Tulsa Race Riot, 1921 (Edexcel A-Level History): Revision Notes
Tulsa Race Riot, 1921
Background and context
The Tulsa Race Riot of 1921 stands as one of the most devastating racial attacks in American history. It occurred in Tulsa, Oklahoma, a booming oil town that had attracted large numbers of both white and black migrants seeking economic opportunities. The riot took place two years after the Red Summer of 1919, a period marked by numerous race riots across the United States.
The term "Red Summer" refers to the summer and early autumn of 1919, which saw approximately 25 race riots across major American cities. The violence was often triggered by competition over jobs and housing as black Americans migrated from the rural South to urban centers.
Tulsa's prosperity from oil exploitation had created unusual circumstances: the city contained Greenwood, a predominantly black American district that had become economically successful. Some black residents had achieved considerable wealth, which would prove to be a significant factor in the violence that followed.
The trigger event: Dick Rowland's arrest
The immediate cause of the riot began on 30 May 1921 when Dick Rowland, a young black American, was accused of sexually assaulting a white girl in a lift. He was subsequently arrested and held in the local jail.
On the following day, 31 May 1921, the local newspaper, the Tulsa Tribune, published a fabricated story. The paper falsely claimed that Rowland had scratched the hands and face of the white girl during an alleged assault. This sensationalist reporting, presented as fact despite being entirely fictitious, inflamed racial tensions in the city.
The Power of False Journalism
The Tulsa Tribune's completely fabricated story demonstrates how irresponsible media reporting can directly incite racial violence. No evidence of an assault ever existed—the entire newspaper account was fiction designed to inflame public sentiment.
The violence escalates
By 10.30pm on 31 May, the situation had deteriorated rapidly:
- Nearly 2,000 white Americans had gathered outside the jail where Rowland was being held
- The crowd attempted to lynch Rowland (lynching refers to the illegal killing of someone, usually by hanging, carried out by a mob without trial)
- Black sympathisers from Greenwood travelled to the jail to protect Rowland from the mob
- Violence broke out between the two groups
By the end of that night, white mobs had turned their attention to Greenwood itself, launching a devastating attack on the black American community.
The destruction of Greenwood
The assault on Greenwood involved extensive violence and widespread arson. The scale of destruction was unprecedented:
Human cost:
- Between 200 to 300 black Americans were killed
- The actual death toll may have been higher, as many bodies were never officially recorded
Property destruction:
- Approximately 1,000 black homes and businesses were burned to the ground
- Total property damage was estimated at $1,500,000 (a massive sum in 1921)
- Widespread looting accompanied the burning
Population displacement:
- The intensity of the attacks forced 2,500 black Americans (half of Tulsa's entire black population) to flee the city
- Many never returned, leaving Greenwood permanently diminished
The Scale of Devastation
To put the $1,500,000 in property damage into perspective, this would be equivalent to approximately $23 million in today's money. The destruction of Greenwood represented the complete annihilation of what had been known as "Black Wall Street"—one of the most prosperous African American communities in the United States.
Underlying causes of the riot
Walter White, a leading American civil rights activist, secretly entered Tulsa after the riot and investigated the causes. Writing for The Nation magazine in an article entitled 'The Eruption of Tulsa' (published 29 June 1921), White identified several key factors:
Economic resentment
Oklahoma's black community had experienced remarkable economic success, sharing in the sudden prosperity brought by the oil boom. This achievement, however, generated bitter resentment among poorer white residents:
- At least three black Oklahomans were worth $1 million each
- J.W. Thompson of Clearview was worth $500,000
- Numerous black residents possessed wealth valued at $25,000 to $100,000
The Paradox of Black Success
Many white residents, particularly those from lower economic backgrounds, felt that black Americans—whom they regarded as members of an 'inferior race'—were being 'presumptuous' in achieving greater economic prosperity than themselves. This contradicted their belief in white racial superiority and created deep resentment.
Rather than inspiring admiration or acceptance, black economic achievement became a catalyst for violence—a tragic pattern repeated throughout American history.
