Themes (Leaving Cert English): Revision Notes
Themes
The themes in Claire Keegan's Small Things Like These work together to create a powerful exploration of moral courage in the face of institutional power and community silence. Set during Christmas in 1985 Ireland, the novel examines how personal experiences of kindness shape our capacity for moral action, even when that action comes at great personal cost.
Family
Family serves as both the driving force behind Bill Furlong's decisions and the lens through which he understands love and responsibility. The theme reveals how genuine family bonds transcend traditional definitions and biological connections.
Bill's deep affection for his wife and five daughters fundamentally influences every choice he makes throughout the story. He refers to them using the Irish word "leanbh", meaning "child," which demonstrates the warmth and emotional depth of his connection to his family.
The term "leanbh" is an Irish word of endearment meaning "child." Keegan's use of this term reflects not just linguistic heritage but also the tender care Bill feels towards those he loves, emphasising the cultural and emotional depth of family bonds in the novel.
The partnership between Bill and his wife Eileen illustrates the collaborative nature of their family life. Eileen is portrayed as someone who "kept the house so well and minded everything", highlighting how their household functions through shared responsibility and mutual care. This domestic harmony provides the emotional foundation that sustains Bill throughout his moral crisis.
The central tension in the family theme emerges when Bill's loyalty to his family conflicts with his conscience. He understands that rescuing Sarah from the convent puts his family's future security at risk, particularly because "the nuns had power" over education and social standing in their community.
However, Bill's decision to bring Sarah into his home ultimately expands the definition of family beyond blood relations. This act of compassion mirrors the care once shown to his own mother, suggesting that true family relationships are built through kindness and protection rather than mere biological connection or social convention. His choice demonstrates that family can be created through acts of love and moral courage.
Hypocrisy
The theme of hypocrisy exposes the dangerous gap between public appearances and private realities, particularly within religious and community institutions. Keegan uses this theme to critique how moral authority can be used to mask cruelty and abuse.
The most shocking example of institutional hypocrisy comes through Bill's discovery of the disturbing truth about the convent. While the community reveres the nuns and their institution as morally pure and charitable, Bill learns that "the girl was locked in the coal shed". This brutal revelation stands in stark contrast to the Church's public image as a sanctuary of compassion and care, exposing the dark reality hidden behind religious authority.
Textual Evidence: Community Willful Ignorance
Keegan captures the community's moral cowardice through the observation that "People preferred to look away and move on," revealing how entire communities can become complicit in cruelty through their deliberate choice to remain silent and inactive.
Bill initially participates in this hypocrisy when he accepts payment from the Mother Superior and leaves without intervening. This moment represents his temporary surrender to social pressure and self-preservation. However, when he returns the envelope, it marks a crucial turning point where he rejects complicity. The simple but powerful action of going "back and knocked on the door" represents his quiet but determined rejection of the community's hypocritical silence.
The theme reveals that hypocrisy operates on both institutional and personal levels. Bill's internal struggle between self-preservation and moral truth demonstrates how individuals can become trapped between what they know is right and what society expects them to ignore. This personal dimension makes the theme more complex, showing how good people can become complicit in systems of harm through fear and social pressure.
Individual versus community
This theme explores the tension between personal moral conviction and community expectations, examining what happens when an individual's conscience conflicts with collective values of conformity and discretion.
Bill Furlong finds himself isolated in a town that prioritises conformity and social harmony over moral action. The community values discretion above justice, creating an environment where questioning authority or intervening in institutional practices is strongly discouraged.
Keegan captures this pressure through the haunting question that torments Bill: "The thing is, if you saw something wrong... was it your responsibility to do something?" This rhetorical question encapsulates the central moral dilemma that drives the entire narrative.
Despite this community pressure, Bill's individual character shines through small acts of natural kindness. His simple gestures—such as helping elderly customers or extending credit to those in need—reveal his instinctive goodness and moral sensitivity. These everyday actions create a sharp contrast with the community's larger moral blindness, highlighting how individual conscience can persist even within corrupt social systems.
The voice of community conformity finds expression through Bill's wife Eileen, who warns him: "You don't go interfering with the religious". Her fear demonstrates how deeply the Church's authority has become entrenched in the community's thinking, making resistance seem not just dangerous but almost unthinkable. This represents the way institutional power maintains itself through fear and social pressure.
Bill's choice to rescue Sarah despite the risks transforms him from a passive community member into an active moral agent, positioning him as what could be called a moral outlier. This decision demonstrates how individual courage can challenge corrupt systems even when it comes at great personal cost.
Ultimately, Bill chooses individual moral action over community acceptance, understanding that this decision positions him as a moral outsider. His choice highlights both the cost and the necessity of resisting social pressure when the majority becomes complicit in wrongdoing.
Care and kindness
The theme of care and kindness forms the moral foundation of the novel, showing how early experiences of compassion shape our capacity for moral action throughout our lives. This theme reveals that kindness creates ripple effects that can span generations.
Bill's own identity has been fundamentally shaped by the care he received as a child from Mrs. Wilson. He explicitly acknowledges that "had it not been for Mrs. Wilson... life might have been very different", recognising how her kindness literally changed the trajectory of his existence. This direct acknowledgement reveals his deep understanding of how transformative genuine care can be in a person's life.
The Power of Educational Care
Mrs. Wilson's belief that "everyone should have a vocabulary" speaks to her understanding that education and dignity should be available regardless of social background or circumstances. Her support provided Bill not only with practical stability but also with moral clarity about how people should treat one another.
The gardener Ned also contributed to Bill's emotional development through practical acts of affection. By bringing Bill to the river and teaching him useful skills, Ned showed how care can be expressed through action and attention. These moments, though they might seem small, created a foundation of emotional security that Bill carries throughout his adult life.
The Christmas setting amplifies these themes of care and generosity. Bill reflects that "Christmas can bring out the best or the worst in people", framing his decision to rescue Sarah not merely as compassionate action but as spiritually redemptive behaviour. The holiday context suggests that acts of rescue and protection carry deeper meaning during a season traditionally associated with hope and renewal.
Bill's final decision to take Sarah home represents the culmination of all the lessons about care and kindness he has absorbed throughout his life. This act demonstrates how receiving care creates an obligation to pass that care forward, even when doing so requires significant personal sacrifice.
Bill's choice shows that the kindness we receive becomes part of our moral responsibility to others, creating chains of compassion that can persist across time and circumstances.
Key Points to Remember:
-
Family is redefined through compassion: Bill's use of "leanbh" and his decision to rescue Sarah show that true family bonds are created through love and protection, not just biology.
-
Hypocrisy operates at multiple levels: The gap between the Church's moral reputation and the reality of abuse reveals how institutions can use moral authority to hide cruelty, while community silence makes everyone complicit.
-
Individual conscience can challenge corrupt systems: Bill's decision to act despite community pressure demonstrates that personal moral courage can resist collective complicity and social conformity.
-
Early kindness shapes lifelong moral capacity: Mrs. Wilson's care and Ned's affection provided Bill with the emotional foundation necessary to recognise suffering and respond with compassion as an adult.
-
Christmas amplifies moral choices: The holiday setting transforms Bill's rescue of Sarah into a spiritually significant act, suggesting that moments of moral crisis can become opportunities for redemption and renewal.