The Extent to Which Danish Witch-Hunting Influenced Events in Scotland (Edexcel A-Level History): Revision Notes
The Extent to Which Danish Witch-Hunting Influenced Events in Scotland
Introduction: James VI's Danish connection
King James VI's journey to Denmark in 1589-90 to marry Anne of Denmark is often seen as a turning point in his attitudes towards witchcraft. However, historians debate how much Danish witch-hunting practices actually influenced events in Scotland, particularly the North Berwick trials of 1590-91.
This historical debate centers on a fundamental question: did James VI import Danish ideas about witchcraft to Scotland, or did Scottish witch-hunting develop independently? The answer has important implications for understanding how witch-hunting practices spread across early modern Europe.
James's meeting with Niels Hemmingsen
Historians Christina Larner and P.G. Maxwell-Stuart argue that James's encounter with the respected Danish theologian Niels Hemmingsen may have significantly shaped his beliefs about witchcraft. Hemmingsen had written an influential book in 1575 called Admonitio de Superstitionibus Magicis Vitandis (Avoiding Magic and Superstition). His views were complex:
- He accepted that witches could perform maleficium (harmful magic)
- However, he rejected the idea that witches could make pacts with the Devil
Understanding maleficium: This Latin term refers to harmful magic that causes physical damage to people, animals, or property. It was distinguished from other forms of magic in early modern legal thinking. Danish witch trials focused primarily on maleficium rather than on theological questions about Devil worship.
This meeting is significant because it shows James engaging with continental European ideas about witchcraft at the highest intellectual level.
Challenging the Danish influence theory
Historian Thomas Riis offers a contrasting view. He argues that James's visit to Denmark would have had limited impact on his thinking because:
- Danish witchcraft accusations focused mainly on local cases of maleficium
- Danish trials rarely involved accusations of pacts with the Devil
- This differed significantly from the demonological approach that would emerge in Scotland
Critical Context: This debate highlights the importance of understanding the specific context of Danish witch-hunting when assessing its influence on Scotland. We cannot assume that proximity or political connections automatically mean ideological influence - the actual content of witch-hunting practices must be compared carefully.
Witchcraft in Denmark: legal context and characteristics
Danish legal protections for the accused
Denmark had developed a relatively progressive legal framework for dealing with witchcraft accusations by the late 16th century:
1547 reforms:
- Laws passed to ensure fair trials for suspected witches
- Torture was prohibited
- Testimony from disreputable individuals was excluded from trials
- Gave suspected witches remarkable state protection
The 1547 reforms were remarkably progressive for their time. While other European countries were intensifying their witch-hunts with brutal torture and summary executions, Denmark was moving in the opposite direction by establishing legal safeguards. This makes the Anna Koldings case (discussed later) particularly noteworthy, as torture appears to have been used despite being illegal.
1576 reforms:
- Appeals against local court decisions could be heard in the high court in Copenhagen
- Added another layer of protection against miscarriages of justice
Key characteristics of Danish witch trials
Danish witch-hunting differed from other European countries in several important ways:
- Trials rarely referenced satanic pacts with the Devil
- Focus remained on accusations of maleficium (harmful magic causing physical harm)
- Legal safeguards meant fewer executions than in many other countries
- Witch-hunting arrived relatively late compared to other European nations
Key Difference: These differences are crucial for understanding whether Danish practices could have influenced the very different approach that emerged in Scotland. If Danish trials avoided the demonological elements that became central to Scottish trials, how could Denmark have served as a model?
The Protestant Reformation connection
Religious parallels between Denmark and Scotland
Both Denmark and Scotland underwent Protestant Reformations that shared similar characteristics, creating a foundation for shared prejudices about witchcraft:
Lutheran influence in Denmark:
- Lutheran Bishop Peter Palladius (1503-60) actively encouraged Christians to report suspected witches
- He reported that 52 witches were burned in a single hunt
- Each convicted witch confessed the names of others, creating a chain reaction
- High-profile clergy labelled religious opponents as witches during the Reformation
Understanding Lutheranism: Lutheran - A follower of the Protestant reformer Martin Luther. Lutheranism is the oldest Protestant denomination, based on the doctrine of justification by faith alone and the authority of Scripture. In both Denmark and Scotland, Lutheran and Calvinist reformers saw witchcraft as a serious threat to Protestant religious purity.
