Context & Writer's Techniques (AQA A-Level English Literature A): Revision Notes
Context & Writer's Techniques
Context
Victorian England (1840s)
When Emily Brontë published Wuthering Heights in 1847, it emerged during the early Victorian period but challenged the literary and social conventions of the time in radical ways. Victorian readers expected novels to provide clear moral guidance, realistic portrayals of domestic life, emotionally restrained characters, and heroines who embodied angelic passivity. Brontë's novel broke sharply with all of these expectations.
The novel was considered shocking by contemporary readers for several key reasons:
- The depiction of violent, uncontrolled passion between characters
- Its ambiguous morality that refused to clearly label characters as purely good or evil
- The absence of didactic moral closure that would teach readers a clear lesson
- Its complex, multi-layered narrative structure
Why this matters: By challenging Victorian norms so boldly, Wuthering Heights became a precursor to modernist psychological fiction. The novel prioritises internal emotional truth over conventional morality, placing it ahead of its time.
Yorkshire Moors — real landscape, symbolic power
Emily Brontë spent almost her entire life living on the Haworth moors in Yorkshire, and this landscape profoundly shaped the novel. The moors directly influence several aspects of Wuthering Heights:
- The wild, untamed quality of the setting mirrors the passionate nature of the characters
- The geographical isolation of Wuthering Heights reflects the emotional and social isolation of its inhabitants
- The bleakness and intensity of the moorland landscape creates an atmosphere of emotional extremity
Function in the novel: The moors serve as more than mere backdrop. They reflect the emotional extremes experienced by characters and blur the boundaries between the human and natural worlds. The landscape becomes almost a character itself, representing freedom, wildness, and the untamed aspects of human nature that civilised society tries to suppress.
Gender & the Brontë sisters' publishing context
Emily Brontë, like her sisters Charlotte and Anne, initially published her work under a male pseudonym: Ellis Bell. This choice was strategic and necessary for several reasons:
- To avoid gender prejudice in the male-dominated literary world
- To prevent dismissal of her writing as 'unfeminine'
- To escape Victorian expectations of female modesty that would have made her bold content even more scandalous
Function: Understanding this publishing context helps explain the novel's radical treatment of female desire, violent emotion, and social rebellion. Writing under a male name gave Brontë the freedom to explore themes and depict behaviours that would have been considered doubly shocking coming from a female author. Catherine Earnshaw's passionate nature and the novel's frank treatment of female sexuality were revolutionary for their time.
Gothic tradition
Wuthering Heights draws heavily on Gothic literary conventions, incorporating elements such as:
- Storms, darkness, and supernatural moments that create an ominous atmosphere
- Ghosts, particularly Catherine's apparition at the window
- Confinement and imprisonment, both literal and psychological
- Tyrannical characters like Hindley and Heathcliff who wield cruel power
Function: These Gothic elements create an atmosphere saturated with mystery, violence, and psychological extremity. The Gothic mode allows Brontë to explore the darker recesses of human emotion and the potential for cruelty within domestic spaces. It transforms Wuthering Heights itself into a Gothic prison where destructive passions play out across generations.
Social class & inheritance law
Victorian class tensions feature prominently throughout the novel, shaping relationships and determining characters' fates:
- Heathcliff's ambiguous origin as a foundling creates uncertainty about his social status
- The contrasting values of the Earnshaws and the Lintons reflect different class perspectives
- Inheritance systems that favoured male heirs drive much of the plot's conflict and Heathcliff's revenge
Function: Class distinctions determine who has power, who can marry whom, and how characters relate to one another. The rigid class structure becomes a form of oppression that Heathcliff both suffers from and later perpetuates. The novel exposes how social class creates cycles of revenge and cruelty.
Romanticism & Byronic influence
Wuthering Heights is deeply influenced by the Romantic literary movement, which emphasised certain key values:
- Emotional intensity and the expression of powerful feelings
- Rebellion against societal constraints
- Sublime landscapes that reflect inner states
Heathcliff embodies the classic Byronic hero: a dark, passionate, and self-destructive figure who fascinates despite his cruelty.
Function: These Romantic ideals fuel the novel's intense focus on emotion and internal psychological states. The Romantic celebration of feeling over reason explains why characters like Heathcliff and Catherine act in ways that defy social convention and even self-preservation. Their love becomes an absolute, consuming force.
