Indian Threats and Economic Crisis (Edexcel A-Level History): Revision Notes
Indian Threats and Economic Crisis
Introduction
The residents of Salem felt their way of life had been seriously disrupted by external forces during the late 17th century. The revolt that removed Governor Edmund Andros had brought few improvements, and with reduced representation from local Puritan leaders, community problems and disputes became harder to resolve. There was a noticeable lack of legal authority. As difficulties mounted, the Puritan majority increasingly believed that the Devil was at work in their community.
The late 17th century was a period of significant upheaval for Salem residents, with political instability following Governor Andros's removal leaving them vulnerable to both external threats and internal conflicts. This combination of circumstances would prove crucial in setting the stage for the witch trials.
Indian threats
Changing historical perspectives
For many years, until the mid-1980s, most historians did not regard Indian attacks as a significant cause of the Salem witch craze. However, more recent scholarship by historians such as James Kences and Mary Beth Norton has given this factor much greater credibility. Indian attacks had been a constant reality since Europeans first settled in North America, but these threats became far more intense towards the end of the 17th century, particularly in Massachusetts.
King Philip's War (First Indian War), 1675-1678
King Philip's War, often called the First Indian War, took place between 1675 and 1678 and had devastating consequences across the region. Towns throughout Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island and Maine suffered severe damage. The human cost was enormous - one-tenth of all military-age men were killed. In Salem specifically, the constant threat of attack made residents increasingly fearful and suspicious of outsiders.
The casualty rate of King Philip's War was staggering - with one in ten military-age men killed, virtually every family in Massachusetts would have experienced direct loss. This trauma created a climate of fear and suspicion that persisted for decades.
Weakened colonial defences
After the overthrow of Governor Andros, the colony's defensive capabilities became significantly weaker. Fewer troops were available for military service, which meant attacks became more frequent and colonists faced regular danger of being killed. The young girls who later provided evidence at the Salem trials would certainly have been affected by seeing their friends and neighbours fall victim to these violent attacks. In the years immediately before the witch-hunt, several outsiders who had survived Indian attacks relocated to Salem, bringing their traumatic experiences with them.
King William's War (Second Indian War)
The Salem trials occurred during King William's War, also known as the Second Indian War. This conflict was part of the broader Nine Years' War (1688-1697) that William of Orange was fighting against France in Europe. Both European powers formed alliances with different Indian tribes, making the conflict in North America part of a wider international struggle.
The timing of the Salem witch trials is significant - they occurred during an active war. The trials took place in 1692-1693, right in the middle of King William's War, meaning Salem residents were living under constant threat of attack while the witch-hunt unfolded.
Puritan beliefs about Indians
In the Puritan worldview, Indians were seen as Devil-worshippers who actively opposed the establishment of a godly society in New England. They were also viewed as allies of the despised French and Spanish Catholics. Contemporary accounts described Indians in extremely hostile terms, treating them as less than human and advocating for their extermination. This dehumanising language reflected deep-seated Puritan fears and prejudices.
Critical Connection: The Puritan belief that Indians were Devil-worshippers created a direct ideological link between the threat of Indian attacks and accusations of witchcraft. In the Puritan mind, both were manifestations of Satan's war against their godly community.
Connection to the witch trials
Several historians have suggested that Tituba, one of the key instigators of the witch craze who worked as a healer and was later accused of witchcraft, may have been of Indian origin. Recent historical research has emphasised the role of fear surrounding Indian attacks in creating a deep-seated paranoia among Puritan settlers. Many believed that God was willing to allow the Devil's agents - in the form of Indians - to punish them for their sins.
Evidence linking witchcraft and Indian attacks
Contemporary writer Joshua Scottow explicitly connected witches with the Indian threat in his writings. According to historian Mary Beth Norton, God was seen as simultaneously punishing New England in two ways: through the Second Indian War on the frontier and through witchcraft in Essex County (where Salem was located). The connections between these two threats became deeply intertwined in colonists' minds.
During witchcraft examinations and trials, there were repeated spectral sightings of the "black man" - a figure the afflicted girls described as resembling an Indian. The language used to describe witches' threats mirrored that of Indian attacks: both witches and the Devil supposedly threatened to "tear to pieces" or "knock in the head" those who opposed them, exactly as the Wabanakis tribe had threatened settlers.
