Themes (OCR A-Level English Literature): Revision Notes
Themes
Christopher Marlowe's Edward II explores complex themes that reflect the political, social and personal tensions of 14th-century England. Understanding these themes is essential for analysing the play's dramatic impact and its commentary on power, identity and human relationships. This guide examines five key themes that run throughout the text.
Edward's sexuality
One of the most distinctive and controversial aspects of Marlowe's play is its portrayal of the king's homosexuality. Whilst the historical Edward II's sexuality remains debated, Marlowe's character is depicted as openly homosexual, engaging in intimate relationships with Gaveston and later with Spencer Junior. This representation was particularly daring for an Elizabethan audience and remains central to the play's exploration of power and prejudice.
The depiction of Edward's sexuality was remarkably bold for Elizabethan theatre, where homosexuality was not only considered sinful but also illegal. Marlowe's willingness to make this a central element of his play demonstrates his daring approach to controversial subjects.
Homophobia and court reaction
The noblemen at court display clear hostility towards Edward's relationships, though they rarely state their homophobia directly. They use the derogatory term minions to describe Edward's lovers, suggesting servile followers who have gained undeserved influence. Since homosexuality was considered sinful in 14th-century England, Edward's behaviour places him outside the authority of the Church. The Bishop of Coventry, a powerful Catholic figure, emerges as a driving force behind Gaveston's initial exile, demonstrating how religious institutions sought to control the king's personal life.
Gaveston's status as both a homosexual and a foreigner from France makes him a double outsider. His presence threatens the established power structure of the English court.
Example from Act 1, Scene 4:
Mortimer Junior criticises Gaveston's flamboyant continental clothing, associating such displays with effeminacy. Later, he accuses Edward of wearing fancy robes into battle, suggesting the king's sexuality has compromised his masculine identity as a military leader. This connection between homosexuality and perceived weakness becomes a weapon the barons use against Edward.
Public display of power
Edward's refusal to hide his same-sex relationships becomes a statement of royal authority. Mortimer Senior notes that many successful rulers and wise men have had same-sex affairs, but Mortimer Junior responds that Edward's relationships lack discretion. The king openly expresses his love for Gaveston, even seating him on the throne beside him, making his private desires a matter of public record.
The contrast between Edward's public displays and Queen Isabella's secret affair with Mortimer Junior reveals how royal power operates differently for men and women. Edward exploits his unlimited power to normalise what others consider transgressive behaviour, whilst Isabella must maintain absolute secrecy.
The cost of favouritism
However, Edward's devotion to his lovers severely compromises his governance. Because his lovers are men, he can appoint them to positions women could never hold in the male-dominated court. He grants both Gaveston and Spencer Junior earldoms (influential positions in the English nobility), despite Spencer Junior's youth and Gaveston's humble background. Both men understand and manipulate their power over the king.
Example from Act 1, Scene 1:
Gaveston describes plans to seduce Edward through sexually charged entertainments, whilst Spencer Junior later tells Baldock he intends to exploit Gaveston's attraction to him for personal advancement. These deliberate manipulations show how the favourites consciously use their intimate relationships for political gain.
Punishment and cruelty
Edward's imprisonment and torture in Act 5 can be interpreted as punishment for what the barons view as deviant behaviour. The assassin Lightborne speaks to Edward with the tenderness of a lover before killing him, creating a sophisticated form of psychological cruelty that mocks Edward's sexuality even in death.
Pride and abuses of power
The central conflict of the play revolves around the struggle for control between Edward and his barons. In the first half, Edward confronts the nobles as a group; in the second half, his confrontation with Mortimer Junior becomes dominant. Both sides demonstrate how pride leads to the corruption and abuse of power.
Edward's tyrannical behaviour
Edward consistently uses his royal privileges to serve personal interests rather than the nation's welfare. He controls England's finances and spends lavishly on courtly entertainments designed to seduce him, as Gaveston anticipates in Act 1, Scene 1. The king furnishes Gaveston with expensive clothing that enrages the barons, who see this as a vulgar display of unearned wealth.
