Evil and suffering (AQA GCSE Religious Studies A): Revision Notes
Evil and suffering
The challenge of evil and suffering
The presence of evil and suffering in our world creates a significant challenge for Christians who believe in an all-loving and all-powerful God. This theological problem, often called the 'problem of evil', questions how a benevolent deity could allow terrible things to happen to innocent people. Christians have developed various explanations and responses to address this fundamental challenge to their faith.
The problem of evil poses one of the most difficult questions in Christian theology: If God is both perfectly good and all-powerful, why does evil exist? This challenge has led to extensive theological debate and the development of various explanatory frameworks.
Biblical teachings about evil and suffering
The origins of evil
The Bible provides several explanations for how evil entered the world:
Genesis and the Fall: According to Christian teaching, God originally created a perfect world without suffering. However, the story of Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden explains how evil entered creation. When the first humans chose to disobey God by eating from the forbidden tree, this act of disobedience (known as 'the Fall') allowed sin and suffering to corrupt the previously perfect world.
The concept of the Fall is central to Christian understanding of evil. It explains why the world contains suffering despite being created by a perfect God - evil is not part of God's original design but entered through human choice.
The role of the devil: Christian theology teaches that evil also enters the world through the influence of the devil or Satan. This is illustrated in the Genesis account where the serpent (representing the devil) tempts Adam and Eve to disobey God's commands.
Jesus's mission: Christians believe that God sent Jesus Christ to Earth specifically to overcome evil and die for humanity's sins on the cross. This demonstrates God's love and provides a way for evil to ultimately be defeated.
Christian responses to evil and suffering
Finding comfort in scripture
The Book of Psalms: Many Christians turn to the Psalms during difficult times because they offer reassurance that God is present even in suffering. The Psalms acknowledge that evil and suffering exist, but they also affirm that these experiences serve a purpose in God's greater plan. A key verse that provides comfort is: "God is our refuge and our strength" (Psalm 46:1). This passage reminds believers that they can find protection and support in God during their darkest moments.
The Book of Job: This biblical book tells the story of Job, a righteous man who experienced tremendous suffering including physical illness and the loss of his family. Despite these terrible trials, Job maintained his faith in God.
Biblical Example: Job's Response to Suffering
The story of Job provides a powerful example of maintaining faith during extreme hardship:
- Job loses his wealth, his family, and his health
- His friends suggest he must have sinned to deserve such punishment
- Job maintains his innocence and continues to trust God
- The text states: "In all this, Job did not sin by charging God with wrongdoing" (Job 1:22)
- Job's example teaches that suffering doesn't mean God has abandoned believers
Job's example teaches Christians that suffering doesn't mean God has abandoned them, and that maintaining trust in God during difficult times is both possible and valuable.
Theological explanations
Free will: Many Christians argue that God deliberately gave humans the freedom to make their own choices, including the ability to choose between good and evil. This free will explains why humans sometimes commit evil acts - it's not because God wants evil to happen, but because genuine love and goodness can only exist when people have the freedom to choose otherwise. Some Christian thinkers, such as those influenced by St Augustine's teachings, use this concept to explain moral evil in the world.
The free will defence argues that moral evil exists because:
- God values human freedom above preventing all evil
- Genuine love and goodness require the possibility of choosing evil
- A world with free beings capable of good is better than a world of programmed robots
Vale of soul-making: This theological concept suggests that evil and suffering aren't pointless, but actually serve an important spiritual purpose. According to this view, experiencing difficulties can make people stronger and help them develop important qualities like compassion, resilience, and faith. Suffering might be unpleasant, but it can lead to spiritual growth and character development. However, this theory acknowledges that we don't always understand why certain events happen, particularly when suffering seems random or excessive.
Practical responses to suffering
Prayer: Many Christians respond to evil and suffering through prayer, believing that God will provide them with the strength they need to cope with life's challenges. Prayer serves multiple purposes - it allows believers to express their concerns to God, seek guidance during difficult decisions, and find comfort in the belief that God listens to their struggles. Christians often pray not just for their own problems, but also for others who are suffering.
Charitable action: Rather than simply accepting suffering as inevitable, many Christians feel called to actively help others who are experiencing hardship. This charitable response is inspired by Jesus's teachings about caring for those in need.
Practical Example: The Samaritans Organisation
Chad Varah's response to suffering demonstrates how Christian beliefs inspire action:
- Varah worked as a priest in London and witnessed community suffering
- He was particularly moved by cases of suicide and emotional distress
- He established the Samaritans organisation to provide support
- The Samaritans offer confidential listening services to people in crisis
- This shows how Christian compassion can create practical solutions to reduce suffering
The Samaritans provide support for people experiencing emotional distress, demonstrating how Christian beliefs can inspire practical action to reduce suffering.
Key Points to Remember:
-
The problem of evil challenges Christian belief - The existence of suffering creates theological difficulties for belief in an all-loving, all-powerful God
-
The Bible explains evil through the Fall - Genesis teaches that evil entered God's perfect creation when humans first disobeyed, and that Jesus came to overcome this evil
-
Scripture provides comfort during suffering - The Psalms and Job's story show that faith can be maintained even during terrible experiences
-
Free will explains moral evil - God gave humans genuine choice, which means they can choose to do wrong as well as right
-
Christians respond through prayer and charity - Believers both seek God's help through prayer and actively work to reduce others' suffering through charitable actions