Photo AI
To what extent would you agree that the political careers of Butt and Parnell ended in failure? - Leaving Cert History - Question 1 - 2015
Question 1
To what extent would you agree that the political careers of Butt and Parnell ended in failure?
Worked Solution & Example Answer:To what extent would you agree that the political careers of Butt and Parnell ended in failure? - Leaving Cert History - Question 1 - 2015
Step 1
Political Career of Butt
Answer
Isaac Butt was a prominent political figure who aimed to restore Ireland's self-governance. His career is often seen as a failure due to his inability to secure significant legislative changes. Although he founded the Home Rule League and raised awareness about Irish issues, he struggled with uniting various factions within the Irish nationalist movement, which hindered his effectiveness.
Step 2
Political Career of Parnell
Answer
Charles Stewart Parnell, on the other hand, was much more successful initially. He became a well-known leader who had substantial influence over Irish politics, advocating for Home Rule. However, his political career fell into disrepute due to personal scandal, which ultimately undermined his leadership. The split in the Irish Parliamentary Party after his death further contributed to the perception of failure in his political legacy.
Step 3
Comparison of Careers
Answer
When comparing the two, Butt's career can be seen as a foundation that Parnell built upon, showing some elements of success, but both careers faced significant challenges and controversies. This complexity suggests that while elements of their political endeavors achieved some recognition, the ultimate outcomes left both politicians facing significant setbacks.
Step 4
Conclusion
Answer
In conclusion, while aspects of Butt's and Parnell's careers were marked by initial success, the eventual failure in achieving their broader political objectives arguably characterizes their political journeys. Thus, one can agree to a considerable extent that their careers ended in failure, albeit with varying degrees of impact and legacy.