Edward's financial mismanagement directly damages the nation. In Act 1, Scene 4, Mortimer Junior reveals that soldiers fighting England's wars are not being paid. When Mortimer Senior is captured in Scotland, Edward refuses to pay the ransom, despite this being a royal obligation. This betrayal of the very nobles who fund his extravagances pushes the barons towards rebellion.
The nature of absolute monarchy
England's 14th-century kingship was an absolute monarchy, meaning the king's power could not be legally checked or challenged. Obeying the king was both a moral and political duty, and opposition risked execution. Edward, uncertain how to wield this immense power responsibly, quickly becomes angry and vindictive. In Act 1, Scene 1, he immediately threatens his barons with death when they disagree with recalling Gaveston. He even gives Gaveston the king's seal, granting him the power to save or punish anyone at will.
Absolute monarchy in medieval England meant that the king's word was law. There were no constitutional checks on royal power, no parliament with real authority to refuse the king's demands, and no legal mechanism for removing an incompetent monarch. This made the barons' resistance both dangerous and technically treasonous, even when motivated by genuine concern for the realm.
Strategic resistance
The barons, lacking the king's absolute authority, must use strategy to resist. In Act 1, they secure Gaveston's exile by allying with the Catholic Church, the only institution capable of effectively challenging royal power. Mortimer Junior tries to intimidate Edward by emphasising that the Mortimer family name should inspire fear, asserting his authority as a born aristocrat. Later, he exploits his relationship with Isabella to control the royal family after Edward's removal from power.
Moral responsibility and loyalty
The play explores the difficult balance between personal loyalty to the king and responsibility to the nation. Characters struggle with conflicting duties when their monarch proves weak and incompetent.
Competing obligations
The barons recognise they should maintain a harmonious relationship with the monarchy. When Edward briefly reconciles with them in Act 1, Scene 4, they gladly return to court, claiming their defiance was a last resort forced by the king's negligence. Both Warwick and Isabella describe the civil war as unnatural, a violation of fundamental social principles.
Example from Act 2, Scene 2:
Mortimer Junior accuses Edward of failing his responsibility to listen to and support his loyal nobles. He argues that a strong court strengthens the monarch, and Edward's court grows weaker as he alienates the aristocracy. The conflict tears England apart with civil war. By Act 3, Scene 4, when Edward prepares to execute Warwick and Lancaster, Mortimer Junior declares that the king's treatment of his nobles has crippled the country.
Shared convictions
As the play progresses, both sides become increasingly convinced of their moral righteousness. Marlowe employs rhetorical repetition, having characters echo their opponents' phrases to demonstrate how both factions have similar motivations. Self-interest and concern for the realm mix in complex ways.
Some characters act more selflessly than others in navigating these competing loyalties:
- Kent shifts loyalties as he tries to support whoever will best serve England
- Prince Edward remains devoted to both his father and the institution of monarchy
- Isabella and Gaveston balance personal ambition with genuine concern for those they love
Cruelty and violence
Physical and psychological violence permeate Edward II, serving as tools for domination, manipulation and revenge. The play demonstrates how cruelty becomes both a weapon and a self-perpetuating cycle.
Execution as intimidation
Threatened and actual executions help characters rule through fear. The vengeful Edward frequently imagines graphic mass slaughter. In Act 1, Scene 4, after the Archbishop of Canterbury forces Gaveston's exile, Edward envisions rivers running with priests' blood. When contemplating revenge for Gaveston's death, he desires to take as many lives as he has castles and towns in England.
Even a single execution can terrify the country into obedience. Spencer Junior and Kent both advise Edward to display the heads of treacherous barons on poles, where they will 'preach' to the public. This grim language suggests the severed heads will serve as sermons warning against rebellion.
When King Edward III orders Mortimer Junior's execution at the play's end, a lord brings the king Mortimer's severed head. This dramatic convention of Elizabethan tragedy signals the complete defeat of an enemy.
Humiliation and torture
Edward cruelly humiliates his enemies whilst in power. In Act 1, he wants the Bishop of Coventry 'christened' in a channel (open sewer), using religious language sarcastically to indicate the bishop will be stripped of titles and authority.
