Conclusion (AQA A-Level History): Revision Notes
Conclusion
Overview of transformation 1951-2007
By 2007, Labour had governed Britain for a decade. The nation possessed a service-based economy, with the European Union as its main trading partner. This appeared vastly different from 1951, when 13 years of Conservative rule were beginning, Britain retained a large manufacturing sector, and the country remained an imperial power. However, this surface-level comparison obscures a more nuanced understanding of Britain's transformation and the complex relationship between change and continuity across these 56 years.
Understanding Britain's transformation between 1951 and 2007 requires looking beyond surface-level changes. The relationship between change and continuity is far more complex than it first appears, with both elements deeply intertwined throughout this period.
Political continuity and adaptation
Both Labour and the Conservatives demonstrated remarkable resilience throughout 1951-2007. Each party experienced extended periods in government and opposition, yet both managed to transform their public image and policy platforms to regain electoral support. This ability to adapt proved essential for survival.
The parties confronted multiple crises stemming from governance challenges and their responses to social and economic shifts. Despite these pressures, both maintained their position as Britain's dominant political forces, demonstrating that political institutions could evolve whilst retaining their core identity.
The survival of both major parties demonstrates an important principle: political success in Britain required the ability to reinvent and adapt to changing circumstances whilst maintaining enough continuity to preserve party identity and voter loyalty.
Economic transformation and persistent problems
Economic changes
Britain underwent substantial economic transformation between 1951 and 2007:
- Deindustrialisation (the decline of manufacturing industry) reshaped entire regions of Britain
- New retailing formats emerged, including supermarkets and out-of-town shopping centres
- The internet revolutionised commerce from the late 1990s onwards
- Living standards rose considerably compared to 1951
- Consumer expectations shifted dramatically - cars, household appliances like fridges, and foreign holidays became necessities rather than luxuries to most people
Economic continuities
Despite successive governments' aspirations for modernisation, economic progress proved slow and uneven. Persistent structural problems endured:
- Underinvestment in infrastructure and industry
- Low productivity relative to competitors
- Skills shortages
- Inflation pressures
- Balance of payments difficulties
Whilst the British economy looked very different in 2007 from 1951, longstanding economic weaknesses remained unresolved. This persistence of structural problems demonstrates that economic transformation was incomplete, with deep-rooted issues continuing to challenge policymakers throughout the entire period.
Social revolution and continuity
Social changes
Britain experienced periods of accelerated social change that transformed large parts of the country by 2007:
- A cleaner physical environment
- Extensive urban development
- Greater diversity and tolerance regarding culture and ethnic background
- Women's participation in the workplace increased substantially (in 1951, women had been predominantly housewives)
- More urban areas affected by immigration and cultural change
These shifts were often described as a social revolution, reflecting how markedly different Britain appeared in 2007 from 1951.
Social continuities
Not all equality issues had been resolved by 2007. Prejudice and discrimination persisted in various forms. Some parts of the country, particularly those untouched by urbanisation and immigration, had changed remarkably little. The extent of social transformation varied considerably across different regions and communities.
The pace and extent of social change was highly uneven across Britain. While urban areas experienced dramatic transformation through immigration and cultural diversity, rural and some suburban areas remained relatively unchanged, creating a patchwork of modern and traditional communities across the nation.
Class structure: change and continuity
Class changes
Evidence suggested shifts in Britain's class structure:
- Multiple prime ministers between 1951 and 2001 had been educated at state secondary schools (rather than elite private institutions)
- The Conservative Party was no longer wholly dominated by the upper middle classes as it had been in the 1950s
- The Labour Party had increasingly moved away from its old working-class roots
- By 2007, politicians from all parties sought to be seen as classless and in tune with society, regardless of their background
Class continuities
Despite these changes, Britain had experienced less transformation than commonly believed. Traditional elite institutions and power structures remained largely intact:
- Queen Elizabeth II had reigned since 1952, with royal scandals causing little lasting damage to the monarchy
- The House of Lords still contained hereditary peers
- The BBC remained a national institution, funded by the licence fee
- Large parts of the Establishment (traditional elite institutions) were still intact
- An analysis of 500 leaders in politics, media, law, journalism and business in 2007 found that 53 per cent had been educated at independent schools and 47 per cent had attended either Oxford or Cambridge University
The Persistence of Elite Power
The statistics on Britain's leadership in 2007 reveal the limited nature of class transformation. Despite decades of social change and expanded educational opportunities, the traditional elite maintained a disproportionate hold on positions of power and influence. This demonstrates that surface-level changes in political rhetoric about classlessness masked deeper continuities in Britain's power structures.
Britain's position in the world
Changes in international standing
Britain's global position appeared transformed between 1951 and 2007:
1951:
- Decolonisation had already begun, but Britain held a substantial empire
- Britain maintained an ambivalent relationship with Europe, encouraging integration from the sidelines but unwilling to fully engage
- Foreign policy was dominated by the 'special relationship' with the United States and by Cold War pressures
2007:
- The Empire was gone
- The Cold War was over
- Britain was now a member of the European Union
Contrasting Britain's International Position
The contrast between 1951 and 2007 appears stark on the surface. Britain transformed from an imperial power with global territories to a medium-sized European nation. However, examining continuities reveals that Britain's self-perception and ambitions on the world stage changed less dramatically than these facts might suggest.
Continuities in international relations
The transformation was incomplete. Whilst the Empire had ended, some old attitudes of Empire persisted. Britain retained its place at the 'top table' of international affairs and possessed a nuclear deterrent. Upholding the relationship with the United States had been a constant preoccupation of almost all governments since 1951, demonstrating enduring patterns in British foreign policy.
Overall assessment: intertwined change and continuity
The period 1951-2007 was, in many respects, one of rapid change. Yet it simultaneously encompassed many continuities. These changes and continuities in politics, culture, society and economy were intertwined rather than separate. Understanding Britain in this period requires grappling with the complexity of these relationships - how transformation and persistence occurred simultaneously, sometimes reinforcing and sometimes contradicting each other. It is the untangling of this complexity that enables genuine depth of understanding about Britain between 1951 and 2007.
Key Points to Remember:
-
By 2007, Britain had a service-based economy and was an EU member, appearing vastly different from 1951, yet this surface comparison obscures deeper continuities.
-
Both major parties (Labour and Conservative) survived throughout the period by reinventing their policies and image to attract voters, despite experiencing serious crises.
-
Economic transformation was substantial (deindustrialisation, new retailing, internet, higher living standards), but persistent structural problems (underinvestment, low productivity, inflation, balance of payments) remained unresolved.
-
Social change was considerable (cleaner environment, diversity, women in workplace), yet prejudice persisted and some areas remained largely unchanged; the Establishment stayed largely intact (53% of leaders from independent schools, 47% from Oxbridge by 2007).
-
Britain's world position shifted dramatically (Empire gone, Cold War over, EU membership), but old attitudes endured, the nuclear deterrent was retained, and the US relationship remained a constant preoccupation; change and continuity in politics, society, economy and culture were deeply intertwined.