The Nature of Family Law (HSC SSCE Legal Studies): Revision Notes
The Nature of Family Law

The concept of family law
Family law is a comprehensive area of law that governs behaviour within family contexts. It addresses rights and responsibilities concerning children and the distribution of property when marriages end.
The primary function of family law is to ensure care and protection of family members. The law ensures that people in family relationships are financially secure and that children are properly cared for.
Family law takes a holistic approach to protecting all members of a family unit, with particular emphasis on vulnerable members such as children and dependent spouses.
Evolution of family structures
Traditionally, family relationships were based on marriage. However, modern Australian society reflects significant diversity in domestic arrangements, including:
- Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander (ATSI) customary marriages
- De facto relationships (partners acting as a married couple but not legally married)
- Same-sex relationships
- Single-parent families
- Blended families (created when a parent remarries, including stepparents and stepchildren)
- Extended families (including individuals related through marriage or parentage beyond the nuclear unit)
Family law continues to evolve to extend protection to members of all these alternative family structures.
Constitutional basis
Under s 51(xxi) of the Australian Constitution, the federal government has exclusive power to make laws governing marriage and divorce.
Key Commonwealth legislation includes:
- Marriage Act 1961 (Cth) – establishes legal requirements for valid marriages
- Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) – sets out legal duties and obligations created by marriage
This constitutional division means that while marriage and divorce are federal matters, most other aspects of family law (particularly child protection) are governed by state legislation.
Referral of powers
Previously, only state parliaments could legislate on de facto relationships. However, most states have now referred their powers to the Commonwealth through the referral of powers mechanism (pursuant to s 51(xxxvii) of the Constitution).
After the Family Law Amendment (De Facto Financial Matters and Other Measures) Act 2008 (Cth), matters concerning property division and spousal maintenance for de facto couples are determined under federal law.
Exceptions to Federal Jurisdiction:
- South Australia's state courts retain jurisdiction over de facto matters (as of 2010)
- Western Australia maintains a separate Family Court dealing with both federal and state family law issues
Philosophical approach
Family law emphasises reconciliation and compliance rather than sanctions or coercion. This reflects the law's focus on protecting family relationships and encouraging parties to meet their obligations voluntarily.
Legal requirements of marriage
Marriage is a legal institution with specific requirements and consequences. When two people marry, they make a promise before witnesses to provide and care for one another.
The legal definition of marriage
Australian legislation bases its definition on the English case Hyde v Hyde and Woodmansee (1866) LR 1 P&D 130.
Lord Penzance defined marriage as: "the voluntary union for life of one man and one woman, to the exclusion of all others"
This definition establishes marriage as a formal, monogamous and heterosexual union comprising three essential elements:
1. Voluntary entry
- Marriage must be freely entered into without force or deception
- If either party was forced or tricked, the marriage is not legally binding
Case Example: Di Mento v Visalli (1973) 1 ALR 352
A 14-year-old girl was kidnapped and later pressured by her father to marry her captor under threat of death.
Court's decision: The marriage was declared void due to duress.
Key principle: The court noted that coercion need not come from the spouse themselves – pressure from family members or third parties can also invalidate consent.
2. For life
- Marriage is intended to be permanent
- However, couples retain the right to divorce before death of either party
3. One man and one woman
- Parties must be of different sexes
- Polygamous marriages (having multiple spouses) are not recognised and are void if entered into in Australia
Requirements for a valid marriage
The Marriage Act 1961 (Cth) specifies several requirements:
Gender
In 2004, the Commonwealth Government added the definition of marriage to the Act through the Marriage Amendment Act:
- Section 5(1) defines marriage as "the union of a man and a woman to the exclusion of all others, voluntarily entered into for life"
- Section 88EA explicitly states that same-sex marriages solemnised in foreign countries are not recognised in Australia
Marriageable age
- Minimum age: years (s 11)
- Persons aged – may marry only with:
- A court order from a judge or magistrate (s 12)
- Granted only in "exceptional and unusual" circumstances
- Examples: parental consent, demonstrated maturity and financial independence
- Pregnancy alone is insufficient
- No person under can marry
Important Note on Age Requirements:
The law takes a strict approach to underage marriage to protect minors. Courts grant exceptions only in genuinely exceptional circumstances, and pregnancy by itself is explicitly deemed insufficient justification.
