How the New Deal Aided Black Americans (Edexcel A-Level History): Revision Notes
How the New Deal Aided Black Americans
Introduction
Despite facing significant discrimination under many New Deal programmes, black Americans did benefit from certain aspects of Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal policies between 1933 and 1941. These benefits came primarily through federal employment opportunities, welfare relief programmes, and housing initiatives. The New Deal opened doors for black Americans in the federal government and provided crucial economic support during the Great Depression.
Federal government opportunities
The New Deal created unprecedented opportunities for black Americans to work within the federal government itself, breaking down some racial barriers in public administration.
Robert Weaver's appointment
In 1934, Robert Weaver became the first black American to serve as a presidential adviser when Roosevelt appointed him as his special adviser on the Economic Status of the Negro. This groundbreaking appointment demonstrated that the federal government was beginning to consider the specific economic challenges facing black Americans. Weaver's position allowed him to influence policy decisions and advocate for black Americans' interests at the highest levels of government.
Weaver's appointment was revolutionary for its time - it marked the first instance of a black American having direct access to presidential decision-making and the ability to influence New Deal policies from within the administration.
Harold Ickes and progressive leadership
Weaver's advancement was largely due to Harold Ickes, who served as Secretary of the Interior from 1933 to 1946. Ickes brought a strong commitment to racial equality, having previously served as president of the Chicago branch of the NAACP (National Association for the Advancement of Colored People). His progressive views on race enabled him to champion policies that directly assisted black Americans, particularly through his leadership of the Public Works Administration.
Housing programmes and racial quotas
One of the most significant ways the New Deal aided black Americans was through housing initiatives that actively sought to include them.
The Public Works Administration housing division
Under Ickes' leadership, the PWA housing division (which later became the US Housing Authority) introduced an important innovation: racial quotas for construction projects. This policy ensured that black Americans, who comprised ten percent of the US population, would receive ten percent of the jobs created by federal programmes.
By 1940, the results were impressive – black Americans occupied one-third of all housing units built by the PWA housing division. This represented a substantial improvement in living conditions for thousands of black American families who gained access to modern, publicly funded housing.
The racial quota system was groundbreaking for the 1930s, as it was one of the first federal policies designed to ensure proportional representation of black Americans in government programmes. The fact that black Americans eventually occupied one-third of PWA housing units (well above their ten percent population share) demonstrates the success of this progressive approach.
The Works Progress Administration
The Works Progress Administration (WPA), led by Harry Hopkins, became the largest relief agency established by the New Deal and provided crucial support to black American communities.
Employment and economic relief
Between 1936 and 1940, the WPA consistently provided employment for 350,000 black Americans every year. This represented a massive injection of income into black communities during the Depression, helping families survive economically during the worst economic crisis in American history. The WPA's scale meant it touched the lives of millions of black Americans either directly or indirectly.
Educational programmes
Beyond simple employment, the WPA made significant contributions to education within black communities. The agency employed over 5,000 black American teachers, providing professional opportunities for educated black Americans while simultaneously delivering educational services to their communities.
The WPA's literacy programmes were particularly important – they taught 250,000 black Americans how to read and write, addressing the educational disadvantages that resulted from decades of segregation and unequal schooling. This investment in literacy had long-term benefits, enabling black Americans to access better employment opportunities and participate more fully in civic life.
The WPA's educational impact extended far beyond immediate literacy gains. By teaching a quarter of a million black Americans to read and write, the programme helped break cycles of poverty that were perpetuated by illiteracy. These newly literate individuals could access better jobs, help their children with schoolwork, and participate more effectively in civic and political life.
National Youth Administration
The National Youth Administration focused specifically on providing skills training for young people, with particular attention paid to black American youth.
Mary McLeod Bethune, a prominent black American educator and civil rights activist, headed the Negro Affairs Department within the National Youth Administration. Under her leadership, the department provided vocational skills training for 500,000 young black Americans. This training equipped them with practical skills that could lead to employment, helping to break cycles of poverty and limited opportunity.
Bethune's appointment itself was significant – it placed a black American woman in a position of authority within the federal government, and her work had direct, measurable impacts on young black Americans' futures.
The Resettlement Administration and Farm Security Administration
The Resettlement Administration, created in 1935 and later renamed the Farm Security Administration, represented perhaps the most genuinely colour-blind New Deal agency.
Rexford Tugwell's leadership
Placed under the direction of Rexford Tugwell, a close presidential adviser, the Administration was tasked with coordinating New Deal programmes designed to help the rural poor. Tugwell made a conscious effort to run what he called a 'colour blind' administration, meaning he tried to treat black and white Americans equally in distributing aid and resources.
