Theme or Issue (Leaving Cert English): Revision Notes
Major themes and issues
Elia Kazan's "On the Waterfront" explores profound moral and social questions through the story of Terry Malloy's transformation. The film presents several major themes that work together to create a powerful commentary on corruption, conscience, and the courage needed to stand up for what's right.
The major themes in "On the Waterfront" are interconnected and work together to create the film's powerful moral message: conscience and moral awakening, corruption and abuse of power, redemption and sacrifice, brotherhood, betrayal, and loyalty, the power of the individual, and lost potential and regret.
Conscience and moral awakening
The central theme of the film revolves around Terry Malloy's journey from moral passivity to active conscience. At the beginning of the story, Terry exists as someone who goes along with corruption without questioning it, but gradually awakens to his moral responsibilities as a human being.
Terry's transformation becomes clear through his relationship with Edie and the influence of Father Barry. His confession to Edie represents a pivotal moment: when he says "I was ratting on a bum, Edie, I'm glad what I done," we see him choosing justice over the twisted loyalty that previously governed his actions. This quote shows Terry recognising that his previous understanding of loyalty was misplaced.
Terry's Moral Transformation:
The turning point comes after Dugan's death, when Father Barry delivers his passionate speech: "The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing." This moment crystallises the film's belief that personal morality must be actively pursued, even in environments dominated by violence and intimidation.
Terry's moral awakening demonstrates that conscience can be activated and acted upon, even when surrounded by corruption. His journey from passive complicity to active moral courage serves as the film's central character arc and thematic foundation.
Corruption and the abuse of power
The film presents a devastating critique of how power can be systematically abused to exploit and control people. Johnny Friendly's control over the docks operates like a criminal organisation, where workers live in constant fear of losing their jobs or their lives if they dare to speak up.
The corruption shown in the film is not just individual but institutional. Johnny Friendly's declaration that "Everything moves in and out, we take our cut" reveals an exploitative system where those in power extract profit from the labour of others through intimidation and violence. This systematic exploitation keeps workers trapped in poverty and fear.
Institutional Failure and Moral Responsibility:
The film shows how corruption spreads through different levels of society. The police and courts prove ineffective against Johnny's operation, and even the church remains absent from the struggle until Father Barry decides to act. This portrayal suggests that speaking truth to power becomes a moral necessity when institutions fail to protect the vulnerable.
The dock workers' silence is not cowardice but survival, making Terry's eventual courage all the more significant. The film demonstrates how systemic corruption creates environments where moral action requires extraordinary personal risk.
Redemption and sacrifice
Terry's journey represents a powerful story of redemption achieved through truth-telling and personal sacrifice. The film suggests that redemption is possible for anyone willing to confront their past mistakes and take action to make things right.
At the story's beginning, Terry describes himself as a "bum" who helped kill a friend and wasted his potential. However, his transformation becomes complete when he stands against Johnny Friendly, declaring "I'm glad what I done" even after suffering brutal consequences. This repetition of the phrase shows how Terry's understanding of right action has completely changed.
The theme of sacrifice extends beyond Terry to other characters. Charley's death serves as a redemptive act - he finally chooses Terry over Johnny Friendly, sacrificing his life to protect his brother. This sacrifice demonstrates that moral courage often demands everything from those who practice it, but can restore personal dignity and meaning.
The Price and Reward of Moral Action:
The film suggests that while redemption through moral action may cost everything, it offers the possibility of reclaiming one's humanity and self-respect. Terry's physical beating represents the price of moral courage, but his walk into the warehouse symbolises triumph over the forces that once controlled him.
Brotherhood, betrayal, and loyalty
The film examines loyalty as a complex and potentially dangerous force. Terry initially remains silent due to his loyalty to Charley and the union, but this loyalty actually enables corruption and betrayal of the broader community.
Terry's relationship with Charley illustrates the painful conflicts that arise when personal loyalty clashes with moral responsibility. When Terry tells Charley "I coulda been a contender... I coulda been somebody," he reveals how Charley's loyalty to Johnny Friendly actually betrayed Terry's potential and dreams. This famous quote exposes how misplaced loyalty can destroy the very people it claims to protect.
True vs. False Loyalty:
The most significant conflict in the film is not between Terry and Johnny Friendly, but between competing definitions of loyalty - loyalty to corrupt systems versus loyalty to conscience and community. Authentic brotherhood requires truth and moral courage, not blind obedience to destructive systems.
Charley's betrayal of Terry by arranging the boxing match represents personal manipulation disguised as family care. The film demonstrates that Terry's decision to testify represents a higher form of loyalty - loyalty to justice and to the community of workers being exploited. Only by breaking destructive bonds of silence can genuine integrity and meaningful relationships emerge.
The power of the individual
One of the film's most inspiring themes centres on how individual courage can challenge and ultimately break cycles of oppression. Terry represents the ordinary person who discovers they have the power to resist systemic corruption.
Terry is not portrayed as a natural leader or heroic figure - he's an uneducated dock worker with a troubled past and limited options. Yet his decision to testify and "stand over here now" inspires others to reject Johnny Friendly's authority. This transformation shows how moral courage can be more powerful than physical strength or political position.
The Strength of Ordinary People:
The final scene, where Terry walks into the warehouse after being beaten nearly to death, serves as a triumphant symbol of resistance. Father Barry and Edie also demonstrate individual moral action by choosing to get involved rather than remaining passive observers. Their actions show that challenging corrupt systems requires truth and compassion rather than violence.
The film celebrates what it calls "the quiet strength of ordinary people" - the idea that regular individuals have the capacity to resist oppression and create change through moral courage and truth-telling.
Lost potential and regret
Terry's reflexion "I coulda been a contender. I coulda been somebody, instead of a bum" captures one of the film's most poignant themes about wasted human potential and the search for dignity in a system that offers little opportunity for growth.
The film suggests that corrupt systems deliberately waste people's talents and dreams, particularly those of the working class. Terry's past as a promising boxer represents a life that could have provided meaning and achievement, but was sacrificed to serve others' corrupt interests.
This theme connects to broader social critique about how economic and social systems can rob people of their agency and potential. Terry's past represents not just personal regret, but the systematic destruction of working-class dreams and aspirations.
Reclaiming Dignity Through Moral Action:
However, the film also suggests that reclaiming dignity is possible even after years of wasted potential. Terry's journey becomes one of discovering that he can still "be somebody" through moral action and truth-telling, even if his boxing career is over. His transformation shows that it's never too late to find purpose and meaning through ethical choices.
Key Points to Remember:
-
Moral awakening is possible: Terry's transformation from passive complicity to active conscience shows that people can change and choose to do right, even in corrupt environments.
-
Individual courage breaks systems of oppression: One person's decision to speak truth can inspire others and challenge powerful corrupt forces, as shown through Terry's testimony and its effects.
-
True loyalty serves justice, not corruption: The film distinguishes between loyalty that enables wrongdoing and loyalty that serves the broader good - authentic relationships require moral courage.
-
Redemption comes through sacrifice: Characters like Terry and Charley find meaning and dignity through sacrificing for moral principles, even when it costs them everything.
-
Lost potential can be reclaimed: While corrupt systems waste human potential, individuals can still find purpose and "be somebody" through ethical action and truth-telling, regardless of past mistakes.