Photo AI
1. (a) According to document A, what did the average SA man think about attendance at Nuremberg? (b) What has document B to say about the music at Nuremberg? (c) How is it shown in document A that attendance at Nuremberg ‘was no bed of roses’? (d) According to document B, what lighting technique was used within the stadium and what was its effect? 2 - Leaving Cert History - Question 1 - 2016
Question 1
1. (a) According to document A, what did the average SA man think about attendance at Nuremberg? (b) What has document B to say about the music at Nuremberg? (c) H... show full transcript
Worked Solution & Example Answer:1. (a) According to document A, what did the average SA man think about attendance at Nuremberg? (b) What has document B to say about the music at Nuremberg? (c) How is it shown in document A that attendance at Nuremberg ‘was no bed of roses’? (d) According to document B, what lighting technique was used within the stadium and what was its effect? 2 - Leaving Cert History - Question 1 - 2016
Step 1
According to document A, what did the average SA man think about attendance at Nuremberg?
Answer
According to document A, the average SA man thought that participation at Nuremberg was routine and significant. They felt a sense of duty to represent their comrades, reflecting a commitment to the cause despite the challenges faced during the event.
Step 2
What has document B to say about the music at Nuremberg?
Answer
Document B states that the music had an almost religious quality. It was timed to resonate with the emotional responses of the crowd, enhancing the atmosphere of the rally and contributing to the fervent experience of the attendees.
Step 3
How is it shown in document A that attendance at Nuremberg ‘was no bed of roses’?
Answer
Document A indicates that attendance at Nuremberg was demanding, as many participants were forced to march long distances, often in unfavorable conditions. The lengthy hours of parading underlines that it was a sacrifice, rather than a privilege, for the attendees.
Step 4
According to document B, what lighting technique was used within the stadium and what was its effect?
Answer
Document B describes the use of floodlighting at the rally, which illuminated the stadium and created a powerful visual impact. This technique emphasized the grandeur of the event while evoking an emotional response from the crowd.
Step 5
Do both documents agree that the appeal of Hitler’s personality was greater than the appeal of his ideas? Explain your answer, referring to both documents.
Answer
Yes, both documents agree that Hitler’s personality was more appealing than his ideas. Document A reflects a lack of enthusiasm for the ideology itself, while Document B highlights that the rally atmosphere was charged by Hitler's personal charisma.
Step 6
Do the writers of both documents wonder why a person like Hitler can command such admiration? Explain your answer, referring to both documents.
Answer
Both writers express some curiosity about Hitler’s ability to command admiration. Document A mentions a ‘fanatical devotion’ that Hitler inspired, while Document B notes that he was viewed as a superhuman figure, which raises questions about the nature of his appeal.
Step 7
Do you consider document A to be an objective source? Give reasons for your answer, referring to the documents.
Answer
Document A may not be entirely objective as it reflects a personal viewpoint of an individual who was part of the Nazi regime. It lacks a critical perspective on the events and the implications of the ideology. Conversely, Document B offers a broader observation of the rally, suggesting that it aims for a more comprehensive account.
Step 8
Which document gives the clearer idea of what happened at a Nuremberg Rally? Give reasons for your answer, referring to both documents.
Answer
Document B generally provides a clearer depiction of the events at a Nuremberg Rally. It describes the atmosphere, lighting, and crowd reactions more vividly, while Document A focuses more on the subjective experiences of the participants without encapsulating the event's broader context.
Step 9
What did the Nuremberg Rallies and/or Joseph Goebbels contribute to Nazi propaganda?
Answer
The Nuremberg Rallies, with the orchestration by figures like Joseph Goebbels, contributed significantly to Nazi propaganda by crafting a powerful image of unity and strength. They fostered a sense of belonging and enthusiasm among attendees, utilizing emotional appeals to solidify support for the regime.