Themes (AQA A-Level English Literature A): Revision Notes
Themes
Tennessee Williams' Cat on a Hot Tin Roof explores several interconnected themes that drive the dramatic tension and character development throughout the play. Understanding these themes is essential for analysing how Williams critiques 1950s American society and examines the human condition. The central themes work together to create a complex portrait of a dysfunctional Southern family struggling with truth, identity and mortality.
Delusion and artifice
The theme of self-deception and false appearances permeates the entire play, affecting each main character in distinct ways. Williams demonstrates how individuals construct elaborate facades to avoid confronting painful truths about themselves and their relationships.
This theme operates as the foundation for much of the play's conflict. Each character's delusion serves a specific psychological purpose, protecting them from truths they find unbearable. Williams uses these layers of deception to critique the artificiality of 1950s Southern society.
Brick's self-deception: Brick refuses to acknowledge the true nature of his friendship with Skipper, denying any homosexual element existed between them. He uses this delusion to avoid confronting his own sexuality and culpability in Skipper's death. Through alcohol, Brick attempts to numb himself and maintain his detachment from reality.
Big Daddy's elaborate lies: Big Daddy has immersed himself in delusion throughout his entire life. He deceives himself about his marriage to Big Mama, his relationship with his sons Gooper and Mae, and most critically, about not having cancer. Despite physical pain that contradicts the doctor's false diagnosis, Big Daddy chooses to believe he will live for many years. He wants Big Mama to continue living rather than preparing for his death, yet he simultaneously accuses her of being eager to control the estate after his passing. This demonstrates the unreliability of his perspective and judgement.
Gooper and Mae's pretence: These characters present a carefully constructed facade of devotion to Big Daddy. However, their true motivation is securing the family estate and inheritance. Their performance of family loyalty masks their resentment toward Brick and Maggie and their mercenary attitude toward Big Daddy's impending death.
Maggie's complexity: Maggie emerges as perhaps the most honest character, though she too engages in artifice. She attempts to maintain the appearance of a happy marriage whilst knowing the family recognises their troubles. However, Maggie demonstrates greater self-awareness than other characters. She openly acknowledges her ambition for the inheritance and doesn't conceal this fact. She tries to accomplish her goals directly, showing her hatred of Gooper and Mae openly. In a moment of dramatic irony at the play's end, Maggie uses dishonesty and artifice strategically by pretending to be pregnant. This lie succeeds in manipulating the situation to her advantage.
The denial of death: A primary motivation for the characters' self-deception involves avoiding the reality of mortality. Big Daddy accepts a false medical diagnosis to escape confronting death. Brick numbs himself with alcohol to avoid the pain of Skipper's death and his own guilt. Maggie, raised in poverty, seeks to inherit the estate to protect herself from future hardship and the ultimate pain of death. These denials create a foundation for much of the play's conflict.
Lack of communication
Poor communication serves as the method through which characters maintain their delusions and avoid confronting uncomfortable truths. Williams illustrates how the absence of honest dialogue perpetuates suffering and prevents resolution.
Communication—or the lack thereof—functions as the mechanism that allows delusion to persist. When characters refuse to speak honestly, they enable each other's self-deceptions and prevent any possibility of genuine connection or resolution.
Brick's avoidance strategies: Brick actively blocks meaningful conversation with Maggie by getting drunk, creating a barrier between them. Throughout the play, he repeatedly attempts to terminate conversations with Big Daddy to prevent his father from uncovering painful truths about his relationship with Skipper and his sexuality. This refusal to engage in honest dialogue hurts both Maggie and Big Daddy whilst allowing Brick to maintain his self-deception.
Gooper and Mae's indirect communication: These characters fear openly expressing their dislike of Brick and Maggie. Consequently, they resort to indirect methods, reporting disparaging information they overhear about the couple to Big Mama. They regularly grimace and make subtle jabs at each other, often without achieving their desired effect. This passive-aggressive communication style maintains the artifice of family harmony whilst expressing their true feelings.
Big Mama's facade: Big Mama conceals her genuine hurt feelings by adopting a frivolous and foolish manner. She uses cheerful, superficial communication as a protective screen to hide her pain from others and perhaps from herself.
Big Daddy's accumulated lies: Big Daddy reveals to Brick the burden of dishonesty he has carried throughout his life, stating: Think of all the lies I got to put up with! Eventually, Big Daddy becomes exhausted by the constant deception and desires direct, honest communication with his son Brick. However, when father and son attempt genuine dialogue, other family members—particularly Mae and Big Mama—constantly interrupt them, preventing the honest conversation Big Daddy desperately seeks.
Homophobia
Homophobia functions as the fundamental cause of the play's central conflict, influencing the development of the entire dramatic work. Brick's internalised homophobia represents a permanent and immovable condition within the play. He suffers from this internalised prejudice consistently throughout the action, and this psychological state never changes.