Prohibited relationships
Individuals cannot marry someone closely related by:
- Consanguinity (blood relations)
- Affinity (marriage relations)
Cannot marry:
- Descendants or ancestors (children, grandchildren, parents, grandparents)
- Siblings (including half-siblings and adopted siblings)
- Adopted descendants or ancestors
Can marry:
- Uncles/aunts, nieces/nephews
- First cousins
Notice of marriage
A Notice of Intended Marriage form must be given to an authorised celebrant (person authorised to perform civil or religious marriage ceremonies):
- No earlier than months before the marriage
- No later than month and day before the marriage
- Must be in writing and signed by both parties before a witness
Approved witnesses include:
- Marriage celebrants
- Justices of the peace
- Police officers
- Solicitors
- Doctors
Required documentation:
- Proof of age (usually birth certificate)
- If previously married: evidence that the marriage ended (death certificate or divorce papers)
Requirements for a valid marriage ceremony
The ceremony must satisfy conditions in Parts IV and V of the Marriage Act 1961 (Cth):
Essential requirements:
- Performed by an authorised marriage celebrant
- Two witnesses present, both aged over
- No formal requirements for attire, structure, or specific words
Australian marriage law takes a flexible approach to ceremony requirements, allowing couples to personalise their ceremonies while ensuring legal validity through the presence of an authorised celebrant and witnesses.
Marriage certificate:
- Issued by the celebrant after the ceremony
- Legal proof that the ceremony occurred according to law
- Three copies provided, signed by celebrant, spouses, and two witnesses
- One copy must be lodged at the state Registry of Births, Deaths and Marriages within days
Void marriages
A marriage can be declared void (invalid) through nullification or annulment (declaration that the marriage never legally existed) if:
It fails to meet the definition of marriage:
- Parties were of the same sex
- Consent was not freely given
- One or both parties were already married to someone else
It fails to meet statutory criteria:
- One or both parties were too young
- Parties are too closely related by blood or marriage
- The marriage did not meet requirements in the Marriage Act 1961 (Cth)
Important Note About Children:
Even if a marriage is annulled, any children born during the marriage are considered legitimate children of that relationship. The annulment does not affect the legal status or rights of children.
Legal consequences and responsibilities of marriage
Marriage creates legally binding mutual duties and obligations between spouses. The law intervenes primarily when marriages break down or when parties fail to fulfil their responsibilities.
Mutual duties of husband and wife
Spouses are mutually responsible to one another. While the law does not dictate how partners carry out their duties during a functioning marriage, general expectations include:
- Financial support
- Emotional support
- Fidelity (though no legal enforcement exists)
Legal clarifications:
- No law against adultery (no longer grounds for divorce)
- No automatic right to sexual relations (non-consensual sex is a crime regardless of marital status)
Maintenance
Maintenance is a financial payment made by one spouse to contribute to the care and welfare of the other spouse and/or children of the marriage.
Under s 72 of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), a spouse must provide maintenance if the other cannot support themselves due to:
- Having care and control of a child under years
- Being unable to work due to age or physical/mental incapacity
Key Principles of Maintenance:
- Maintenance is not automatic – it is based on demonstrated "need"
- The court considers multiple factors including:
- Income, property, and financial assets of the spouse seeking maintenance
- Capacity of the other spouse to pay
- Maintenance is usually sought after marriage ends
- Typically granted for a limited period until the recipient gains financial independence
- Both parties have a duty to maintain any children of the marriage
Property rights
Property ownership in marriage follows specific principles:
Marital home:
Couples can purchase property as:
- Joint tenants – equal shares; surviving spouse inherits entire property
- Tenants in common – unequal shares possible; shares can be left to others (e.g., children from previous relationships)
Individual property:
- Property purchased by one spouse during marriage remains that person's property
- Property owned before marriage continues to belong to that person after marriage
- Marriage does not automatically change property ownership
Common Misconception:
Many people believe that marriage automatically creates joint ownership of all property. This is not correct. Property purchased by one spouse or owned before marriage remains that person's individual property unless specifically transferred or jointly purchased.
Determining ownership:
However, upon marriage breakdown, the court considers:
- Length of marriage
- Financial contributions by each party
- Non-financial contributions (e.g., homemaking, childcare)
- Any improvements made to property
Contract and agency
Individual contracting:
- Marriage does not alter an individual's ability to enter contracts
- Spouses are not automatically authorised as agents for each other in contractual situations
Individual liability:
- Spouses cannot be held liable for each other's debts
- Debts in one person's sole name remain that person's responsibility
Court intervention:
- Only upon marriage breakdown can the court make orders altering property interests under Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) s 79
- Spouses can sue each other in contract or tort (s 119)
Wills
A will is a document stating how a person intends to distribute property after death.