Witchcraft and religious identity
Both Danish and Scottish witch trials sometimes linked witchcraft accusations to religious affiliation:
Case Study: Bessie Dunlop (Scotland, 1576)
Bessie Dunlop was accused of witchcraft in Ayr, before the North Berwick trials. This case demonstrates the connection between witchcraft and religious identity in Scotland:
- She was charged with conversing with the Devil, who allegedly invited her to become a Catholic
- Under torture, she confessed that the ghost of a dead soldier had helped her heal animals and find stolen goods
- This case shows Scottish authorities linking witchcraft to suspected Catholicism
Significance: The Bessie Dunlop case reveals how witchcraft accusations could be weaponized against religious minorities, particularly Catholics, in Protestant Scotland. This pattern would be repeated in the North Berwick trials.
Similar Danish cases:
- Danish trials also featured accusations of hidden Catholicism
- This reinforced Scottish prejudices and created shared assumptions about the relationship between witchcraft and religious deviance
These religious connections suggest that shared Protestant anxieties, rather than specific witch-hunting practices, may have been the main Danish influence on Scotland.
The direct connection: Anna Koldings and the 1590 witch-hunt
The North Berwick-Denmark connection emerges
In the North Berwick case, the link between Danish and Scottish witchcraft became explicit in July 1590:
Early July 1590:
- A disturbed woman arrived in Leith (Edinburgh's port)
- She prophesied that James would carry out noble acts
- This created an atmosphere of supernatural anxiety
Later in July 1590:
- News reached Scotland that witches in Denmark had been arrested
- They were accused of conjuring storms that prevented Anne from travelling to Scotland
- This news created a direct parallel with the storms that had affected James's voyage
Critical Timing: This timing is crucial - it shows that events in Denmark were known in Scotland and could have influenced how Scottish authorities interpreted their own cases. The question is whether this news merely reinforced existing Scottish suspicions or actually triggered new investigations.
The Anna Koldings case
A letter dated 23 July 1590 from a spy of English statesman Lord Burghley provides important details:
Case Study: Anna Koldings and the Copenhagen Witch-Hunt
The arrests:
- Danish admiral Peter Munk demanded that five or six suspected witches be taken to Copenhagen
- They were accused of using witchcraft to disrupt the voyages of Anne and James
Anna Koldings's interrogation:
- One suspect was Anna Koldings
- She was interrogated and possibly tortured, despite torture being illegal in Denmark
- Fearing further torture, she named five other women as accomplices
- One of the accused was the wife of the borgmaster (chief magistrate) of Copenhagen
Note: Borgmaster - The principal magistrate of a Danish town, similar in stature to a mayor.
The confessions:
- All the women eventually confessed to raising a storm to sink Anne's ship
- They admitted to sending demons to climb onto the ship and pull it under the waves
- Koldings said the women held meetings at the house of Karen the Weaver
The executions:
- Anna Koldings was burned at the stake
- At least 12 other women were executed during this witch-hunt
- This was a significant number for Denmark, where executions were relatively rare
Historical Significance: This case is extraordinary for Denmark because it violated established legal protections and produced an unusually high number of executions. The involvement of high-status individuals (the borgmaster's wife) and the international political dimension (threats to royal voyages) made this a unique case in Danish witch-hunting history.
Initial scepticism about witchcraft
Interestingly, Danish authorities initially sought rational explanations before turning to witchcraft:
- Christopher Valkendorff, the minister of finance, was first accused of providing an inadequate and poorly constructed fleet
- He defended himself by blaming the witches, particularly Karen the Weaver
- This suggests that even in Denmark, witchcraft accusations could be used as scapegoating for political or administrative failures
This pattern of scapegoating is significant because it shows how witchcraft accusations could serve political purposes beyond genuine belief in supernatural harm. When powerful individuals faced criticism for failures, deflecting blame onto witches provided a convenient explanation that was difficult to disprove.
