The Peace Settlement (AQA A-Level History): Revision Notes
The Peace Settlement
Woodrow Wilson played a direct role in the Paris Peace Conference following the First World War. However, American engagement in European affairs proved short-lived. The Senate rejected membership of the League of Nations, and the United States returned to a policy of isolationism.
The Fourteen Points
In 1918, Wilson delivered a speech outlining his vision for a lasting peace settlement. His proposal, known as the Fourteen Points, aimed to establish stable international relations and prevent future conflicts.
The Three Categories of the Fourteen Points:
The Fourteen Points were organized into three distinct groups, each addressing different aspects of post-war peace:
- General Principles (Points 1-5): Focused on preventing the conditions that led to war
- Self-Determination (Points 6-13): Addressed territorial adjustments based on national identities
- International Organization (Point 14): Proposed the League of Nations as a peacekeeping body
The first five points addressed general principles for maintaining order between nations, drawing lessons from the war's origins. Wilson emphasised that secret agreements between nations had created insecurity and encouraged double-dealing. He advocated for open diplomacy conducted transparently rather than through covert treaties.
The next eight points concerned self-determination – the principle that borders should reflect the wishes of local populations. This category included the restoration of Alsace-Lorraine (the region Germany had taken from France after the Franco-Prussian War in 1871) to France and renewed guarantees for Belgian independence.
The fourteenth point proposed establishing a League of Nations – an international organisation dedicated to peacekeeping and mutual cooperation. All signatories of the peace treaties would be required to join.
The Myth of Full Implementation
Wilson received the 1919 Nobel Peace Prize for his efforts, though the peace settlement never fully embodied the Fourteen Points. The concept of self-determination created inherent problems, as redrawing borders to satisfy one population inevitably meant others would lose territory. The final settlement represented a compromise between Wilson's idealistic vision and the harsh realities of post-war politics.
Nevertheless, Wilson's idealistic framework influenced the peace process and earned him international recognition.
The peace conference
A peace conference convened in Paris during January 1919 to establish a lasting settlement. Three leaders dominated proceedings: Clemenceau (French prime minister), Lloyd George (British prime minister), and Wilson. Each brought different priorities shaped by domestic circumstances and war experiences.
Wilson's personal involvement
Wilson made the momentous decision to attend the Paris conference personally. No previous American president had left the United States whilst in office. Wilson felt so determined to secure a lasting settlement that he gambled with his own health and political standing.
The Physical Toll of Peacemaking
The strain of the peace conference proved immense for Wilson. He worked eighteen-hour days, squatting uncomfortably over huge maps spread across the floor, carving out regions like jigsaw pieces. The extreme stress manifested in paranoia, with Wilson becoming obsessed with French spies. On 3 August 1919, he suffered his first stroke – a warning sign of the complete physical collapse that would ultimately derail his campaign for the League of Nations.
Competing national agendas
Wilson's vision of a lasting peace settlement based on fairness and moral principles struggled to gain traction in this atmosphere. The "Big Three" – the USA, Britain and France – made most decisions, but each pursued a different agenda shaped by their war experience.
Three Leaders, Three Visions
The conflicting priorities of the Big Three shaped the entire peace settlement:
-
France (Clemenceau): Sought harsh punishment for Germany to finance reconstruction and ensure Germany could never threaten France again. France had endured most Western Front fighting on its soil.
-
Britain (Lloyd George): Recognized that excessive harshness risked generating resentment in Germany that could fuel future conflict. However, the British population largely demanded revenge, creating a political dilemma.
-
USA (Wilson): Prioritized gaining acceptance of the League of Nations above all else. To achieve this, Wilson proved willing to compromise on other matters, including self-determination and German war guilt.
Whilst Wilson disliked German militarism and believed Germany should face punishment, he wanted this done in a manner that would promote European reconciliation rather than revenge.
The USA and the League of Nations
The League of Nations represented Wilson's most cherished proposal from the Fourteen Points. He viewed it as essential for maintaining lasting peace after the Versailles settlement. Wilson returned to America after the peace conference determined to secure Senate approval for League membership.
Wilson's failed campaign
Opposition emerged immediately. A document signed by 37 Republican senators condemned the League of Nations and argued it should be delayed. Wilson's campaign for membership faced two insurmountable obstacles.
First, Wilson defied doctors' orders and toured the USA in September 1919 to build public support for League membership. Opposition from those who opposed the League equally vocally followed him. The tour exhausted Wilson completely. He delivered 37 speeches within two days. On 25 September, Wilson collapsed after a speech in Pueblo, Colorado. His campaign ended abruptly.
The Reservationists: A Missed Opportunity for Compromise
The reservationists represented senators occupying a middle position – not entirely opposed to League membership but wanting to negotiate modifications. Senator Lodge introduced a compromise bill in November, but Wilson instructed Democrats to oppose it. This refusal to compromise proved costly: the measure failed by 53 votes to 38.
The final rejection
When the Senate reconsidered the original peace settlement in March 1920, it passed by 49 votes to 35. However, this fell seven votes short of the two-thirds majority required for treaty approval.
The Knox-Porter Resolution in October 1921 finally resolved the matter. The Covenant of the League of Nations was attached to all peace treaties. By rejecting League membership, the USA effectively refused to sign the peace treaties. The Knox-Porter Resolution declared the war over and allowed the Senate to pass the peace treaties except for the Covenant of the League of Nations.
Wilson's physical collapse
Wilson's stroke on 3 August 1919 marked only the beginning of his physical decline. Detailed contemporary accounts describe how, by November 1918, Wilson appeared in his wheelchair with tears streaming down his face. His left arm and leg no longer functioned. Though Cabinet members could see him through the windows, they could not communicate with him directly. Senator Gilbert Hitchcock fought for the Treaty, but Wilson remained locked in his sickroom, unable to lead the campaign he considered most dear to his heart.
Key dates
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 1918 | Wilson delivered speech announcing the Fourteen Points |
| 1919 | Wilson awarded the Nobel Peace Prize |
| January 1919 | Peace conference began in Paris |
| June 1919 | Signing of the Treaty of Versailles |
| August 1919 | Wilson suffered his first stroke |
| September 1919 | Wilson undertook speaking tour across USA; collapsed in Pueblo, Colorado on 25 September |
| November 1919 | Senate rejected League membership by 53 to 38 votes |
| March 1920 | Senate passed peace settlement by 49 to 35 votes, seven short of required two-thirds majority |
| October 1921 | Knox-Porter Resolution declared war over and passed peace treaties excluding League Covenant |
Key Points to Remember:
-
Wilson's Fourteen Points proposed open diplomacy, self-determination, and the League of Nations, organized into three categories: general principles, territorial adjustments, and international organization. The peace settlement never fully implemented these principles.
-
The "Big Three" dominated the Paris Peace Conference with competing visions: Clemenceau sought harsh punishment for Germany, Lloyd George took a moderate position balancing revenge with pragmatism, and Wilson prioritized League of Nations acceptance above all else.
-
Wilson's exhausting speaking tour in September 1919 (37 speeches in two days) ended with his collapse in Pueblo, Colorado on 25 September, effectively ending his campaign and marking the beginning of his complete physical breakdown.
-
The Senate rejected League membership twice: first by 53-38 votes in November 1919, then by 49-35 votes in March 1920 (seven votes short of the two-thirds majority needed). Wilson's refusal to compromise with the reservationists contributed to both defeats.
-
The Knox-Porter Resolution in October 1921 allowed the USA to declare the war over and sign peace treaties whilst excluding the League of Nations Covenant, marking America's return to isolationism and the permanent failure of Wilson's most cherished goal.