Themes (AQA A-Level English Literature A): Revision Notes
Themes
Themes represent the fundamental and universal ideas that run throughout a literary work. In The Awakening, Kate Chopin explores several interconnected themes that reflect the constraints faced by women in late 19th-century American society and the psychological consequences of seeking personal freedom within an oppressive social structure.
Isolation
The theme of isolation is central to understanding Edna Pontellier's journey throughout the novel. For Edna, the concepts of independence and isolation become increasingly intertwined and ultimately inseparable.
Social constraints on Victorian women
Women in the late 1800s faced severe restrictions on their ability to express themselves as individuals. The expectations of tradition, combined with legal limitations, meant that Victorian women had very few opportunities for genuine independence or self-expression.
Society expected women to focus entirely on domestic duties and ensure the health and happiness of their families, leaving little room for personal fulfilment. This created an environment where personal ambitions and self-expression were systematically suppressed.
Edna's discovery of independence
When Edna first experiences moments of independence, she discovers her own inner strength. Through her pursuit of painting, she rediscovers the pleasure of individual creation and personal achievement. This awakening represents a profound shift in her self-perception. However, as Edna begins to articulate her feelings of independence, she encounters significant resistance from the various constraints that govern her life.
The limits of independence
The most notable opposition to Edna's independence comes from her husband, Léonce, who represents the societal expectations that weigh upon her active life. When Edna makes the decisive choice to abandon her former lifestyle, she comes to a difficult realisation: independent ideas cannot always translate into a simultaneously self-sufficient and socially acceptable existence.
The gap between her inner desires and outer reality proves impossible to bridge. This fundamental incompatibility becomes the central tragedy of Edna's awakening, as she discovers that Victorian society offers no viable path for a woman seeking both autonomy and social acceptance.
Robert and the failure of connection
Robert's feelings for Edna, whilst genuine, are not strong enough to enable him to join her in a true union of minds. Although his passion is intense enough to make him feel torn between his love and his sense of moral rectitude, it ultimately lacks the strength necessary for him to choose his love over societal convention.
The note Robert leaves for Edna makes clear that she is ultimately alone in her awakening. When Robert refuses to transgress the boundaries of societal convention, Edna must acknowledge the profound depth of her solitude.
Exam tip: Consider how Chopin uses isolation to critique the limited options available to women who sought self-actualisation in the 19th century.
Identity
Edna's awakening centres on her discovery of ways to express her authentic self, a journey that involves learning new forms of communication and self-expression that Victorian society had denied her.
Learning new languages of expression
During her awakening, Edna learns at least three new 'languages' that allow her to articulate her previously repressed emotions.
The first language she encounters comes from the Creole women on Grand Isle. Despite their chastity, these women speak freely and share their emotions openly, which initially shocks Edna. However, she soon finds this frankness liberating.
Observing her Creole friends teaches Edna that it is acceptable to speak and think about one's own feelings. Through this exposure, she begins to acknowledge, name, define and articulate her emotions in ways she never had before. This represents the first crucial step in her journey toward self-expression.
Expression through art
Edna also discovers expression through art, particularly in Chapter 9 when she hears Mademoiselle Reisz perform on the piano. Previously, music had merely called up pleasant images in her mind, but Mademoiselle Reisz's playing stirs her in a much deeper way. She experiences no mental pictures, only solitude, hope, longing, and despair washing over her. The music no longer provides passive entertainment but becomes a powerful call to something within herself.
The waves beat upon her splendid body, representing both the overwhelming nature of these new emotions and their connection to her physical being. As the music stops conjuring external images, it becomes instead a call to her inner self. Mademoiselle Reisz recognises their connection, noting Edna's agitation and observing that Edna is the only one at the party who is worth playing for.
Once Edna becomes aware of music's power to express emotion, she begins to paint as she has never painted before. Painting ceases to be merely a diversion and becomes instead a genuine form of self-expression. This transformation marks a critical evolution in her awakening.
The language of love and passion
From Robert and Alcée, Edna learns how to express the love and passion she has kept secret for so long. Through her interactions with them, she finds the vocabulary with which to articulate her needs and desires, enabling her to better define them for herself.
A pattern emerges: Edna can learn a language from a person but then surpass her teacher's use of that newfound form of expression. For instance, whilst Adèle teaches her that two people can be open with one another, Edna soon wants to apply this frankness to all areas of her life. Similarly, although Robert helps teach her the language of sexuality, she wants to speak this language loudly and openly, whilst Robert still feels social pressure to whisper it.
The tragedy of incomprehension
As Edna's ability to express herself develops, the number of people who can understand her newfound languages paradoxically shrinks. Ultimately, Edna's suicide is linked to a scarcity of people who can truly understand and empathise with her perspective.