Probate process:
- The executor must obtain a grant of probate (legal document certifying the will is valid)
- Probate authorises the executor to administer the estate (release monies and assets)
Intestacy:
When a person dies without a valid will (intestacy), state laws determine property distribution:
- Generally, the entire property goes to the surviving spouse (minus probate costs)
- If there are children, spouse and children may share the estate
- Other family members (parents, siblings) may inherit if no spouse exists
- In NSW, distribution follows a predetermined formula under the Succession Act 2006 (NSW) as amended by the Succession Amendment (Intestacy) Act 2009 (NSW)
Family Provision Orders:
The Succession Amendment (Family Provision) Act 2008 (NSW) amended s 58 of the Succession Act to allow certain family members to apply for a family provision order.
Eligible applicants include:
- Spouse or de facto spouse
- Child or grandchild
- Former spouse
- Person in a close personal relationship with the deceased
- Person dependent on the deceased
The Act encourages mediation rather than court contests to resolve disputes about estate distribution.
Effect of marriage on wills:
- Marriage automatically cancels any pre-existing will (unless made in anticipation of marriage) – Succession Act 2006 (NSW) s 12
- Divorce or annulment cancels provisions favouring the divorced spouse – Succession Act 2006 (NSW) s 13
Critical Planning Point:
If you marry, any will you made before the marriage becomes invalid unless it was specifically made "in contemplation of marriage." You must make a new will after marriage to ensure your wishes are followed.
Alternative family relationships
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples' customary law marriages
ATSI relationships are governed by traditions and enforced through customary law:
- Children may be betrothed at an early age
- Parents or elders typically arrange marriages
- Generally do not conform to Marriage Act 1961 (Cth) requirements
- Not legally recorded or registered
- Do not have formal legal standing under Australian law
Recognition efforts
The 1986 Australian Law Reform Commission report recommended that traditional ATSI marriages should be recognised to:
- Ensure legitimacy of children
- Provide child protection under adoption and welfare laws
- Protect inheritance rights of surviving spouses dying intestate
- Allow compensation claims (e.g., workers' compensation)
- Provide evidentiary protections in court proceedings
- Enable tax benefits equivalent to de facto or married couples
Federal government response (1995):
- Suggested most recommendations are more appropriate for state implementation
- However, ATSI children's circumstances are specifically addressed in federal legislation
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) Provisions:
Section 61F requires courts making parenting responsibility decisions to consider:
- Kinship obligations
- Child-rearing practices of the child's Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander culture
This ensures that cultural practices and connections are maintained when courts make decisions affecting ATSI children.
State recognition:
State parliaments have addressed some recommendations, including limited recognition of traditional marriages.
Child protection:
Children of ATSI relationships (whether traditional marriages or not) are protected under:
- Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)
- Status of Children Act 1996 (NSW)
If an ATSI customary marriage breaks down, the Family Court determines parenting orders based on:
- The "best interests" of the child
- The child's need to maintain connection with ATSI lifestyle, culture, and traditions
Single-parent families
Growth factors:
- Increased divorce rates
- Changing social attitudes
- Improved welfare state
- Greater financial independence of women
Statistics (2006-07):
- Australia had million families
- () were single-parent families
- One in five children live in single-parent families
- of single-parent families with children under were headed by women (2006)
Legal challenges
Single parents may face difficulties:
- Accessing legal advice
- Pursuing rights in court
- Obtaining adequate legal protection
- High costs may discourage court action
These challenges highlight the importance of accessible legal services and support systems for single-parent families who may have limited resources to navigate the legal system.
Child Support Scheme
Introduced in 1988 to enforce maintenance orders on non-resident parents:
Key features:
- Originally part of the Australian Taxation Office
- Now part of the Commonwealth Department of Human Services
- Automatically deducts payments from the supporting parent's wage
Legislation:
- Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) – shifted collection from courts to administrative system
- Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) – introduced formula for calculating child support
Blended families
A blended family is created when a parent remarries, combining:
- The parent and their children from a former marriage/relationship
- Another parent and their children in similar circumstances
- Stepmother/stepfather and stepchildren
Context:
- One-third of registered marriages in 2008 involved individuals marrying for the second time
- Many divorced couples choose to cohabit rather than remarry
Legal position of step-parents
Limited automatic rights:
Step-parents do not have the same legal responsibilities as biological parents:
No automatic rights to:
- Discipline the partner's child
- Make day-to-day decisions about health and welfare
- Financial maintenance or support of the partner's child
Financial obligations remain with the child's biological parents.
