Themes (OCR A-Level English Literature): Revision Notes
Themes
Introduction
Oliver Goldsmith's She Stoops to Conquer is a comedy that explores several interconnected themes central to 18th-century English society. Understanding these themes is essential for analysing the play's social commentary, character development, and dramatic structure. The themes work together to create both humour and meaningful critique of social conventions.
The themes in She Stoops to Conquer don't exist in isolation—they interact and overlap throughout the play, creating a complex web of social commentary. For example, the country versus city theme connects directly to issues of social class, whilst mistaken identity exposes both generational conflicts and class prejudices.
Country versus city
This theme establishes the fundamental tension in the play between rural traditional values and urban modernity. The conflict is immediately introduced through the contrasting views of Mr and Mrs Hardcastle.
Mr Hardcastle's perspective:
- Views London as a centre of foolishness and superficiality
- Represents the traditional country squire, wedded to old customs
- Prefers everything old, including his wife
- Disapproves of the modern, impudent behaviour of his city visitors
- Embodies conservative rural values
Mrs Hardcastle's perspective:
- Fascinated by London fashion and style
- Feels bored and isolated in the country
- Their social circle consists of uninspiring company: Mrs Oddfish (the curate's wife) and Cripplegate (the dancing-master)
- Has never actually visited London but loves to discuss it
- Describes herself and other country people as having no manner at all
- Refers to her husband as a piece of antiquity
Dramatic Demonstration: The Country-City Divide
Act 2 demonstrates this theme most humorously when Mrs Hardcastle questions George Hastings about London manners and current fashions. Despite never having visited the city herself, she desperately seeks information about urban life, revealing her fascination with a world she only knows through hearsay. This scene perfectly captures the irony of her position—simultaneously scorning country life whilst being entirely confined to it.
Historical Literary Context
The country versus city theme has deep roots in English literature. Goldsmith explored this in his poem The Deserted Village (1770), lamenting the decline of traditional rural life. This echoed Thomas Gray's Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard (1751). However, not all writers romanticised country life—George Crabbe's The Village (1783) presented a more realistic view of rural poverty and hardship.
The theme also appeared in earlier Restoration comedies, such as William Wycherley's The Country Wife (1675), showing its enduring relevance to English audiences.
Social class and snobbery
Social stratification permeates every aspect of the play, driving both plot and characterisation. The title itself encapsulates this theme—Kate must stoop (lower her social position) in order to conquer (win Marlow's affections).
The rigid class boundaries of 18th-century England create both the play's central conflict and its primary source of comedy. Characters constantly navigate social hierarchies, judging others by their perceived rank and adjusting their behaviour accordingly.
Examples throughout the play:
-
Hardcastle and servants (Act 2): Hardcastle coaches his servants in proper social behaviour, warning them not to presume equality with the visiting company, who are their betters. This scene emphasises the rigid class boundaries of the period.
-
Hastings and Marlow's snobbery: The London visitors display considerable arrogance when discussing what they believe to be the innkeeper Hardcastle's pretensions, revealing their class prejudices.
-
Kate's courtship strategy: Kate successfully courts Marlow by pretending to be a humble barmaid because he feels more comfortable with women of lower social status. This demonstrates how class restrictions affected even romantic relationships.
-
Mrs Hardcastle's obsession: Mrs Hardcastle is fixated on fashion and style, revealed through her conversation with Hastings about London manners. Her preoccupation reflects how social status was performed through appearance and behaviour.
-
Marlow's rejection: Before Kate reveals her true identity, Marlow dismisses the possibility of marriage because he believes she is a poor relation. This shows how class considerations trumped personal affection in arranged marriages.
Critical Consideration for Analysis
Consider how Marlow's class-based behaviour might affect a modern audience's view of him as a romantic hero. His treatment of those he considers social inferiors reveals unattractive snobbery that complicates his supposedly positive qualities. When analysing the play, ask yourself: Does Goldsmith critique or simply reflect the class attitudes of his time? How does the comedy depend on accepting these class distinctions?
