The Effects of Rules and Rule-Making Processes (Leaving Cert Politics and Society): Flashcards
Practise the cards
15 cards from this deck
ShowHide
Practise the cards
15 cards from this deck
Rule-making process definition
Rule-making process definition
How regulations are developed, debated & implemented in schools
Five groups in Irish school governance
Five groups in Irish school governance
Boards, principals, teachers, parents, students
Keogh & Whyte (2005) main finding
Keogh & Whyte (2005) main finding
Student councils have severely restricted influence
Issues students typically consulted on
Issues students typically consulted on
Minor admin: canteen food, fundraising
Major issues students excluded from
Major issues students excluded from
Discipline policies & curriculum content
Education Act 1998 on student boards
Education Act 1998 on student boards
Students explicitly excluded from boards of management
Effect of student exclusion from boards
Effect of student exclusion from boards
Creates fundamental democratic deficit
Ombudsman for Children (2017) report
Ombudsman for Children (2017) report
Students felt little real say; especially acute for minorities & SEN
Hart's Ladder (1992)
Hart's Ladder (1992)
Framework: tokenism to genuine decision-making power
Irish councils on Hart's Ladder
Irish councils on Hart's Ladder
Middle rungs: consulted but lack decisive influence
Lundy Model (2007)
Lundy Model (2007)
Distinction: having voice vs having influence
Locke's consent principle
Locke's consent principle
Authority legitimate only with consent of governed
Locke's govt work (year)
Locke's govt work (year)
Two Treatises of Government (1689)
Chomsky's manufactured consent
Chomsky's manufactured consent
Appearance of participation, decisions remain with elites
Balanced approach suggestion
Balanced approach suggestion
Adults: safety/legal; students: daily-life issues