Southern prejudices transplanted
Oklahoma's white population included many pioneers who had migrated from other states, particularly from the Deep South:
- Former residents of Mississippi, Georgia, Tennessee, and Texas had brought their anti-Negro prejudices with them
- These migrants were often described as 'lethargic and unprogressive by nature'
- It particularly angered them to see black Americans making greater economic progress than they were achieving
- Their racial attitudes had been shaped by the more intensely segregated societies they had left behind
Political corruption in Tulsa
Walter White identified a third crucial factor: rotten political conditions in Tulsa itself:
- A vice ring (organised criminal network) had controlled the city for fourteen years
- This criminal element allowed the open operation of:
- Houses of ill fame (brothels)
- Gambling establishments
- Illegal whiskey sales
- Banks and stores were regularly robbed with hardly any arrests made
- Even when criminals were arrested, there was minimal chance of conviction
- The 'better element' of Tulsa's citizens were interested only in making money and leaving
- They took little interest in electing honest city or county officials
- This allowed those involved in vice operations to secure officials who would protect their illegal activities
The Role of Lawlessness
This corrupt political environment meant that law and order had broken down in Tulsa, creating conditions where mob violence could occur with little expectation of legal consequences. The absence of effective law enforcement emboldened the attackers and left Greenwood's residents without protection.
The broader historical context
The Tulsa Race Riot did not occur in isolation. The race riots of the 1917-21 period took place against a backdrop of increasing discrimination against black Americans:
- The creation of legal segregation in the Old South was being enforced through violence
- White supremacist groups like the Ku Klux Klan used intimidation and violence to maintain racial hierarchy
- There had been a major deterioration in black American civil rights
- The gains in rights achieved at the end of the Civil War (1861-65) had almost entirely disappeared
The Bitter Irony of War Service
Discrimination against black Americans actually increased after the First World War ended in 1918. This occurred partly in response to fear of thousands of returning black American servicemen who had served their country fighting for democracy abroad, yet returned to find themselves denied basic rights at home.
Black soldiers who had fought to "make the world safe for democracy" came home to Jim Crow segregation, disenfranchisement, and deadly violence—a profound betrayal that highlighted the hypocrisy of American democratic ideals.
Historical significance
The Tulsa Race Riot represents a particularly extreme example of racial violence in early 20th-century America. Several factors make it historically significant:
- Scale of violence: With 200-300 deaths, it was one of the deadliest race riots in American history
- Property destruction: The systematic burning of an entire prosperous black community was unprecedented
- Economic motivation: Unlike some riots triggered purely by racial hatred, Tulsa demonstrated how black economic success could provoke violent white backlash
- Official complicity: The involvement of local authorities and the failure to protect black citizens revealed how deeply racism was embedded in American institutions
- Media role: The Tulsa Tribune's fictitious reporting demonstrated how sensationalist journalism could incite racial violence
- Long-term impact: The destruction of Greenwood eliminated a thriving black business district, setting back black economic progress in the region for generations
A Pattern in American Race Relations
The riot also revealed a common pattern in American race relations: black achievement and prosperity, rather than reducing prejudice, often intensified white resentment and violence. This paradox—where success invited punishment rather than respect—shaped the African American experience throughout much of the 20th century.
Comparison with earlier riots
The Tulsa riot shared some similarities with the Chicago riot of 1919, but also had distinct characteristics:
Similarities:
- Both occurred during the period of black migration northward and westward
- Both involved competition over resources (housing in Chicago, economic opportunities in Tulsa)
- Both featured newspaper reporting that inflamed racial tensions
- Both resulted in significant casualties and property damage
Differences:
- Tulsa was specifically triggered by an accusation of assault against a white woman
- The scale of property destruction was far greater in Tulsa
- Tulsa involved the complete devastation of an entire black community (Greenwood)
- The economic resentment factor was more prominent in Tulsa due to the visible black prosperity there
Key Points to Remember:
-
The Tulsa Race Riot occurred on 30 May - 1 June 1921 in Tulsa, Oklahoma, triggered by the arrest of Dick Rowland, a young black American falsely accused of assaulting a white girl.
-
The Tulsa Tribune published a fictitious story that inflamed racial tensions, leading to a mob of nearly 2,000 white Americans gathering to lynch Rowland.
-
The violence spread to Greenwood, the prosperous black American district, resulting in 200-300 deaths, the destruction of approximately 1,000 homes and businesses, and the displacement of 2,500 people (half of Tulsa's black population).
-
Three underlying causes drove the violence: economic resentment of successful black Americans, anti-Negro prejudices brought by southern migrants, and political corruption that had allowed a vice ring to control Tulsa for fourteen years.
-
The riot occurred during a period of increasing discrimination against black Americans after the First World War, despite their service to the country, demonstrating how black economic success could provoke violent white backlash rather than acceptance.