Common Misconception:
Many step-parents assume they automatically gain parental rights when they marry or cohabit with a parent. This is not the case. Step-parents have limited legal rights unless granted by court order.
Court-ordered support:
A court may order a step-parent to pay financial support if satisfied the step-parent has a duty to maintain the child (Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) ss 66D, 66M, 66N).
Circumstances creating financial responsibility:
- Long-term family relationship
- Natural parent is dead or cannot be found
Adoption by step-parents
Process:
- Apply to the Family Court (Family Law Act s 60G)
- Upon approval, apply to state Supreme Court for adoption order
Requirements in NSW (Adoption Act 2000 (NSW) s 30):
- Step-parent must have lived with the child and natural/adoptive parent for at least years
- Child must be at least years old
Effect of adoption:
Adopted children have the same legal rights as children born naturally into the relationship.
Inheritance rights
Stepchildren have no automatic claim to their step-parent's estate if the step-parent dies intestate.
To claim against the estate, stepchildren must prove:
- Financial dependence on the step-parent
- May apply for a family provision order under s 58 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW)
De facto relationships
Definition
Section 4AA of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) defines a de facto relationship as one where:
- Partners are not legally married to each other
- Neither is the parent, child, descendant, or sibling of the other
- They have a relationship as a couple living together on a genuine domestic basis
Statistics:
Over of couples who married (as of 2008) had lived together prior to marriage.
Legal framework
Following states referring powers to the federal government, the Family Law Amendment (De Facto Financial Matters and Other Measures) Act 2008 (Cth) governs:
- Property settlements for separating de facto couples
- Maintenance orders
Applicability:
- Couples whose relationship broke down on or after 1 March 2009
- Those whose relationship broke down earlier may choose federal law
- Matters relating to children heard in the Family Court
Same-sex relationships
State legislation
Property (Relationships) Act 1984 (NSW):
- Originally the De Facto Relationships Act 1984 (NSW)
- Amended and renamed by the Property (Relationships) Legislation Amendment Act 1999 (NSW)
- Recognises same-sex relationships as having the same legal standing as heterosexual de facto relationships
Section 4 definition:
A de facto relationship is "a relationship between two adult persons who live together as a couple, and who are not married to one another or related by family"
Application to succession law:
This definition applies to:
- Applications for family provision under Succession Act 2008 (NSW)
- Entitlements under intestacy laws (amended by Succession Amendment (Intestacy) Act 2009 (NSW))
Same-sex partners have the same entitlements as if married.
Property settlements:
Section 4AA(5) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) states that de facto relationships exist whether persons are of the same or different sexes. Therefore, federal law governs property settlements between separating same-sex couples.
Federal legislation
Evidence protection:
Under s 18 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) and NSW/Victorian Evidence Acts:
- A de facto partner (same-sex or opposite-sex) cannot be compelled to give evidence against their partner in certain criminal proceedings
- Note: Not all states have such provisions
2008 federal amendments:
In response to the Australian Human Rights Commission's report Same-Sex: Same Entitlements (2007), the federal government amended 84 Commonwealth Acts in 2008 to remove differential treatment of same-sex couples.
Areas covered:
- Tax
- Superannuation
- Medicare
- Aged care
- Veterans' entitlements
- Workers' compensation
- Employment entitlements
- Family law
- Child support
These reforms represented a significant shift toward equality for same-sex couples, ensuring they have the same rights and protections as heterosexual de facto couples in most areas of federal law.
Same-sex marriage
While same-sex couples now have most of the same rights as de facto heterosexual couples, same-sex marriage remains prohibited.
Attempted reform:
- Marriage Equality Amendment Bill 2009 introduced by the Greens
- Would have amended the Marriage Act 1961 (Cth) definition
- Defeated in the Senate in February 2010
Polygamous marriages
Definition:
A polygamous marriage involves an individual marrying more than one person simultaneously.
Australian position:
- Not legal in Australia
- Some cultures and religions permit polygamous marriages overseas
Limited recognition:
Under s 6 of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), polygamous marriages entered into overseas are deemed marriages for specific purposes:
Available remedies if relationship breaks down:
- Child maintenance orders
- Spousal maintenance orders
- Property division
- Parenting plans
- Domestic violence orders
This approach recognises the reality of such relationships while not endorsing polygamy domestically. It ensures that parties in polygamous marriages entered overseas have access to legal protections when relationships break down.
Legal rights and obligations of parents and children
Children are considered the most vulnerable family members and require the greatest legal protection. Their rights are paramount within family law.
