Before You Were Mine (Scottish Highers English): Revision Notes
Before You Were Mine
Overview
This poem is addressed directly to Carol Ann Duffy's mother. Duffy responds to an old photograph and imagines the life her mother lived during the 1950s before she was born.
The poem is structured as an imagined conversation with the past, where Duffy reconstructs her mother's youth from visual evidence and family stories.
The tone throughout is nostalgic as Duffy pictures her mother's carefree youth. At the same time, the poem reflects on the sacrifices her mother made when she took on the responsibilities of parenthood. The poem explores themes of youth, love and happiness whilst examining the contrast between freedom and duty.
Form and structure
The poem consists of four stanzas, each containing five lines. Duffy writes in free verse without regular rhyme, which is characteristic of much of her poetry. This lack of formal structure creates an intimate, conversational tone, as though Duffy is speaking directly to her mother.
Free verse is poetry without regular rhyme or metre, allowing the poet to create a natural, speech-like rhythm that mirrors everyday conversation.
The poem ends by repeating its title, creating a cyclical effect. This frames the reflections and images explored in the earlier verses. Both the opening and closing present happy images of Duffy's mother, which leaves the reader with a lasting impression of her mother's joyous, youthful spirit whilst also creating a sense of completion.
Stanza one
The opening establishes an immediate sense of direct address through the personal pronouns in the first line. Duffy speaks "as if to her mother directly" using "I'm" and "you". Combined with the phrase "ten years away", Duffy creates a sense of temporal distance in both time and connection between herself and this younger version of her mother:
"I'm ten years away from the corner you laugh on / with your pals"
The word "corner" suggests her mother was at a turning point, standing on the edge of adulthood. This emphasises her youth, particularly when paired with the informal word "pals" in the second line.
Duffy presents a scene of independence and joyful, carefree friendship. Phrases such as "holding/each other" and "shriek at the pavement" convey the friends' physical closeness and uninhibited behaviour. The combination of "bend from the waist" and "shriek" reveals that the friends are overwhelmed with laughter. They are lost in the moment, unconcerned with appearances or social expectations.
This image of unrestrained joy contrasts with the glamorous picture that follows:
"Your polka-dot dress blows round your legs. Marilyn."
Analysis of Imagery and Structure
The "polka-dot dress" and reference to Marilyn Monroe establish the 1950s setting whilst painting a picture of Duffy's mother as a glamorous, beautiful woman. Marilyn Monroe was regarded at the time as a sex symbol, and this reference suggests the mother's freedom and sexuality.
The final minor sentence sounds authoritative and definite, directly comparing the mother to the Hollywood actress without qualification.
Minor sentence: a sentence without a main verb, used here for emphasis and impact.
Stanza two
Stanza two opens with the blunt statement "I'm not here yet". This sudden intrusion interrupts the glamorous imagery from stanza one. The image of parenthood remains like an unseen threat as Duffy returns to her mother's carefree youth and continues the Marilyn Monroe imagery:
"the fizzy, movie tomorrows"
This phrase captures the excitement of cinema and the happy, romantic endings typical of Hollywood films. The adjective "fizzy" suggests excitement, anticipation and champagne-like celebration. The phrase "the right walk home" in the following line hints at alternate futures that might follow a romantic encounter. This reference to walking home appears again in the final stanza, though with very different associations.
"The thousand eyes" of the ballroom are fixed on the mother. This image again conveys her beauty and magnetism. These eyes perhaps belong to potential romantic partners, men who the mother might choose to walk home with.
Duffy tells her mother, "I knew you would dance/like that", inviting the reader to imagine skilful, energetic dancing. This thought is interrupted by Duffy's repetition of the poem's title. The phrase "Before you were mine", the mention of her mother's mother (highlighting the life before Duffy's birth) and the threat of "a hiding for the late on" reveal the risks involved in the young woman's carefree lifestyle:
"You reckon its worth it."
This minor sentence suggests this rebellious young woman has weighed the risks and decided that freedom and fun outweigh the consequences. This image of the defiant, independent younger woman directly contrasts with the older version presented in stanza four.
Stanza three
A sense of regret enters Duffy's voice at the opening of stanza three. She describes her "loud, possessive yell" and acknowledges that her mother probably preferred life before having her.
"I remember my hands in those high-heeled red shoes, relics"
The description of "high-heeled red shoes" as "relics" suggests that Duffy recognises the glamour and excitement of her mother's life is behind her. These two lines place the responsibility for this loss at Duffy's feet. "Relics" are artefacts from historical figures, or even their remains, so the image carries a hint of death. This idea continues in the phrase "your ghost clatters towards me". There are still moments when Duffy can glimpse her mother as she once was, but the clumsy connotations of "clatters" reveal the awkward movements of an older woman. This contrasts starkly with the graceful dancer seen earlier.