After Robert's rejection of her in Chapter 38, Edna is convinced definitively of her essential solitude because the language of convention Robert speaks has become incomprehensible to her. Although Robert has taught her the language of sexuality, Edna has become too fluent in it.
Trapped in this dilemma, Edna mirrors the parrot in Chapter 1, which speaks French and a little Spanish but also a language which nobody understood, unless it was the mockingbird. The mockingbird, which merely whistles inarticulate fluty notes with maddening persistence, resembles Edna's friends who seem to understand her but do not speak back.
Exam tip: Analyse how Chopin uses the metaphor of language-learning to represent Edna's journey towards self-understanding and the tragic impossibility of being fully understood by others.
Depression
Throughout the novel, Edna experiences an unspecified sense of malaise and despondency whose precise source she cannot identify or articulate.
The trap of limited roles
It becomes apparent that Edna feels trapped, forced into the narrowly defined roles society affords to women in her era.
The pursuit of self-fulfillment and self-realisation she craves only leads to further isolation, which exacerbates her depression rather than alleviating it. This creates a vicious cycle: the more she seeks personal satisfaction, the more separate she becomes from the world around her.
The impossibility of reconciliation
By the novel's end, Edna has discovered that the role she desires—that of wife and independent woman—is fundamentally incongruous with the world's expectations and conventions. Society offers no space for a woman who wishes to maintain both her marriage and her autonomy.
This realisation of the impossibility of reconciling her inner needs with outer demands culminates in her suicide, representing the ultimate consequence of a society that offers women no viable path to authentic self-expression.
Exam tip: Consider how Chopin presents depression not as a personal failing but as a reasonable response to impossible social circumstances.
Marriage
The Awakening portrays marriage as a trap and a false promise of happiness for women who are unwilling to sacrifice their identities entirely.
Marriage as accident rather than choice
In Chapter 7, the narrator describes Edna's marriage to Léonce as purely accidental, indicating that she was thrown together with him by circumstance rather than genuine affection or careful choice. The narrator mentions Edna falling for various men before she meets Léonce, but at no point does she consider the implications of being a wife—that is, of building a household with someone and having children.
In this sense, Edna desires love, but because society inexorably ties love to marriage, falling in love saddles her with a lifestyle she has not fully bargained for. This reflects the broader theme of women's lack of agency in choosing their life paths.
The illusion of contentment
As Edna becomes conscious of herself as an individual, she begins seeing Adèle, who is happy in her marriage, as living in blind contentment. Adèle appears happy only because she doesn't know to ask for more, lacking the awareness that might lead her to question her circumstances.
Marriage and the erasure of women's identities
The marriages within The Awakening depict wives who must subvert their identities and desires in favour of their husbands' needs and ambitions.
When Edna refuses to take visitors, Léonce's first concern is not that she may have snubbed one of his business associate's wives out of personal choice or need. Instead, Edna taking visitors is not meant to offer her a social outlet or opportunity for social advancement. Rather, it functions as an extension of Léonce's business interests.
The ideal wife as self-effacing
This pattern continues in Adèle's marriage to Monsieur Ratignolle, whom Creole society considers the ideal couple. Although the narrator states that Adèle and her husband are two halves of a whole, Adèle hangs on Monsieur Ratignolle's every word, supporting his ideas instead of contributing her own thoughts.
When Monsieur Ratignolle attends Edna's party on behalf of both himself and Adèle, this demonstrates that his presence is necessary whilst Adèle's presence is not. Therefore, although their marriage may appear happy, it is a happiness dependent on Adèle shrinking herself, living for her husband and children without consideration of her own needs as an individual.
Exam tip: Examine how Chopin presents marriage not as a partnership of equals but as an institution that requires women to sacrifice their autonomy and identity.
Remember!
-
Isolation and independence are inseparable for Edna: her pursuit of autonomy inevitably leads to increasing loneliness as society offers no acceptable space for an independent married woman.
-
Identity requires expression: Edna's awakening involves learning new 'languages' through which to articulate her feelings, but tragically, fewer people can understand her as she becomes more fluent in self-expression.
-
Depression stems from impossible choices: Edna's melancholy arises from the realisation that society offers women no viable path to reconcile personal fulfilment with social acceptability.
-
Marriage functions as entrapment: Chopin portrays marriage not as a source of happiness but as an institution requiring women to subvert their identities in favour of their husbands' needs and society's expectations.
-
The novel's tragedy lies in incompatibility: the fundamental conflict is between Edna's awakened sense of self and a society that has no place for such a woman, making her suicide the inevitable conclusion of an impossible situation.