Legislative framework
Federal law:
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) governs:
- Divorce or annulment proceedings
- Maintenance and property proceedings (married or separating parties)
- Part VII – proceedings relating to children, particularly parenting arrangements
State/territory law:
Most laws relating to care and protection of children operate at state/territory level.
Key NSW Acts concerning children:
| Legislation | Coverage |
|---|---|
| Adoption Act 2000 (NSW) | Adoption procedures; access to adoption information |
| Child Protection (Offenders Registration) Act 2000 (NSW) | Registration requirements for persons convicted of offences against children |
| Children (Criminal Proceedings) Act 1987 (NSW) | Criminal proceedings against children and young persons |
| Children (Protection and Parental Responsibility) Act 1997 (NSW) | Parental responsibility for children's behaviour; police powers regarding children |
| Children and Young Persons (Care and Protection) Act 1998 (NSW) | Responsibilities of Community Services and agencies regarding children at risk |
| Children's Court Act 1987 (NSW) | Establishment and jurisdiction of Children's Court of NSW |
| Status of Children Act 1996 (NSW) | Equal rights of ex-nuptial children; parentage establishment via DNA testing |
| Young Offenders Act 1997 (NSW) | Alternative procedures for child offenders (conferences, cautions, warnings) |
Child obligations:
Children must obey the law like adults, though enforcement procedures differ from adult legal mechanisms.
Parental care
Rights derived from international law
The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (CROC) protects children's rights:
- Adopted by the UN in 1989
- Ratified by all but two member states (as of March 2010)
- Declares persons under must be protected from violence, discrimination, exploitation, and neglect
Australia's Commitment:
- Ratified CROC in 1990
- Bound in international law to its terms
- CROC declared a "relevant international instrument" under Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth)
- Can be used by courts in interpreting statutes or developing common law
Implementation:
- CROC is not binding at domestic level (not enforceable in Australian courts)
- No federal legislation implements it directly
- Commonwealth left implementation to state governments' discretion
- Many CROC principles are embedded in state child protection legislation
Key CROC principles reflected in Australian law:
Article 3 – Best interests:
Children's best interests should be a primary consideration in decisions concerning them (reflected in federal and state legislation).
Article 12 – Right to be heard:
Children have the right to express opinions and be heard in proceedings affecting them, with views given weight according to age and maturity.
NSW Implementation: Children and Young Persons (Care and Protection) Act 1998 (NSW) s 10
The Act establishes the "principle of participation", which requires:
Information provision:
- Director-General must provide children with adequate information in understandable language
- Information about outcomes and reasons for decisions
Voice and participation:
- Opportunity to express views freely according to abilities
- Necessary assistance to express views
- Views will be recorded and considered
Response:
- Opportunity to respond to decisions
- Due regard to age and developmental capacity
This ensures children are active participants in decisions affecting their lives, not merely passive subjects.
Preamble – Cultural values:
Recognition of traditions and cultural values in child protection and development.
NSW implementation: Sections 11, 12, and 13 of the Children and Young Persons (Care and Protection) Act 1998 (NSW) specifically prescribe taking an Indigenous child's culture into account.
Article 2 – Protection from discrimination:
Children must be protected against discrimination based on parents' or family members' status, activities, or beliefs.
NSW implementation: Section 202 requires those providing children's services to have regard to the Anti-Discrimination Act 1977 (NSW).
Parental responsibility under the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)
Part VII objectives:
Ensure the best interests of children are met – the chief factor in making children's orders.
Best interests (s 60B) include:
- Benefits of meaningful involvement in their lives by both parents
- Protection from physical or psychological harm (abuse, neglect, violence)
- Adequate and proper parenting to help children achieve full potential
Underlying Principles (s 60B):
- Children have the right to know and be cared for by both parents
- Children have the right to spend time and communicate regularly with parents and significant others (e.g., grandparents)
- Parents share responsibilities for children's care and welfare
- Parents should agree about parenting matters
- Children have the right to enjoy their culture with others who share it
Legislative evolution:
- Family Law Reform Act 1995 (Cth) introduced emphasis on responsibilities shared equally by both parents
- Family Law Amendment (Shared Parental Responsibility) Act 2006 (Cth) further emphasised child's right to meaningful family relationships over parents' "rights"
Parenting plans:
Introduced by the Family Law Reform Act 1995 (Cth):
- Written agreements voluntarily agreed to by parents
- Can address any aspect of child's care and welfare:
- Living arrangements
- Time spent with each parent
- Educational, cultural, and religious needs
- Process for making changes or resolving disagreements
- If parents cannot agree, courts issue parenting orders (court-imposed decisions)
Parental responsibilities:
Not specifically defined in legislation, but include:
- Providing adequate food and shelter
- Providing access to education
- Consenting to medical treatment
- Providing discipline
- Protecting child from harm and illegal activities
- Ensuring child does not harm others
Consequences of parental neglect under state laws
Neglect is continued failure by a parent to provide basic needs for proper development (food, shelter, hygiene, medical/dental care, supervision, emotional security).
