Introduction to the Show Trials and General Background

Stalin's show trials are a key topic of Dictatorship and Democracy to study. They are not only a case study but are commonly asked about when D&D is an essay topic. The following few notes will provide context on the causes of the trials and describe the three main trials in detail.

---

Areas covered:

1. What is a Show Trial?
2. Causes of the Trials
3. The Assassination of Kirov - A Deep Dive
4. The Death of Stalin's Wife
5. Who were the NKVD?

What is a Show Trial?

A show trial is a highly publicised court proceeding in which the authorities predetermine the outcome. These trials are often used as propaganda tools to demonstrate the power of the state and intimidate the population. Defendants in show trials are typically forced to confess to crimes they may not have committed, often under duress or torture.

The trials aim to eliminate political rivals, instil fear, and justify harsh measures by presenting the accused as traitors or enemies of the state. During Stalin's era, show trials were a key component of the Great Purge.

Prelude and Causes of the Show Trials in Russia

• The show trials in the Soviet Union, particularly during the late 1930s, were a series of highly publicized trials where former Communist Party leaders and military officials were accused of treason and other crimes against the state. Joseph Stalin orchestrated these trials as part of his broader strategy to consolidate power and eliminate potential rivals. The causes of these trials were rooted in several key factors:
• After Lenin's death, Stalin's rise to power was marked by intense political manoeuvring and the elimination of rivals such as Leon Trotsky. By the mid-1930s, Stalin sought to consolidate his control over the Communist Party and the Soviet state further. The show trials served as a tool to remove any remaining opposition within the party and to instil fear and obedience among the populace.
• Stalin's regime was characterised by a pervasive atmosphere of paranoia and suspicion. The NKVD, the Soviet secret police, played a crucial role in monitoring and reporting any signs of dissent. Stalin's fear of conspiracies and plots against his rule led to a heightened sense of insecurity, which he addressed through purges and show trials.
• The rapid industrialisation and collectivisation policies of the 1930s caused significant social and economic upheaval. Resistance to collectivisation, particularly among peasants, and the hardships faced by the working class created unrest. Stalin used the show trials to divert attention from these issues, blaming "enemies of the state" for the difficulties and portraying himself as the protector of the Soviet people.

Assassination of Sergei Kirov

• A pivotal event leading up to the show trials was the assassination of Sergei Kirov on December 1, 1934. Kirov was a prominent Communist Party leader and the head of the party organization in Leningrad. He was considered a loyal supporter of Stalin, and his murder shocked the Soviet leadership.
• Kirov was assassinated at his office in the Smolny Institute by Leonid Nikolayev, a disgruntled party member. The circumstances surrounding the assassination remain controversial, with some historians suggesting that Stalin may have orchestrated or at least exploited the murder to justify a broader crackdown on dissent.
• In the immediate aftermath of Kirov's assassination, Stalin used the event as a pretext to initiate a massive purge of the Communist Party. He claimed that Kirov's murder was part of a larger conspiracy against the Soviet state. The NKVD arrested thousands of people, including many of Kirov's associates and other party members, on charges of participating in the supposed plot.
  • Kirov's assassination provided Stalin with a convenient justification for intensifying his campaign of repression. The murder was framed as evidence of widespread counter-revolutionary activity, enabling Stalin to eliminate perceived enemies within the party and the military. The show trials that followed were presented as efforts to root out these conspiracies and to protect the revolution.

• The assassination of Kirov marked the beginning of the Great Purge, during which hundreds of thousands of people were arrested, executed, or sent to labour camps. The show trials became a central feature of this purge, serving as a method to publicly demonstrate the supposed threat of internal enemies and to legitimize the regime's harsh measures.
• Kirov's death thus played a critical role in shaping the repressive policies of Stalin's government and in setting the stage for the show trials that followed.

The Suicide of Stalin's Wife and Its Impact on the Show Trials

The suicide of Nadezhda Alliluyeva, Joseph Stalin's second wife, on November 9, 1932, had profound personal and political repercussions. Nadezhda, deeply troubled by Stalin's policies, particularly the harshness of collectivisation and the resulting famine, was also unhappy in her marriage.

Her death, officially declared a result of illness but widely understood as suicide, had a significant impact on Stalin's psyche and the political landscape of the Soviet Union.

Personal Impact on Stalin

• Nadezhda's death left Stalin emotionally devastated and further fuelled his paranoia. The loss of his wife, combined with his existing insecurities and suspicions, likely exacerbated his distrust of those around him.
• It is believed that her suicide intensified Stalin's belief in conspiracies and plots against him, deepening his resolve to eliminate any potential threats to his power.

Political Ramifications

• The period following Nadezhda's death saw an increase in Stalin's repressive actions. Already committed to consolidating his control over the Communist Party and the state, Stalin became even more ruthless in his pursuit of absolute power.
• Her death contributed to the climate of fear and suspicion that characterised his regime.

Fuelling the Show Trials

• Nadezhda's suicide can be seen as a catalyst for the increased severity of Stalin's purges. Her death may have heightened his determination to root out perceived enemies, both real and imagined.
• The intensified atmosphere of paranoia and the desire to demonstrate control and strength led to the orchestrated show trials of the late 1930s.
• These trials targeted prominent Bolshevik leaders, military officers, and other high-ranking officials, accusing them of treason, espionage, and plotting against the Soviet state.
• The show trials served to eliminate Stalin's rivals and instil terror within the party and the general population, solidifying his dictatorial rule.

The NKVD: Stalin's Secret Police

• The NKVD (People's Commissariat for Internal Affairs) was the Soviet Union's secret police agency, playing a central role in Stalin's regime from 1934 to 1946. Formed from earlier security agencies like the Cheka and the OGPU, the NKVD was responsible for internal security, intelligence, and law enforcement. Under the leadership of figures such as Genrikh Yagoda, Nikolai Yezhov, and Lavrentiy Beria, the NKVD became notorious for its brutal methods.
• The NKVD's primary functions included conducting mass arrests, executing perceived enemies of the state, and managing the Gulag labour camps. They were instrumental in carrying out the Great Purge (1936-1938), during which hundreds of thousands of people, including party members, military leaders, and ordinary citizens, were arrested, tortured, and executed or sent to labour camps.
• The NKVD utilized extensive surveillance, informants, and torture to extract confessions and eliminate dissent. They orchestrated high-profile show trials to publicly justify the purges and instil fear among the populace. The agency also engaged in espionage and counter-intelligence activities, both domestically and internationally.
• The NKVD's actions under Stalin's rule contributed significantly to the climate of terror and repression in the Soviet Union. The agency's brutal tactics and widespread purges left a lasting legacy of fear and trauma, shaping the Soviet state's oppressive character for decades.