispanic communities
Campaign organisation and fundraising
The Obama campaign demonstrated exceptional organisational capabilities and fundraising prowess. According to a BBC assessment on 5 November 2008, several factors stood out:
Fundraising success:
- The campaign attracted over three million donors
- Total fundraising reached $650 million
- This exceeded the combined spending of both major candidates in the 2004 presidential election
Campaign infrastructure:
- Obama established four times as many campaign offices as McCain
- In the final weeks, Obama outspent McCain by a ratio of 4 to 1 in key swing states
- Swing states are those where both major parties have similar levels of support and which possess large numbers of electoral college votes; in the 21st century, Ohio and Florida have been particularly important
Campaign Impact in Florida:
The campaign conducted a major voter registration drive that demonstrated the effectiveness of Obama's grassroots organization. In Florida alone, Obama added 300,000 people to the registered Democrat list. This grassroots mobilisation proved crucial in turning out supporters on election day and helped secure this vital swing state.
Innovative use of social media
Obama's campaign made pioneering and decisive use of social media, which proved to be a game-changing factor. The well-planned digital strategy successfully communicated Obama's message in ways that previous candidates had failed to achieve.
Social Media's Impact on the Campaign:
The social media campaign helped to:
- Reinforce Obama as the candidate for change
- Emphasise his representation of a young generation
- Create a sense of connection and participation among supporters
- Mobilise voters and organise grassroots activities
This innovative approach to campaigning set new standards for political communication and demonstrated how technology could be harnessed for political success.
McCain's vulnerabilities
While Obama ran a strong campaign, McCain faced several significant disadvantages that hampered his ability to compete effectively:
Age and image:
- At 72, McCain was portrayed as "yesterday's man"
- His age contrasted unfavourably with Obama's youthful energy
Association with Bush:
- McCain struggled to distance himself from the unpopular outgoing president
- This association damaged his credibility, particularly on the Iraq War and economic management
McCain's "Out of Touch" Moment:
McCain's personal wealth became a liability during the economic crisis. A damaging moment came when he could not remember how many houses he owned when questioned by the media. This created an image of someone out of touch with ordinary Americans struggling economically during the financial crisis.
Media coverage concerns:
- A September 2008 Gallup Poll revealed partisan divisions over media coverage of the Republican ticket
- 54 percent of Republicans felt vice-presidential candidate Sarah Palin received unfairly negative coverage
- However, only 33 percent of all Americans agreed, with 36 percent believing coverage was "about right"
- Regarding McCain himself, 53 percent of Americans felt media treatment was "about right", though 30 percent believed coverage was unfairly negative
Obama's victory speech: themes of unity and hope
On the night of 4 November 2008, Obama delivered his victory speech in Grant Park, central Chicago. The speech articulated several powerful themes that would define his presidency:
Validation of democracy:
- Obama addressed those who doubted whether "all things are possible" or questioned "the power of our democracy"
- He pointed to the unprecedented voter turnout as evidence that democracy works
National unity:
- The speech emphasised that Americans had sent a message that the country was not "just a collection of individuals or a collection of Red States and Blue States"
- Instead, Americans were and would always be the United States of America
- He listed the diverse groups who supported him: "young and old, rich and poor, Democrat and Republican, black, white, Hispanic, Asian, Native American, gay, straight, disabled and not disabled"
The message of change:
- Obama declared that after a long struggle, "change has come to America"
- He acknowledged this was a "defining moment" in American history
- The speech positioned the election as the fulfilment of long-held hopes for transformation
Future challenges:
- Obama outlined the work ahead: putting people back to work, opening doors of opportunity, restoring prosperity, and promoting peace
- He spoke of reclaiming the American Dream
The Power of "Yes We Can":
The speech concluded with Obama's famous campaign slogan "Yes we can". This phrase was presented as a "timeless creed that sums up the spirit of our people" and represented a response to "cynicism, and doubts, and those who tell us that we can't". The slogan became iconic and symbolized the optimism and determination of the Obama campaign.
The victory speech successfully balanced celebration with a recognition of the serious challenges facing the nation, setting a tone of hopeful determination for the incoming administration.
Key Points to Remember:
-
Barack Obama won decisively on 4 November 2008, securing 365 electoral college votes (67.8 percent) and 52.86 percent of the popular vote, becoming the first Democrat to win a majority of the popular vote since Jimmy Carter in 1976.
-
Obama's victory was built on multiple factors: his message of change resonating after Bush's unpopular presidency, exceptional campaign organisation with $650 million raised from over three million donors, and innovative use of social media.
-
Obama assembled a broad demographic coalition, winning 95 percent of black American votes, 65 percent of Latino votes, and 54 percent of white voters under 30, demonstrating his appeal across racial and generational lines.
-
The Bradley Effect (where white voters claim they will vote for an ethnic minority candidate but actually vote for the white candidate) did not occur, suggesting progress in American racial attitudes.
-
Obama's 47 years contrasted with McCain's 72 years, allowing him to position himself as representing a new generation, while McCain struggled with his association with Bush and appeared out of touch during the economic crisis.