Criminal offences:
- Children and Young Persons (Care and Protection) Act 1998 (NSW) s 228 – fines up to $22{,}000
- Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) s 43A – imprisonment up to years
Community Services Intervention:
If suspected abuse or neglect is reported:
Investigation and support:
- Caseworker talks with parents and family members
- May provide practical help or counselling
Court intervention:
- May apply to Children's Court of NSW for orders:
- Supervision of family relationship
- Support services
- Transfer of parental responsibilities (e.g., foster care)
Foster care:
- Usually temporary
- Involves a couple taking parental responsibility for caring for and controlling the child
- Alternative: "group homes" under adult supervision (youth workers, child counsellors)
Tort liability:
Parents may be held liable in tort for damage or injury their child causes and forced to pay compensation (monetary payment to make amends for loss, injury, or property damage).
Related legislation:
- Children and Young Persons (Care and Protection) Act 1998 (NSW) – addresses family problems in terms of child's needs and care
- Children (Protection and Parental Responsibility) Act 1997 (NSW) – deals with prevention of juvenile crime
- Children (Criminal Proceedings) Act 1987 (NSW) – addresses criminal process for persons under
Education
The right to education is enshrined in:
- Education Act 1900 (NSW) (object of the Act)
- UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (CROC)
State duty:
The Education Act imposes on the state the duty to ensure every child receives adequate education.
Parental rights and duties:
- Parents cannot refuse their child an education
- Parents have the right to choose where their child is educated
Educational options:
- State school
- Approved non-government or private school
- Home education (with government consent)
- Distance education
All education must follow curricula approved by the state Board of Studies.
Criminal Offence:
Failure to enrol a child in a school or provide access to education is a criminal offence. Parents must ensure their children receive proper education.
Compulsory education in NSW:
- Attendance required from age until minimum school-leaving age
- Minimum school-leaving age: years or completion of Year 10
- 2009 changes to Education Act 1900 (NSW): Every young person who has completed Year 10 must be in education, training, or employment until age
Discipline
Parents have the right to discipline children using physical force to correct behaviour, but force must be "reasonable, having regard to the age, health, maturity or other characteristics of the child, the nature of the alleged misbehaviour or other circumstances" (Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) s 61AA).
Defence of "lawful correction":
Not available in criminal proceedings for assault (criminal offence involving infliction or threat of physical force) if physical force was not reasonable.
Unreasonable Punishment:
The following are considered unreasonable and may result in criminal charges:
- Striking the head or neck
- Causing pain lasting more than a short period
- Shaking a young child
- Striking with a closed fist
Cultural variation:
What is considered reasonable and acceptable discipline varies across cultures, but Australian courts apply consistent standards.
Medical treatment
Parents are responsible for ensuring appropriate medical and dental care for minor children. However, consent must be given before treatment.
Consent requirements:
Consent implies understanding of the procedure and acceptance of risks.
Age-based consent framework (Minors (Property and Contracts) Act 1970 (NSW) s 49):
- Under 14: Parent or guardian consent required
- 14–16: Either child's consent OR parent's consent required
- 16–17: Young person's consent required
Parental Refusal:
If parents refuse medical or dental treatment (e.g., on religious grounds), a court can authorise treatment to protect the child's health and wellbeing.
Intellectually Disabled Children Over 16:
If the child cannot understand the problem and treatment, the Guardianship Act 1987 (NSW) specifies who can give consent (usually a "person responsible" such as a parent).
Autonomy of children
Autonomy refers to freedom of the will, self-government, and the ability to act without outside interference.
Children are considered to lack:
- Fully developed cognitive abilities
- Capacity to understand consequences of actions
- Ability to make fully informed decisions
To protect children, the law prohibits certain activities. A child's legal capacity changes as they mature.