Williams' Critical Insight
Tennessee Williams wrote that the moral paralysis of Brick was a root thing in his tragedy. This statement reveals the centrality of homophobia to the entire play. Because Brick cannot transcend his internalised homophobia, he becomes paralysed and unable to take any affirmative action toward resolving the conflicts in his life. This theme's constant presence motivates the behaviour of all other characters.
Without this theme driving the action, the entire dramatic structure would collapse. The play's conflict exists precisely because of Brick's inability to accept or even acknowledge his feelings for Skipper.
Impact on Maggie's situation: Maggie fears not inheriting the estate because she lacks children by Brick. If Brick had accepted being heterosexual whilst also feeling affection for Skipper, he would likely maintain a healthier relationship with Maggie, and they would probably have children. Maggie's fear and ambition would be relieved, fundamentally changing her character's motivation.
Impact on Big Daddy's concerns: Big Daddy worries about Brick's drinking and would gladly leave his estate to his favourite son if Brick could function properly. Gooper and Mae would recognise they had no chance of persuading Big Daddy to leave the estate to them, making their entire performance of parading their children before Big Daddy useless. Without homophobia as a driving force, the story would lack its central conflict.
Alternative scenario: If Brick were homosexual and accepted this fact, he would probably divorce Maggie. Big Daddy would realise Brick could not provide him with grandchildren and would regretfully leave the estate to Gooper and Mae. Again, the fundamental conflict would disappear.
Societal damage: Through Brick's homophobia, Williams demonstrates how blindly accepting society's view of correct or moral behaviour produces damaging results. Because Brick accepts societal prejudices concerning homosexuality, he becomes detached from himself and from others. Whilst characters such as Gooper and Mae accept societal convention and perform their designated roles—even though appearing ridiculous—Maggie demonstrates an ability to break from convention. She emerged from poverty and proved willing to acknowledge the unusual nature of Brick's relationship with Skipper.
Broader examples: Williams presents other examples of damage caused by conforming to society's expectations. Big Daddy married and tolerates a wife he hates because he wants societal acceptance. For the same reason, he attends church and various clubs, even though he dislikes these activities. After his confrontation with death, Big Daddy vows to abandon those conventions. Unfortunately for him, this realisation arrives too late. Whether Maggie, through creating new life, will succeed in pushing Brick toward the same rejection of harmful conventions remains open to interpretation.
Cruelty
If lack of communication represents the method supporting delusion and artifice, cruelty emerges as the consequence of these themes. Williams focuses particularly on the cruelty of Brick toward Maggie and Big Daddy toward Big Mama.
Brick's cruelty toward Maggie: Brick treats Maggie harshly through his emotional detachment and refusal to maintain sexual relations with her. His cold rejection causes Maggie significant pain whilst allowing him to avoid confronting his feelings about Skipper.
Big Daddy's cruelty toward Big Mama: Big Daddy treats Big Mama cruelly through vicious remarks directed at her and his humiliation of her in front of other family members. His verbal attacks wound her deeply whilst expressing his long-suppressed resentment about their marriage.
Cruelty among other characters: Maggie and Mae exchange numerous vicious comments with each other. Gooper and Mae mock Brick and treat Big Mama callously. However, all this cruelty originates from delusion and artifice supported by inadequate communication.
The Cycle of Cruelty
The play reveals a destructive cycle where each theme reinforces the others. Because Brick refuses to communicate directly, he inflicts pain on both Maggie and Big Daddy. Big Daddy has accumulated anger and frustration over years due to the artifice of his marriage and the constant dishonesty or absence of honest communication in his life. Finally, all his anger erupts in harsh insults directed at his wife. Gooper and Mae attempt to use artifice to manipulate Big Daddy, which constitutes a cruel act in itself. As they engage in this manipulation, Gooper and Mae refuse to communicate honestly with either Big Daddy or Big Mama.
This interconnection demonstrates Williams' sophisticated approach to theme—no element exists in isolation. Each theme grows from and feeds into the others, creating a complex web of dysfunction.
Key Themes to Remember:
-
Delusion and artifice: Every main character engages in self-deception to avoid painful truths, particularly concerning death, sexuality and family relationships. Maggie demonstrates the most self-awareness whilst still using artifice strategically.
-
Lack of communication: Characters use poor communication to maintain their delusions. Brick avoids conversation through drinking, Gooper and Mae resort to indirect attacks, and Big Daddy's attempts at honest dialogue with Brick are constantly interrupted.
-
Homophobia as the central conflict: Brick's internalised homophobia, described by Williams as causing his "moral paralysis," drives the entire play's conflict. Without this theme, the dramatic tension would collapse entirely.
-
Interconnected themes: These themes function together—lack of communication maintains delusion, which leads to cruelty. Understanding their connections helps analyse character motivation and dramatic structure.
-
Exam tip: When discussing themes, support your points with specific character examples and consider how Williams uses these themes to critique 1950s American Southern society and its restrictive conventions.