Analysis: the extent of Danish influence
Evidence for Danish influence
Several factors suggest Danish witch-hunting did influence events in Scotland:
Direct connections:
- The timing of the Danish arrests in July 1590 coincided with the start of the North Berwick investigations
- Both cases centred on storms affecting royal voyages
- Both involved confessions about raising storms and sending demons
Shared Protestant culture:
- Similar anxieties about Catholicism and religious deviance
- Protestant clergy in both countries actively promoting witch-hunting
- Shared theological frameworks from the Reformation
Political factors:
- James's personal connection to Denmark through his marriage
- The international nature of the accusations (affecting both Danish and Scottish royalty)
- The use of witchcraft accusations to explain political embarrassments
Evidence against significant Danish influence
However, important differences suggest Danish practices had limited direct influence:
Different legal approaches:
- Denmark had strong legal protections; Scotland did not
- Torture was illegal in Denmark but used in Scotland
- Danish appeals system was more developed than Scotland's
This legal difference is perhaps the strongest evidence against significant Danish influence on Scottish practice. If James had been deeply impressed by Danish approaches to witchcraft, we might expect him to have imported some of Denmark's legal safeguards. Instead, Scottish trials proceeded with methods that would have been illegal in Denmark.
Different theological focus:
- Danish trials rarely involved Devil pacts
- Scottish trials (especially North Berwick) heavily emphasized demonic pacts and sabbats
- This suggests Scotland drew more from continental demonology than Danish practice
Historian Thomas Riis's argument:
- Danish witchcraft was primarily about local maleficium
- This would not have provided a model for Scotland's more elaborate demonological approach
- James may have been influenced by continental theorists rather than Danish practice
The historiographical debate
Understanding the Historical Debate:
Christina Larner and P.G. Maxwell-Stuart's position:
- James's meeting with Hemmingsen was significant
- Danish ideas about witchcraft influenced James's thinking
- The Danish connection helped trigger the North Berwick trials
Thomas Riis's counter-argument:
- Fundamental differences between Danish and Scottish approaches
- Danish focus on maleficium versus Scottish focus on Devil pacts
- Limited practical influence of Danish methods
This debate reflects broader questions about how ideas about witchcraft spread across Europe and how local contexts shaped witch-hunting. It reminds us that cultural exchange is complex - exposure to foreign ideas doesn't automatically mean adoption of those ideas.
Exam focus: analyzing the extent of influence
When answering exam questions on this topic, consider:
Exam Strategy: Analyzing "Extent" Questions
For questions asking about the extent of Danish influence:
- Present both sides of the historiographical debate
- Use specific evidence (dates, cases, legal differences)
- Distinguish between direct influence on practices and indirect influence through shared culture
- Consider alternative explanations (continental demonology, Scottish political context)
Key analytical points:
- The Anna Koldings case created a direct parallel but not necessarily a model
- Shared Protestant anxieties may have been more influential than specific practices
- Legal frameworks in Denmark and Scotland were fundamentally different
- Timing of events suggests some Danish influence but doesn't prove causation
Common pitfall to avoid:
- Don't assume that because James visited Denmark and Danish witch trials occurred, this automatically means significant influence
- Always consider the specific differences in how witchcraft was understood and prosecuted in each country
Summary
Key Points to Remember:
-
Danish legal context: Denmark had progressive protections (no torture, appeals system) that were absent in Scotland, suggesting limited influence on Scottish legal practice
-
Anna Koldings case (July 1590): Created direct parallel with North Berwick but was itself unusual for Denmark, with illegal torture used
-
Historiographical debate: Larner and Maxwell-Stuart argue for Hemmingsen's influence; Riis argues Danish focus on maleficium made influence unlikely
-
Key difference: Danish trials rarely involved Devil pacts, whereas Scottish trials (especially North Berwick) emphasized demonic pacts and sabbats
-
Protestant Reformation connection: Shared religious anxieties and anti-Catholic prejudices in both countries may have been more influential than specific witch-hunting practices
-
Analytical approach: When assessing "extent," consider both direct influences (the Anna Koldings parallel) and indirect influences (shared Protestant culture) while recognizing fundamental differences in legal and theological approaches