The Cycle of Cruelty:
This exact treatment later befalls Edward himself in Act 5, when his captors shave his beard with sewer water, demonstrating how the cycle of cruelty perpetuates itself. What Edward inflicts on others becomes his own fate, showing the circular nature of revenge and violence in the play.
Psychological manipulation
Flattery and false hope become forms of humiliation. In Act 2, Scene 5, the barons initially promise a final meeting between Gaveston and Edward, only to deny the reunion when Warwick kills Gaveston. Lightborne gives Edward false comfort before his Act 5 execution, speaking as a lover might, causing Edward to feel momentarily secure before the betrayal of death.
Mortimer Junior weaponises psychological cruelty as a control mechanism:
- He instructs Maltravers never to give the captive king hope, as hope might inspire defiance
- He orders Edward's frequent relocation between prisons, preventing rescue whilst disorienting him and destroying any sense of stability
- In Edward's final days, he endures loud noises, terrible smells and sleep deprivation, maximising his pain and terror
Social class and identity
Social status dictates every aspect of life in Edward's court, defining privileges, responsibilities and loyalties. For most characters, class is inseparable from personal identity.
Advancement through favouritism
The easiest path to social and political promotion involves becoming one of Edward's favourites. In Act 1, Scene 1, Gaveston plans seductive entertainments to please the king and is rewarded with unprecedented power. Spencer Junior recognises he can exploit Gaveston's sexual attraction to him for his own advancement, advising Baldock to impress Edward by dressing and acting like an aristocrat. Spencer's comment that Edward appreciates the 'formal toys' of fancy dress reveals the king's susceptibility to superficial displays.
Mortimer Junior also understands royal approval as a shortcut to power, vowing in Act 5, Scene 4 to promote his friends and punish his enemies once he controls the monarchy. This pattern shows that the desire to manipulate power through favouritism extends beyond Edward's favourites to the barons themselves.
Violation of social norms
Edward's favouritism violates the established social order. In 14th-century England, aristocratic status was inherited through birth. The barons come from noble families and have served the king and country for years. They are outraged when Gaveston, a Frenchman from a humble background, receives equivalent status overnight.
Titles and positions become meaningless if anyone can achieve them through favouritism. This loss of status drives the barons to treachery and revenge. Mortimer Junior claims even common people are upset by Gaveston's advancement, since no one else has opportunities to rise above their inherited social position.
Class and personal worth
Social class becomes a powerful determiner of both political and personal value. Gaveston is astounded by his own promotions, feeling undeserving, yet he dismisses common people in Act 1, Scene 1, comparing them to embers he can brush away. When he offers jobs to three poor men, Gaveston tests out his new aristocratic status, enjoying having others ask him for favours.
Edward derives his sense of value entirely from his royal status. He feels entitled to loyalty, obedience and good treatment. The indignities he suffers during the play—separation from his lover, captivity and torture—seem particularly terrible because they happen to a monarch.
Edward's Crisis of Identity:
When forced to resign in Act 5, Edward cannot relinquish his royal identity. He agonises over who he will be without his crown, as surrendering it means surrendering his sense of self. Edward never abandons the belief that he is king. This conviction gives him dignity in his lowest moments, and he reminds Lightborne of his royal status even before execution.
Key Points to Remember:
-
Edward's sexuality is central to the play's exploration of power, prejudice and authority. His open homosexuality challenges both religious doctrine and social norms, whilst his public displays of affection become statements of royal privilege.
-
Power corrupts both sides of the conflict. Edward abuses his absolute monarchy to favour his lovers and fund personal entertainments, whilst the barons use strategic alliances and eventually force to challenge him. Both sides believe they act for England's good whilst pursuing self-interest.
-
Loyalty and moral duty conflict when a weak king fails his responsibilities. The barons struggle between their obligation to obey the monarchy and their duty to protect England from Edward's negligence.
-
Violence serves multiple purposes: executions intimidate opponents, torture breaks resistance, and psychological cruelty manipulates victims. The cycle of cruelty continues as Edward inflicts on others what is later inflicted on him.
-
Social class defines identity in the play's world. Characters' sense of worth depends on their inherited status, and Edward's favouritism threatens the entire social order by granting unearned advancement to outsiders like Gaveston.