Analysis: Part 2 (Scottish Highers English): Revision Notes
Analysis: Part 2
Lines 99–155: The first encounter with the figure
The narrator's encounter with the figure in the wardrobe mirror happens at a specific time: 'I had just had a shower – it was four pm'. This detail grounds the supernatural event in everyday routine, making it more unsettling. The narrator finds the vision 'sickening' because it defies possibility. Fear paralyses them, preventing them from running even though they want to.
The specific time marker ('four pm') serves a crucial narrative function: it anchors the supernatural experience in mundane reality, making the impossible feel disturbingly concrete and immediate.
Physical description of Mal-something
The figure's appearance is described in unusual detail, which contrasts with the vague impressions that dominate earlier sections of the story. This shift to concrete observation suggests the encounter feels more real than the narrator's previous anxieties.
The man appears full of contradictions. He is 'skeletal' yet 'ruddy in the cheeks', suggesting both nearness to death and a strange vitality. His grey hair is described as 'the kind of grey hair people are born with', which creates a sense of temporal disorder. Grey hair typically signals ageing, but the narrator suggests this man was born with it. This could result from genetic factors, malnutrition, vitamin deficiencies, or severe stress. These possible causes encourage us to imagine the harsh conditions of his life.
The paradoxical description of Mal-something (skeletal yet vital, grey-haired from birth) creates a figure who exists outside normal temporal and physical categories. This contributes to the sense that he belongs to a different reality entirely.
The figure's movements also appear strange to the narrator, who attributes this to 'prolonged hunger' and 'lack of body fat'. The implication is that such physical appearances are unfamiliar in the narrator's modern world, where malnutrition is less visible in everyday life.
Communication barriers
When the narrator shows fear, the man speaks in Latin: 'Nolit timere', meaning 'do not be afraid'. The narrator only discovers this meaning later, after looking it up. This delay creates a 'broken rhythm' in their communication, limiting how much understanding can pass between them.
The narrator's fear is so intense that 'language fails them entirely'. They might even have 'barked like a dog' in response. All their rational explanations collapse, leaving only two possibilities: they are 'mad' or 'not mad'. Neither option brings comfort. Either they have lost their sanity, or they are experiencing something genuinely supernatural and inexplicable.
The collapse of language at this critical moment reveals how supernatural experiences can dismantle the systems we rely on to make sense of reality. The narrator is reduced to inarticulate sound, stripped of their primary tool for understanding and communication.
Modern life versus historical experience
After closing the bedroom door, the narrator returns to a routine filled with modern conveniences. They drink tropical fruit juice, use running water and indoor plumbing, and brush their teeth with 'usual' apparatus. These mundane activities would be completely alien to the man in the mirror, emphasising the vast distance between their worlds.
When the narrator re-enters the room, they feel slightly irritated by the visitor's concerned look, calling it the 'cheek' of it. This reaction reveals the complex emotions emerging between them: self-regard, concern, pity, and wonder.
The exchange of names
The two figures exchange names, though the narrator's remains unknown to us. The visitor's name comes across as 'Mal-something', capturing the incomplete recognition that characterises the whole story. The narrator would recognise the full name if they heard it again, though they feel certain this will never happen.
The partial name 'Mal-something' serves as both a narrative device and a thematic statement. It represents the fundamental incompleteness of historical knowledge – we can approach the past but never fully grasp it.
The partial name serves another purpose: it provides evidence that the experience is not imaginary. If the narrator had invented the encounter, their knowledge of history and fantasy literature would have supplied a complete, plausible name.
The narrator's initial questions about what Mal-something is doing in the mirror come across as 'interrogative', almost accusatory. They quickly adjust their tone to avoid being 'a knob' about it. This self-correction shows the narrator beginning to understand the strange balance of proximity and distance between them. Some things feel recognisable, while others remain utterly alien.
Mirroring and reflection
The 'shiver and quick breath' of Mal-something (lines 152-153) mirrors the narrator's own physical response to fear moments earlier (lines 114-115). This creates a literal reflection across the mirror. Similarly, the moment when Mal-something begins his story echoes the beginning of the narrator's own narrative. The fractured rhythm of their conversation continues, as the narrator must record Mal-something's words – delivered in 'a mixture of Scots and some Latin' – then painstakingly transcribe and translate them later.
Notice how the story creates multiple layers of mirroring: physical responses mirror each other, narrative structures parallel one another, and the mirror itself becomes both barrier and connection point. This technique reinforces the theme of reflection and self-understanding.
Lines 156–207: Mal-something's story
Mal-something's story is mostly relayed directly, though the narrator adds asides about the parts they could not understand and the sections requiring further research.
The plague and Scottish history
The location of Mal-something's village cannot be precisely identified. The narrator observes that 'You're never more than about forty miles from the sea in Scotland', meaning the story could take place anywhere in the country. This vagueness suggests the plague and mass death might be read as part of Scotland's entire national history, even though such events are not widely remembered or memorialised.
Mal-something understands his experience through both religious and material frameworks. He mentions 'God' but also describes physical realities: the bodies, the failed crops, his bleeding hands, the approaching winter. His description of death 'standing over the bodies with her long soft wings' causes the narrator to shiver once they translate it. This reaction may stem from uncertainty about how to interpret the image. Should it be understood literally? Is it metaphorical? What does it reveal about how death was conceptualised in that time and place, compared to the narrator's own era?
Social hierarchies and moral values
Mal-something is keen to explain that he has worked hard, has not been lazy, and 'didn't have any ideas about his station in life' just because he moved into the Laird's house after everyone died. The Laird was a landowner, and Mal-something's concern about appearing presumptuous reveals the strict social hierarchies of his society.