Distribution of rural projects
The Administration's rural projects demonstrated this commitment to racial equality. Of 150 rural projects created, 115 were all-white, nine were all-black, and significantly, 26 were mixed-race projects. The existence of mixed-race projects was particularly progressive for the 1930s, when segregation was the norm across much of America. These projects showed that federal programmes could operate on integrated principles, even in the deeply segregated South.
The creation of 26 mixed-race projects was extraordinarily progressive for the 1930s. In an era when segregation was legally enforced across the South and socially expected in much of the North, these integrated projects demonstrated that racial cooperation was possible and that federal programmes didn't have to perpetuate racial divisions.
Case study: Gee's Bend, Alabama
Case Study: Federal Support for Gee's Bend, Alabama
The all-black community of Gee's Bend, Alabama provides an excellent example of how the Administration helped black communities.
Initial Support: The federal government provided the community with cattle, seeds, and fertiliser to help residents become self-sufficient farmers.
Land Ownership Programme (1937): The Administration purchased land worth $122,000 and subdivided it among the community's black farming population. This gave black families land ownership – a crucial step toward economic independence and security.
Significance: Land ownership was particularly important for black Americans in the South, where most worked as sharecroppers or tenant farmers with no assets of their own. By providing land, the federal government gave these families a foundation for long-term economic stability.
However, the Administration's success was short-lived. In 1938, it lost its federal funding and was forced to close down, ending what had been one of the most racially progressive New Deal agencies.
Historical interpretations
Historians have offered differing assessments of how effectively the New Deal aided black Americans. Understanding these different perspectives helps us evaluate the New Deal's true impact on black communities.
Positive assessment
Vivienne Sanders (2003) emphasised the tangible benefits that New Deal programmes delivered to black Americans. She highlighted that these programmes provided one million jobs, nearly 50,000 public housing units, and both financial assistance and skilled occupations training for half a million black youths. This view stresses the real, material improvements in black Americans' lives.
Critical perspectives
However, other historians have been more critical of Roosevelt's approach to racial issues.
Michael Hiltzik (2011) pointed out that race and racial justice were notably absent from Roosevelt's 1932 Democratic platform and campaign speeches. He noted that when the NAACP sent Roosevelt a questionnaire asking about his views on racial issues, the future president never bothered to respond. This suggests that helping black Americans was not a priority for Roosevelt.
Michael Parrish (1992) offered a balanced assessment. He acknowledged that the New Deal did much in one decade to challenge social status and that it made important contributions. However, he criticised Roosevelt for not doing nearly enough to attack historic patterns of bigotry and discrimination.
Most significantly, Parrish noted that Roosevelt never attempted to change the two most obvious forms of oppression affecting black citizens in the South: segregation and disenfranchisement (the denial of voting rights). This meant that while the New Deal provided economic relief, it did not challenge the fundamental structures of racial inequality.
Exam tips
When answering questions about how the New Deal aided black Americans:
-
Balance your answer: Acknowledge both the genuine benefits and the limitations. The New Deal did help black Americans through employment, housing, and education, but it did not fundamentally challenge segregation or discrimination.
-
Use specific evidence: Include statistics (350,000 WPA jobs annually, 250,000 taught to read and write, one-third of PWA housing units) and named individuals (Weaver, Ickes, Bethune, Tugwell).
-
Consider significance: Think about whether the help provided was sufficient given the scale of problems black Americans faced. Was economic relief enough without addressing civil rights?
-
Include interpretations: Reference different historians' views to show you understand that there are debates about the New Deal's impact on black Americans.
-
Context matters: Remember that these programmes operated within a segregated society, which limited their effectiveness.
Remember!
Key Points to Remember:
-
The New Deal provided significant economic relief to black Americans through employment (WPA gave 350,000 jobs annually) and housing (one-third of PWA housing units by 1940).
-
Key progressive figures like Harold Ickes, Robert Weaver, Mary McLeod Bethune, and Rexford Tugwell used their positions to actively help black Americans, introducing innovations like racial quotas and 'colour blind' administration.
-
Educational programmes were particularly important, with the WPA teaching 250,000 black Americans to read and write, and the National Youth Administration training 500,000 young black Americans in vocational skills.
-
The Resettlement/Farm Security Administration represented the most genuinely racially progressive New Deal agency, creating mixed-race projects and helping communities like Gee's Bend, Alabama, though it was shut down in 1938.
-
Historians debate the New Deal's overall impact: while it provided real material benefits, Roosevelt failed to challenge fundamental structures of segregation and disenfranchisement in the South.