Religion & morality
The novel presents a critique of extreme religious attitudes through various characters:
- Joseph's rigid Calvinism represents religious fanaticism
- Nelly's moralising tendency to judge characters
- Cathy and Heathcliff's rejection of Christian norms in favour of their own emotional truth
Function: Rather than endorsing a single moral framework, the novel presents conflicting moral perspectives without clearly favouring one. This moral ambiguity was deeply unsettling to Victorian readers who expected literature to provide clear ethical guidance. The novel suggests that conventional religious morality may be inadequate for understanding the depths of human passion and suffering.
Writer's techniques
Framed narrative structure (nested storytelling)
One of the novel's most distinctive features is its complex narrative structure, which layers multiple storytellers:
- Primary narrator: Mr Lockwood, an outsider who comes to Yorkshire
- Main internal narrator: Nelly Dean, the housekeeper who witnessed most events
- Occasional voices: Zillah, Isabella Linton, Cathy Linton, Heathcliff, and others contribute shorter accounts
Effects of this technique:
- Creates distance and bias, ensuring there is no single, objective truth
- Encourages readers to interpret competing versions of events and question what they're told
- Adds complexity and ambiguity to the story, requiring active engagement from readers
This nested storytelling approach is central to Brontë's method. By filtering the story through multiple perspectives, she ensures that readers must work to uncover emotional truths and psychological motivations rather than being told them directly.
Unreliable narrators
Both Mr Lockwood and Nelly Dean are unreliable narrators, though in different ways, and both are biased, sometimes mistaken, and personally involved in the events they describe.
Lockwood's unreliability:
- He is naïve and socially awkward, frequently misreading people and situations
- He initially romanticises Heathcliff, failing to see his true nature
Nelly's unreliability:
- Her account is influenced by her own loyalties and moral judgements
- She often withholds or filters information based on what she thinks is appropriate
- She has her own stake in events and is not a neutral observer
Function: The use of unreliable narrators makes readers work to uncover emotional truths and psychological motivations. We must read between the lines, question what we're being told, and recognise that every account is shaped by the teller's biases and limitations. This technique creates a more psychologically realistic and morally complex novel.
Non-linear, multi-generational structure
The story spans two generations and unfolds in a non-linear fashion, moving back and forth in time. The narrative mirrors repeating patterns of:
- Revenge passed from one generation to the next
- Oppression that cycles through different characters
- Love and reconciliation that offer the possibility of breaking destructive patterns
Function: This structure reveals the cyclical nature of violence and suffering, showing how trauma and cruelty can echo through time. However, it also demonstrates the possibility of renewal, as the younger generation (young Cathy and Hareton) manages to escape the destructive patterns that trapped their parents.
Gothic imagery and atmosphere
Brontë employs specific Gothic techniques to heighten the novel's intensity:
- Storms that symbolise emotional turmoil and inner chaos
- The haunting presence of Catherine, whose ghost appears at Lockwood's window
- Eerie isolation of both Wuthering Heights and Thrushcross Grange
- Violent scenes such as Heathcliff's grief after Catherine's death and Hindley's abuse of his son
Function: These Gothic elements heighten the emotional intensity of the narrative and blur the boundaries between rational and supernatural, between external reality and internal psychological state. The Gothic atmosphere suggests that powerful emotions can warp reality itself.
Symbolism of setting (Heights vs Grange)
The two main houses in the novel represent opposing value systems and ways of life:
Wuthering Heights:
- Wild and untamed
- Stormy and exposed to the elements
- Primitive and rough
- Associated with passionate, uncontrolled emotion
Thrushcross Grange:
- Civilised and refined
- Elegant and protected
- Orderly and socially conventional
- Represents respectability and restraint
Function: This symbolic opposition represents broader conflicts in the novel: chaos versus order, passion versus reason, nature versus culture. Characters must navigate between these two worlds, and their choices reveal their values and identities. Neither location is presented as entirely positive or negative, reflecting the novel's complex moral perspective.
Character pairing and doubling
Brontë uses foils and doubles throughout the novel to explore different aspects of key themes:
- Heathcliff & Edgar: Passion versus refinement, representing two different models of masculinity
- Catherine Earnshaw & Catherine Linton: Two paths of female experience across generations
- Hareton & Heathcliff: The abused child who becomes either a renewed man or a vengeful destroyer
- Isabella & Edgar: Siblings damaged by different forces within the same family
Function: These pairings reinforce the novel's cyclical structure and highlight contrasts between characters. They allow Brontë to explore how similar situations can produce different outcomes, and how patterns can either repeat or be broken. The doubling suggests that character and fate are shaped by both inherent nature and external circumstances.
