Escalation from 65-68, Tet Offensive, My Lai Massacre and Hearts and Minds Campaign

You could discuss LBJ and his approach to foreign policy in Vietnam in several ways. In these notes, we will discuss just three of them, perhaps the three most clear-cut of them all: the 'Hearts and Minds Campaign', the My Lai Massacre, and the Tet Offensive. All of these events helped shift public opinion against Johnson and fuel the Anti-War Movement that would follow (and will be discussed in the next notes).

Hearts and Minds Campaign

The Hearts and Minds Campaign was a strategic initiative aimed at winning the support of the South Vietnamese population during the Vietnam War. This approach was crucial for undermining the influence and recruitment efforts of the Viet Cong.

3 Key Points to note on the Campaign and its Impacts

• The campaign included civic action programs, such as building infrastructure like schools, hospitals, and roads to improve living conditions and earn the goodwill of the local population. Economic assistance efforts were made to boost the South Vietnamese economy through agricultural development, microloans, and other economic aid. Additionally, information campaigns sought to promote the benefits of the South Vietnamese government and the presence of U.S. forces, contrasting this with the harsh realities of communist rule.
• Despite these efforts, the campaign faced significant challenges. South Vietnamese government corruption often undermined these efforts, with resources being siphoned off or misallocated. Persistent Viet Cong activity made it difficult to secure rural areas, limiting the reach and effectiveness of the programs. Furthermore, the U.S. often misunderstood local customs and social dynamics, leading to ineffective or counterproductive initiatives.
• The limited success of the Hearts and Minds Campaign reflected poorly on President Lyndon B. Johnson's administration. It showcased the challenges of counterinsurgency warfare and the difficulty of achieving a political solution in Vietnam. Despite considerable investment, the campaign did not significantly weaken the Viet Cong's influence, leading to growing scepticism about the war's progress and strategy back in the U.S.

---

KEY MOMENT: Tet Offensive

The Tet Offensive, launched on January 30, 1968, was a major military campaign by the Viet Cong and North Vietnamese forces against South Vietnamese and U.S. positions. It was a turning point in the Vietnam War and if you are writing on LBJ in an essay at all, is a key moment to be able to discuss as it is from here when the tide turned against Johnson heavily.

Key Points to note on the Tet Offensive

• The offensive coincided with the Tet holiday, traditionally a period of truce, allowing the Viet Cong and NVA to exploit the element of surprise. Over 100 cities, towns, and military bases were attacked, including major cities such as Saigon, Hue, and Da Nang. The Viet Cong even breached the U.S. Embassy compound in Saigon, although they were quickly repelled. The city of Hue saw some of the fiercest fighting, with the North Vietnamese capturing large parts of the city and holding it for several weeks before being driven out by U.S. and South Vietnamese forces.
• From a purely military standpoint, the Tet Offensive was a failure for the Viet Cong and NVA. They suffered heavy casualties, with estimates of up to 40,000 fighters killed. The South Vietnamese and U.S. forces managed to repel the attacks and eventually regained control of all the captured areas. However, the high casualty rates and the destruction inflicted on the cities shocked both the U.S. military and the American public.
• The Tet Offensive had a profound psychological impact. It contradicted the optimistic reports from the U.S. government and military leaders about the progress of the war. Prior to Tet, General William Westmoreland and other officials had claimed that victory was within reach and that the Viet Cong were on the brink of collapse. The scale and intensity of the offensive starkly contradicted these claims, leading to what became known as the "credibility gap" – the growing divide between what the government reported and what the public believed.
• The Tet Offensive marked a turning point in U.S. involvement in Vietnam. The shock and disillusionment it caused among the American public led to increased anti-war sentiment and eroded support for the war effort. Prominent news anchor Walter Cronkite famously commented, "To say that we are mired in stalemate seems the only realistic, yet unsatisfactory, conclusion," reflecting a shift in media and public opinion. President Lyndon B. Johnson faced intense criticism and declining approval ratings following the offensive. Recognising the need for a change in strategy, Johnson announced a halt to the bombing of North Vietnam and a reduction in U.S. troop levels. He also decided not to seek re-election, signalling a shift towards de-escalation and peace negotiations.
• The Tet Offensive demonstrated the resilience and determination of the Viet Cong and NVA, highlighting the challenges of achieving a decisive military victory in Vietnam. It underscored the limits of U.S. military power and the complexity of the conflict, ultimately leading to a re-evaluation of U.S. strategy in Vietnam.

---

My Lai Massacre

The My Lai Massacre was one of the most horrific incidents of the Vietnam War, occurring on March 16, 1968, when U.S. Army soldiers killed hundreds of unarmed South Vietnamese civilians in the village of My Lai.

Key Points to Note on My Lai Massacre

• A company of American soldiers, led by Lieutenant William Calley, was conducting a search-and-destroy mission in My Lai. Believing the village to be a Viet Cong stronghold, the soldiers began killing men, women, children, and infants indiscriminately. Many of the victims were also sexually assaulted, mutilated, and tortured. Estimates of the death toll range from 347 to 504 civilians.
• Initial reports of the incident were downplayed or covered up by U.S. military officials. It was not until journalist Seymour Hersh broke the story in November 1969 that the full extent of the massacre became known to the American public. The revelation of the massacre and the subsequent cover-up attempt sparked widespread outrage and further fueled anti-war sentiment.
• The My Lai Massacre had a devastating impact on President Johnson's administration and U.S. policy in Vietnam. It severely damaged the moral credibility of the U.S. military and the government's justification for the war. Public outrage over the incident contributed to growing anti-war sentiment and increased pressure on Johnson to de-escalate the conflict. The massacre also highlighted the brutal realities of the war and the psychological toll it was taking on American soldiers, leading to increased scrutiny of military conduct and the rules of engagement in Vietnam.
• The My Lai Massacre led to significant changes in U.S. military policy and training. The incident underscored the need for stricter adherence to the laws of war and better training for soldiers in ethical conduct and the treatment of civilians. The massacre also played a role in shaping public opinion about the Vietnam War and contributed to the eventual withdrawal of U.S. forces from Vietnam. The trial and conviction of Lieutenant Calley, who was found guilty of murder, further highlighted the accountability issues within the military and the need for reforms.

---