Age distinctions:
Some laws distinguish between:
- Children – persons under years (Children and Young Persons (Care and Protection) Act 1987 (NSW))
- Young persons – persons aged or older but under years
Legal autonomy by area:
| Area | Legal position |
|---|---|
| Alcohol and cigarettes | Illegal for persons under to purchase, possess, or consume |
| Arrest | Police can only question children in presence of an adult (parent/guardian) |
| Civil law | Children can be sued for damage/injury caused; parents may be held responsible |
| Contracts | Child can only enter contracts if an adult acts as guarantor; must benefit the child |
| Criminal responsibility | Under : not criminally responsible (presumed incapable of understanding right from wrong) –: prosecution must prove child understood act was illegal +: considered responsible for criminal actions |
| Driving | Learner's permit at ; probationary licence at |
| Employment | No minimum age in NSW; those under leaving school for full-time work need Department of Education approval; those completing Year 10 but under must enrol in training/education or undertake apprenticeship |
| Evidence | Can give evidence at any age if they understand the nature and consequences of oath/affirmation |
| Leaving home | No minimum age in NSW; persons over will not normally be forced to return if they have safe accommodation and can support themselves |
| Marriage | Under : cannot marry –: can marry only with court permission in exceptional circumstances |
| Sexual intercourse | Legal age for consensual sex is ; offence to have sexual intercourse with child under |
Ex-nuptial children
Historical position:
Ex-nuptial children (born outside marriage) had no legal status and therefore no legal rights.
Legitimacy:
Legitimacy provides children with rights including inheritance and maintenance.
Traditional automatic legitimacy existed for children:
- Born during marriage (nuptial children)
- Ex-nuptial but whose parents later married
- Adopted
Legal Reform:
- Children (Equality of Status) Act 1976 (NSW) – later replaced by Status of Children Act 1996 (NSW)
- Gave ex-nuptial children the same rights as children born to married parents
- Subsequent Acts reinforced this status
- All children have the right to be cared for by their parents
Establishing parentage:
The Act allows:
- Certain presumptions about a child's parentage
- Evidence to disprove presumptions
- Parentage establishment through DNA analysis of blood sample
- Voluntary recognition of the child by the parent
Succession rights:
- Family Provision Act 1982 (NSW) removed the concept of "illegitimacy"
- Succession Act 2006 (NSW) permits any child to apply for a family provision order (whether nuptial or ex-nuptial)
- A testator (person making a will) wanting to exclude children must explicitly state this (e.g., by listing only children intended to inherit)
Adoption
Adoption is the legal process of transferring parental rights and responsibilities from biological parents to adoptive parents.
The aim is to ensure the best and most appropriate parents are found for the child. The needs of adults are secondary to the child's needs. Adoption recreates the legal relationship between child and parents.
Legal requirements and process
Adoption is a state responsibility. In NSW, governed by the Adoption Act 2000 (NSW).
Consent requirements
Birth parents' consent:
- If married or in de facto relationship: both parents must consent
- Single mother: only mother need consent (father must be notified with days to respond)
- Children aged over : must consent to their own adoption
- Birth mother cannot consent within days of child's birth
- 30-day cooling-off period after consent during which parents can change their minds
When Parents Cannot Consent:
If parents cannot be found or are incapable of giving informed consent, the court can give consent.
Relinquishing Parents' Nominations:
Relinquishing parents (parents who nominate their child for adoption) can nominate a relative to adopt, but:
- All adoption criteria must be met
- Adoption can only proceed if court permits
- Parents can nominate desired religious upbringing
Requirements for adoptive parents
Strict guidelines reflect the law's focus on children's rights:
Eligible applicants:
- Married couples
- Long-term, stable de facto relationships (at least years, including same-sex couples)
- Single individuals (no distinction between heterosexual and homosexual applicants)
Age requirements:
- Applicants must be over years but under years
- Prospective male parent must be at least years older than child
- Prospective female parent must be at least years older than child
Character requirements:
- Person of good repute
- Fit and proper parent
- Able to fulfil responsibilities of good and caring parent
Cultural Considerations:
Where applicable, the following are considered:
- Child's culture, language, and religion
- Principle that child's given name, identity, language, and cultural/religious ties should be preserved as far as possible
This is particularly important for children from Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander backgrounds or other cultural minorities.
Selection process:
After meeting criteria, prospective parents are placed on a waiting list. Decision based on:
- Best interests of the child
- Whether child's overall welfare will improve
Legal effects of adoption
Once birth parents agree and the court makes an adoption order:
New birth certificate:
- Registrar of Births, Deaths and Marriages issues new certificate in adopted name
- Includes family details of adoptive family (names, dates of birth of adoptive parents and their other children)
Transfer of rights and obligations:
- Birth parents no longer have any rights or obligations concerning child
- Adopting parents have legal responsibility for care and well-being
- Child is legally their child
Inheritance rights:
- Adopted child's rights of inheritance from biological parents are removed (unless specifically mentioned in a will)
- Adopted child has automatic right to inherit from adoptive parents' estate
Overseas adoptions
Increasing numbers of Australian couples apply to adopt children born overseas.