Nature imagery (romantic sublime)
Natural imagery in the novel serves as a mirror for emotional states and character psychology:
- The moors represent freedom, wildness, and the authentic self
- Wind, trees, and storms reflect psychological intensity and inner turmoil
- The landscape becomes an extension of character, particularly for Catherine and Heathcliff
Function: Characters' identities merge with the natural setting, especially in the cases of Catherine and Heathcliff, who both express their deepest selves through connection with the moors. Nature offers an alternative to civilised society's constraints, representing a space where true feeling can exist without social judgement. This use of nature reflects Romantic ideas about the sublime power of the natural world.
Supernatural elements (ambiguous, not fantasy)
The novel includes supernatural moments, but these are presented ambiguously rather than as clear fantasy:
- Catherine's ghost appearing at the window to Lockwood
- Heathcliff's post-death haunting and his apparent communication with Catherine
- Lockwood's dream-like experiences at Wuthering Heights
Function: These supernatural elements explore the possibility that love can transcend physical boundaries and death itself. However, Brontë keeps these moments ambiguous—they could be supernatural events, or they could be products of grief, desire, or disturbed psychological states. This ambiguity makes the novel more unsettling and psychologically complex than straightforward Gothic fantasy would be.
Violence as narrative technique
Brontë uses both physical and emotional violence as a central narrative tool:
- Violence reveals character, showing who people truly are under pressure
- It dramatises passion, making abstract emotions tangible and visible
- It critiques social power systems, exposing the cruelty inherent in structures of domination
Violence in Wuthering Heights is not gratuitous or merely sensational. Instead, it is central to the novel's moral and emotional world. The violence emerges from thwarted desires, social injustices, and the psychological damage characters inflict on one another. It forces readers to confront the destructive potential of both love and hate.
Language & dialogue
Different characters speak in distinctly different ways, reflecting their social position, personality, and worldview:
- Heathcliff's speech: Raw, intense, and expressive, revealing his passionate nature
- Catherine's: Contradictory and imaginative, showing her divided self
- Edgar's: Soft and refined, indicating his genteel upbringing
- Joseph's: Dialect-heavy and difficult, marking his local Yorkshire roots and religious rigidity
Function: Language becomes a marker of class, personality, and values. The way characters speak tells us who they are and how they see the world. Joseph's thick dialect, for instance, makes him almost incomprehensible to outsiders like Lockwood, symbolising the cultural gap between local Yorkshire folk and educated southerners.
Emotional extremity & psychological depth
Brontë anticipates the development of psychological fiction by focusing intensely on characters' inner lives:
- Interior monologues that reveal private thoughts and feelings
- Depictions of obsession, grief, and identity dissolution that go beyond surface behaviour
- Emotional contradictions that make characters psychologically complex rather than simply good or evil
Function: This approach creates a novel driven more by psyche than by plot. Events matter primarily for how they affect characters internally. Catherine's famous declaration "I am Heathcliff" represents an extreme of psychological merger that goes beyond conventional notions of romantic love. The novel explores how identity, desire, and consciousness work in ways that Victorian literature rarely attempted.
Remember!
Key Takeaways:
-
Victorian rebellion: Wuthering Heights shocked its original readers by breaking with expectations of moral clarity, emotional restraint, and conventional heroines. This makes it a precursor to modernist psychological fiction.
-
Narrative complexity: The framed structure with unreliable narrators (Lockwood and Nelly) ensures there is no single truth. Readers must actively interpret competing versions of events and read between the lines.
-
Symbolic landscape: The Yorkshire moors and the contrast between Wuthering Heights (wild, passionate) and Thrushcross Grange (civilised, refined) represent fundamental conflicts between nature and culture, passion and reason.
-
Gothic + Romantic: The novel combines Gothic elements (ghosts, storms, tyrannical figures) with Romantic ideals (emotional intensity, sublime nature, the Byronic hero) to create its unique atmosphere and psychological depth.
-
Cyclical structure: The multi-generational, non-linear narrative shows how violence and trauma cycle through time, but also how patterns can be broken by the younger generation, offering hope for renewal.