Parallel Language of Terror: The striking similarity between descriptions of witchcraft threats and Indian attack threats reveals how deeply these two fears were connected in the Puritan imagination. When the afflicted girls described supernatural threats using the same violent language associated with Indian warfare, it resonated powerfully with their terrified community.
Scottow's "Narrative of the Planting of the Massachusetts Colony", written shortly after the witchcraft crisis ended, presented the Wabanakis' attacks and those of the witches as related phenomena, both instigated by God as punishment for the colonists' sins.
Economic crisis
Impact of the First Indian War
The First Indian War left Massachusetts's economy virtually ruined. Half of New England's towns had been attacked, and the important Massachusetts settlement of Springfield was completely burnt to the ground. However, the damage was not entirely catastrophic - a population growth rate of three percent per year and the establishment of new towns meant that settlers' livelihoods were not completely destroyed.
Despite this recovery, in the 1680s the colonists requested military assistance from England. This contributed to a significant rise in their tax burden under Governor Sir Edmund Andros, adding to existing economic pressures.
The Navigation Acts
A series of Navigation Acts passed by the English Parliament seriously hampered the economic fortunes of the Massachusetts colony. The first Act was passed in 1651, with modified versions issued in 1660, 1662 and 1673.
Key provisions of the Navigation Acts:
- All goods imported to England and its territories had to be carried on English ships
- At least half of all crews on English ships had to be English by nationality
- The Acts were designed to break the Dutch monopoly on freight trade across northern Europe and North America
- Goods being transported from the colonies to any destination had to travel to England first
These provisions fundamentally restructured colonial trade, forcing Massachusetts merchants to abandon profitable trading relationships and submit to English commercial control.
Historian Christopher Hill argued that the Navigation Acts were significant because they represented the victory of a national trading interest over the separate interests of various private trading companies and fleets based in the colonies.
Impact on Massachusetts
Massachusetts possessed a strong merchant fleet that had previously enjoyed considerable independence. When ship captains ignored the demands of the Navigation Acts, they faced reprimands from English authorities. This rebellious behaviour helps explain why Kings Charles II and James II later attempted to centralise control over the colony.
The Acts effectively reduced the money and resources flowing into Massachusetts, as wealth was instead redirected towards England. The economic impact was severe:
Effects on agriculture:
- It became virtually impossible to ship grain to England as a result of the Acts
- Many farmers in and around Salem were forced to diversify their crops and income sources
Effects on fishing:
- Dutch ships had traditionally offered the best shipping rates for fish caught near Salem
- With the use of Dutch ships now illegal, fishermen were forced to pay much higher fees to transport their produce to England
- This significantly reduced their profit margins
Economic Squeeze on Salem: The combination of war damage, increased taxation, and the Navigation Acts created a perfect storm of economic hardship. Salem residents, particularly farmers and fishermen who formed the backbone of the local economy, saw their livelihoods threatened from multiple directions simultaneously.
Combined pressures
The combination of war damage, increased taxation, and restrictive trade regulations created severe economic hardship for Salem and surrounding communities. These economic pressures, combined with the constant military threat from Indian attacks, created an atmosphere of anxiety and insecurity that made the outbreak of a witch-hunt more likely.
Key Points to Remember:
-
Indian attacks intensified during the late 17th century, with King Philip's War (1675-78) causing massive casualties (one-tenth of military-age men killed) and King William's War coinciding with the Salem trials.
-
Puritans viewed Indians as Devil-worshippers allied with Satan and Catholic powers, creating a link in their minds between Indian attacks and witchcraft.
-
Economic crisis resulted from war damage (Springfield burnt, half of towns attacked), increased taxation under Andros, and restrictive Navigation Acts that forced trade through England.
-
The Navigation Acts severely damaged Salem's economy by making it illegal to use cheaper Dutch ships and forcing all colonial goods to pass through England first, particularly affecting farmers and fishermen.
-
Fear and economic hardship combined to create an atmosphere of paranoia and insecurity, with colonists believing God was punishing them through both Indian attacks and witchcraft, making a witch-hunt more likely.