Evil and suffering (AQA GCSE Religious Studies A): Revision Notes
Evil and suffering
Evil and suffering present one of the most challenging questions for religious believers. These experiences can lead some people to question their faith in God, wondering how a loving and powerful God could allow such pain to exist in the world.
Types of evil and suffering
Understanding different categories of evil and suffering helps us explore how Christians respond to this difficult issue.
The distinction between moral and natural evil is fundamental to understanding Christian responses to suffering. This categorisation helps believers address different types of suffering with appropriate theological explanations.
Moral evil and suffering
This type of suffering is directly caused by human actions and choices. When people choose to act in harmful ways, they create moral evil. Examples include murder, rape, war, and theft. This suffering exists because humans have been given free will and sometimes use it to hurt others. Catholics believe that God gave humans the ability to choose between right and wrong, and unfortunately, people sometimes choose to do evil.
Natural evil and suffering
This category includes suffering that occurs through natural processes rather than human actions. Examples include famines, diseases, earthquakes, and natural disasters. These events cause immense pain and loss, yet they happen without any human intention to cause harm. Natural suffering challenges believers because it seems to occur regardless of whether people are good or bad.
The problem of evil and suffering
The existence of evil and suffering creates what philosophers call the "problem of evil". This centres on an apparent contradiction between God's nature and the reality of suffering in the world.
The inconsistent triad
The Inconsistent Triad - A Core Challenge to Faith
Christians believe God has three key characteristics that seem to conflict with the existence of evil:
Omnibenevolent: God is all-good and loving. If this is true, God would want to remove all evil and suffering because he cares deeply for his creation and desires what is best for everyone.
Omniscient: God is all-knowing. This means God would know exactly how to remove evil and suffering from the world. He would understand every situation and know the perfect solution to end all pain.
Omnipotent: God is all-powerful. If God possesses unlimited power, he would be able to remove evil and suffering completely. Nothing would be impossible for him to achieve.
The challenge is that if God truly possesses all three of these qualities, it seems logical that evil and suffering should not exist. Yet they clearly do exist, which raises difficult questions about God's nature or existence.
What the Bible says about evil and suffering
Scripture provides various perspectives on why evil and suffering exist and how believers should respond to them.
Biblical foundations
The Bible teaches that God originally created a perfect world without suffering. Catholics believe that God never intended for his creation to experience pain or evil. However, evil entered the world through human disobedience, fundamentally changing the nature of human existence.
Christians believe that God sent Jesus to Earth specifically to address the problem of evil and suffering. Through Jesus's death on the cross, God provided a way to overcome evil and offered hope for humanity. This demonstrates God's love and his active involvement in solving the problem of suffering.
Some Christians accept that evil came into the world through the influence of the devil. The story of the snake in the Garden of Eden represents how temptation and evil infiltrated God's perfect creation through external spiritual forces.
Key biblical passages
The Bible offers comfort and guidance for those experiencing suffering:
"Turn to me and be saved, all you ends of the earth; for I am God, and there is no other." (Isaiah 45:22)
This verse declares God's unique position and invites people to turn to him for salvation and relief from their troubles.
"God is our refuge and our strength." (Psalm 46:1)
"The Lord is compassionate and gracious, slow to anger, abounding in love." (Psalm 103:8-9)
These passages from Psalms emphasise God's protective care and loving nature, offering reassurance to those who are suffering.
The Book of Job
Biblical Example: Job's Response to Suffering
Job's story provides a profound example of faith during extreme suffering. Job endured tremendous losses, including his family and physical health, yet he maintained his belief in God.
Key Elements of Job's Story:
- Job didn't blame God for his suffering
- He accepted suffering as part of God's larger plan
- The book suggests suffering can serve as a test of faith rather than a punishment
- Christians believe this teaches that people may not understand why they suffer, but should continue to trust in God
"In all this, Job did not sin by charging God with wrongdoing." (Job 1:22)
Catholic responses to the problem of evil and suffering
The Catholic Church offers several ways to understand and respond to evil and suffering, recognising that this remains a mystery that humans cannot fully comprehend.
The Book of Psalms and reassurance
Catholics find great comfort in the Psalms, which acknowledge the reality of suffering while affirming God's goodness. Psalm 119 specifically talks about God helping his followers to cope with life's struggles if they follow his rules. The psalmist writes: "Seek your servant, for I have not forgotten your commands" (Psalm 119:175-176). This suggests that even when believers don't fully understand their circumstances, they can find purpose and meaning by following God's guidance.
Prayer as a response
Prayer as a Coping Mechanism
Many Catholics respond to evil and suffering through prayer. They believe that turning to God in difficult times provides strength and comfort. Even when prayers aren't answered in the way people want, Christians maintain that God still has a plan for everyone. Prayer connects believers with God's love and helps them find peace despite their circumstances.
Charitable action
Practical Example: The Samaritans Organisation
Suffering often inspires Christians to help others who are experiencing similar difficulties. Chad Varah established the Samaritans organisation as a result of witnessing suffering during his work as a priest in London. This demonstrates how experiencing or observing evil and suffering can motivate believers to take practical action to reduce pain in the world.
Free will and human development
Free Will and Spiritual Development
Catholic teaching emphasises that God gave people free will, allowing humans to choose between good and evil. This gift of choice means that people sometimes commit acts of moral evil.
Key Theological Perspectives:
- St Augustine's theodicy: Suggests that allowing free will, even with its potential for evil, creates greater good than forcing people to be good
- St Irenaeus's view: Proposed that evil and suffering are necessary for human development and spiritual growth. According to this view, experiencing difficulties helps people become more like God by developing compassion, strength, and wisdom
This perspective suggests that a world without any suffering might not allow humans to reach their full potential.
Key Points to Remember:
-
Evil and suffering challenge faith - The existence of pain in the world can make it difficult for believers to understand God's nature, but many Christians find ways to reconcile their faith with this reality.
-
Two types of suffering exist - Moral evil comes from human choices, while natural evil occurs through natural processes, each raising different questions about God's involvement.
-
The Bible offers hope and guidance - Scripture provides comfort through passages that emphasise God's love and protection, while stories like Job demonstrate faithful responses to suffering.
-
Catholics respond in multiple ways - Through prayer, charitable action, and accepting that some aspects of God's plan remain mysterious, believers find meaning even in difficult circumstances.
-
Free will explains some evil - The gift of choice allows humans to commit evil acts, but also enables genuine love and goodness to exist in the world.