Governing framework:
- Hague Convention on the Protection of Children and Cooperation in Respect of Intercountry Adoption
- Bilateral agreements with countries that have not ratified the Convention
Process in NSW:
Step 1: Apply through Community Services for intercountry adoption
Step 2: Allocated a child from the other country
Step 3: If parents accept, lodge adoption visa application
Step 4: Forwarded to appropriate overseas welfare agency
Step 5: Child subject to standard migration medical checks
Step 6: If health requirements satisfied:
- Either adoption finalised overseas in child's country of origin, OR
- Overseas welfare agency authorises child to leave so adoption can occur in Australia
Step 7: Child granted permanent residence in Australia
Privately arranged adoption:
Possible if adoptive parents prove:
- Living in overseas country for more than months prior to application
- Authorities in overseas country approved child's departure
Immigration requirements:
- Australian Department of Immigration and Citizenship can refuse entry visa
- Child must meet migration standards
Access to information
Historical position:
Previously, personal information of parents and children could only be released by the Reunion and Information Register, and only if both parties placed information on the register.
Current framework (Adoption Act 2000 (NSW)):
Relinquishing parents and adopted children have the right to request personal identifying information from Community Services to contact one another and other family members.
Adopted children over 18:
May apply to Community Services for a "supply authority" containing:
- Identifying information of birth parents
- Allows access to further information from adoption records
Relinquishing parents:
Can ask for "supply authority" allowing them to obtain:
- Copy of child's amended birth certificate (prepared after adoption)
- Information about adoptive family
Contact Veto:
Parents and children who do not wish to be contacted can lodge a "contact veto".
Advance Notice Register:
Contact details can be placed on register, which notifies parties if any application for information is made.
Information Release Despite Veto:
Even with a contact veto, information will be released once the party seeking information signs an undertaking not to make contact.
Penalties:
Breaching a contact veto may result in fine and/or imprisonment.
Reunion and Information Register:
Both relinquishing parents and adopted children wanting to make contact can enter their names.
Remember!
Key Concepts:
- Family law governs behaviour within family contexts, focusing on care and protection of members, especially children
- The federal government has exclusive constitutional power over marriage and divorce (s 51(xxi)), while most child protection laws are state-based
- Family law emphasises reconciliation and compliance over sanctions
Marriage Requirements:
- Defined as "voluntary union for life of one man and one woman, to the exclusion of all others" (Hyde v Hyde and Woodmansee)
- Valid marriage requires: different-sex parties, minimum age (or – with court order), no prohibited relationships, proper notice given
- Void marriages can be annulled if they fail to meet legal requirements or the definition of marriage
Legal Consequences of Marriage:
- Creates mutual duties and obligations between spouses
- Maintenance may be required if one spouse cannot support themselves
- Property ownership not automatically changed by marriage; only altered by court order upon breakdown
- Marriage automatically cancels pre-existing wills (unless made in anticipation of marriage)
Alternative Family Relationships:
- Include ATSI customary marriages, single-parent families, blended families, de facto relationships, same-sex relationships
- De facto and same-sex relationships now have most of the same legal protections as marriage for property and maintenance purposes
- Polygamous marriages not legal in Australia but limited recognition for marriages entered overseas
Parental Rights and Obligations:
- Best interests of the child are paramount in all decisions
- Parents share responsibility for children's care, welfare, and financial support
- Parental responsibilities include providing food, shelter, education, medical care, discipline, and protection
- Neglect of parental duties can result in criminal prosecution and/or removal of children
Children's Rights and Autonomy:
- Protected by UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (though not directly binding domestically)
- Have right to participate in decisions affecting them according to age and maturity
- Legal capacity increases with age across various areas (education, medical treatment, contracts, criminal responsibility)
- Ex-nuptial children have the same legal rights as nuptial children
Adoption:
- Transfers parental rights from biological to adoptive parents
- Strict requirements focus on best interests of child
- Both birth parents and adopted children (over ) have rights to access identifying information
- Overseas adoptions governed by international conventions and bilateral agreements
Divorce:
- Only ground is irretrievable breakdown of marriage (evidenced by months separation)
- No-fault system removes need to prove wrongdoing
- Family Court established to hear all marriage and divorce matters