"till I see you, clear as scent"
"Clear" could mean that Duffy has an unobstructed view and a better understanding of her mother. However, the word carries a double meaning. The simile "clear as scent" suggests transparency and intangibility. Like perfume in the air, there is a sense that Duffy's mother is present but cannot be seen or held.
Role Reversal
The question posed in the final line reverses roles:
"and whose small bites on your neck, sweetheart?"
This suggests that Duffy has taken the place of her grandmother, questioning what her daughter has been up to. The term "sweetheart" adds tenderness to this teasing enquiry whilst the "small bites" hint at romantic encounters.
Stanza four
"Cha cha cha!" gives a brief flash of the mother reliving her youth as she teaches dance steps on the way home from church:
"Cha cha cha! You'd teach me the steps on the way home from Mass"
However, this walk home contrasts sharply with the one in stanza two. The reference to "Mass" contrasts her mother's heady, carefree youth with the formal, religious Catholic upbringing Duffy is receiving.
There is irony as Duffy's mother now takes on the role of the "Ma" mentioned in stanza two. The mention of "the wrong pavement" tells us that this is not the life she wants.
"stamping stars from the wrong pavement."
The idea of stars in a pavement refers to the Hollywood walk of fame. However, the glamour of the movies now contrasts sharply with the mother's actual life. Duffy closes the poem with her own desires for her mother to be the girl she once was:
"I wanted the bold girl winking in Portobello, somewhere / in Scotland"
This tells us with nostalgic sadness how much she loves this girl she never knew. Although "I wanted" still hints at Duffy possessing her mother, it also expresses regret that her own existence took so much away from her.
Themes
Youth and happiness
Much of Duffy's poetry focuses on youth and happiness. This poem presents the mother as a happy, vibrant woman enjoying a carefree life. Duffy contrasts this with the more serious picture of her as an adult, clattering across George Square or walking home from Mass.
Whilst there are still glimpses of the younger woman, the overall impression is one of regret and sadness. The poem suggests that the duties of motherhood have robbed the mother of a different life. The contrast between the energetic dancer and the older woman teaching steps on the wrong pavement emphasises what has been lost.
Key Symbolic Element
The "relics" of the red shoes symbolise how youth and glamour have become objects from the past rather than lived experiences. The repeated references to laughter, dancing and freedom in the early stanzas highlight the vibrancy that motherhood appears to have diminished.
Love and nostalgia
The love shown in this poem is complex and unconventional. Rather than a straightforward mother-daughter relationship, Duffy expresses love for the idea of who her mother used to be. Whilst reflecting on this image of her as a younger woman, Duffy feels nostalgia for a version of her mother that she never knew.
This creates a complicated emotional response. Duffy also feels guilty for taking that freedom and joyous youth away from her mother, replacing it with her "loud, possessive yell". The possessive language throughout the poem reveals both Duffy's love and her awareness that this love came at a cost.
The nostalgic tone creates a bittersweet quality. Duffy longs for the "bold girl winking in Portobello" whilst recognising that her own existence made that girl disappear. This mixture of love, nostalgia and guilt runs throughout the poem.
Comparisons
Connecting to Other Duffy Poems
-
Originally pairs well with this poem because both deal with significant change and identity. Originally covers Duffy's move from Scotland to England, whilst Before You Were Mine explores the change in her mother's identity from glamorous youth to parent. Both poems question who we are after major life changes.
-
In Mrs Tilscher's Class shares a similar feeling of nostalgia for the simple, carefree days of youth. Both poems capture the feeling of being on the cusp of adulthood whilst still possessing the energy of youth. Both also express the eventual disappointment that adulthood brings.
-
Havisham, Mrs Midas and Medusa feature fictional and mythological characters, whilst Before You Were Mine focuses on a real person. However, since this presents Duffy's imagined version of her mother, she is in a sense creating her own mythical character who has no voice of her own.
All these poems carry a sense of loss and yearning for a happier past, when the women were young, desirable and followed their own desires. Each poem carries its own emotions - rage, jealousy, disappointment - but all express regret at the changes brought by relationships, time and ageing.
Remember!
Key Points to Remember:
-
The poem addresses Duffy's mother directly, imagining her glamorous life in the 1950s before Duffy was born.
-
The free verse structure creates an intimate, conversational tone, whilst the cyclical effect frames the reflection by returning to the title.
-
Key images contrast youth and motherhood: the polka-dot dress and Marilyn Monroe reference versus the "wrong pavement" and walk home from Mass.
-
The "high-heeled red shoes" described as "relics" symbolise how the glamour and freedom of youth have become objects from the past.
-
Duffy expresses both love and guilt - she adores the "bold girl" her mother once was whilst recognising that her own existence took that life away.