These moral codes are so deeply ingrained that they still control Mal-something's behaviour even when he is the sole survivor. No one remains to judge or punish him, yet he still feels bound by these rules. This shows how powerfully social values can shape individual consciousness, persisting even in the complete absence of social enforcement.
Education and literacy
Mal-something's backstory explains how he gained literacy despite being a peasant. He received brief education from monks, but even this relationship mixed high ideals with material transactions. Knowledge was presented as a virtue, but his family's debt to the monastery was 'paid in oats', grounding the arrangement in economic reality.
The 'angel of death' appears strange to both the narrator and modern readers. When Mal-something suggests he might have been spared death as a 'curse' for failing to commit to monastic life, the description reinforces how different his worldview is from ours.
He studies the Laird's books trying to understand why he survived. He feels certain he has sinned but cannot identify specific transgressions. This pattern of obsessive thought 'echoes the kinds of over-thinking our narrator has revealed of themselves' earlier in the story. The narrator observes: 'He was someone who thought a lot, it seemed.'
The parallel between Mal-something's obsessive self-examination and the narrator's own tendency to overthink creates another layer of mirroring. Both figures are trapped in cycles of anxious reflection, searching for meaning and certainty in their experiences.
Lines 208–268: The narrator's reflections and loneliness
The narrator considers how they would survive if placed in Mal-something's position, 'if everybody around me died'. They recognise their lack of 'practical' skills for survival in such circumstances.
The end of the visitation
A rare direct statement tells us the visitation will end: 'after the mirror had gone back to normal'. The narrator regrets they could not communicate 'in real time' without needing to record, transcribe, and translate everything. This regret extends to specific missed opportunities: learning more about Mal-something's family, telling him how his determination impressed them, expressing sympathy with his loneliness.
Loneliness as the central theme
The story's central theme is finally named explicitly: loneliness. The narrator offers a key definition: 'it's a stronger force than love, because it's a kind of love for everyone that is never returned'. Though loneliness is 'terrible', it possesses a kind of 'power'. Perhaps this power is strong enough to open a 'portal' across time.
The Central Theme Revealed
Loneliness is defined not as mere isolation, but as 'a kind of love for everyone that is never returned'. This paradoxical definition suggests that loneliness contains within it a reaching out, a desire for connection that becomes a force powerful enough to transcend time itself. The portal between past and present may be opened by this profound human need for recognition and understanding.
The narrator seems almost embarrassed by this explanation, comparing it to a 'conspiracy theory'. One appeal of conspiracy theories is that they make the world make sense, even in frightening ways. They provide explanations for suffering. Here, the narrator reaches for a profound explanation that also satisfies a personal need.
The narrator's self-perception
The narrator considers how unremarkable they believe themselves to be, how unlikely a hero they would make in a science fiction or fantasy story. However, knowing that this historical figure chose to visit them brings comfort. This suggests the encounter is helping the narrator find value in themselves.
Attempting connection
Both figures try to reach through the mirror towards one another but cannot make physical contact. The narrator speculates about the portal's mechanics, worrying that even if they could touch, their worlds are so different 'even down to the microbial level' that they might make each other sick. This scientific concern emphasises the distance between them.
What follows, however, shows how distance can be overcome through emotional connection. The encounter produces profound feelings of mutual recognition: 'a funny feeling in my heart'; 'I nursed that feeling'. These phrases suggest something precious has passed between them despite the impossibility of physical touch.
The contrast between physical impossibility and emotional connection is striking. While scientific reality prevents them from touching, emotional reality allows them to reach each other across centuries. The story suggests that some forms of human connection transcend physical limitations.
Understanding through observation
The narrator tries to understand what reflective surface Mal-something is looking into and how he came to look into it. They 'wonder a lot of things', want to invite him into their home, and study his face closely. They read meaning into his features: 'a good face, honest and thin. Lots of care written on it.'
They sit looking at one another for a long time. The portal's limits suggest that history remains ever-present but inaccessible. We cannot step through into it to know it first-hand. We are left only with speculations and ideas that mostly reflect something of ourselves.
The story's conclusion
As darkness falls on both sides of the mirror, they call out to one another. The narrator accounts for the memories they carry from this encounter. They state they do not usually have strong instincts about things, but felt certain they would not see Mal-something again: 'I don't usually get gut feelings about much, but I felt certain…'. This surety suggests a change in the narrator's character.
The story closes with the narrator imagining what Mal-something thought of them, hoping they brought him comfort. Through this strange meeting, the narrator has found something valuable in themselves, something that needed this encounter to emerge.
If loneliness is the key theme, the mirror is the key motif. The story ends with a potentially healthier form of self-reflection. Rather than the narrator's earlier anxious overthinking, they now reflect on their capacity to connect with and comfort another person across time.
Key Points to Remember:
-
The detailed description of Mal-something contrasts with the vague impressions dominating earlier parts of the story, marking a shift to concrete experience
-
Communication barriers (Latin, Scots, translation delays) create a 'broken rhythm' that limits understanding but does not prevent emotional connection
-
Mal-something's concern about social hierarchies reveals how deeply moral codes can shape consciousness, even when no one remains to enforce them
-
The central theme is loneliness, defined as 'a kind of love for everyone that is never returned' – yet it possesses power enough to create connection across time
-
The mirror serves as the key motif, representing both the barrier between the narrator and Mal-something and the possibility of healthier self-reflection by the story's end