Generational conflict
The clash between generations drives much of the play's action and humour. Young characters rebel against parental authority whilst older characters attempt to control their children, sometimes through deception.
Tony Lumpkin's Rebellion
Tony serves as the primary example of youthful defiance. From his first entrance, he refuses to obey his mother's wishes:
- Insists on visiting the Three Pigeons alehouse despite her disapproval
- Depicted as a barfly who celebrates drinking with his companions
- Plays pranks on his stepfather Hardcastle, whom he calls the old grumbletonian
- Continuously resists his mother's matchmaking attempts with Constance Neville
- Helps the young lovers elope, actively working against parental control
Tony's rebellion is loud, physical, and impossible to ignore—he represents open defiance of parental authority.
Constance Neville's Subtler Rebellion
Constance also defies her aunt Mrs Hardcastle's attempts at matchmaking, though more discreetly than Tony. She conspires with George Hastings to elope and gain control of her inheritance (the jewels Mrs Hardcastle guards). In a letter to Tony, George refers to Mrs Hardcastle as the hag, demonstrating the young people's disrespectful attitude towards their elders.
Unlike Tony's boisterous defiance, Constance employs strategic deception—a more traditionally feminine form of rebellion in 18th-century society.
Parental deception: The conflict isn't one-sided. Mrs Hardcastle and her husband have kept Tony's true age secret to maintain control over him. At the play's conclusion, Tony delights in discovering he has reached legal age and can live independently on his income.
Exception to the pattern: Kate Hardcastle and her father share a warm, trusting relationship. However, even here tensions emerge, particularly in Act 3 when they express strongly contrasting opinions of Charles Marlow.
Thematic Significance
The generational conflict reflects broader social changes in 18th-century England, where young people increasingly challenged traditional authority structures. This wasn't merely a personal or familial issue—it mirrored wider shifts in society as Enlightenment values of individual liberty began to challenge inherited hierarchies and unquestioning obedience to tradition.
Mistaken identity
Mistaken identity serves as the play's central comedic device, generating both humour and social commentary. The theme operates on multiple levels throughout the narrative.
Dramatic Example: Tony's Practical Joke (Act 1, Scene 2)
The theme begins when Tony deliberately misleads the London travellers, Charles Marlow and George Hastings, about local geography. He tells them the Hardcastle residence is an inn, setting in motion the play's primary confusion.
What makes this prank so effective is Marlow's complete conviction—he maintains this mistaken belief throughout most of the play, treating his host as an innkeeper. This single deception creates cascading misunderstandings that drive the entire plot forward.
Kate's disguised identity: Kate exploits mistaken identity to her advantage. In Act 2, Charles Marlow is so bashful he never looks at Kate's face during their first meeting. This peculiarity allows Kate to:
- Pretend to be a barmaid
- Later claim to be a poor relation of the family
- Successfully secure Marlow's affection by stooping in social rank
The title's meaning becomes clear through this strategy—Kate conquers Marlow by adopting a lower social position.
Hardcastle as Innkeeper
Much of the play's humour derives from Hardcastle being mistaken for a humble innkeeper rather than a prosperous country squire. The visitors' rude treatment of their host creates uncomfortable comedy whilst satirising social pretensions. Goldsmith uses this confusion to expose how people's behaviour changes dramatically based on their assumptions about others' social status.
Dramatic Example: The Climactic Confusion (Act 5)
Tony's most outrageous prank involves pretending to escort his mother and Constance to Aunt Pedigree's house at night. Instead, he leads them in circles until they become completely disoriented.
Mrs Hardcastle, thoroughly confused, believes she's about to be assaulted by a highwayman—who is actually her own husband taking his regular nighttime walk. This scene demonstrates how complete disorientation can make even the familiar seem threatening and strange.
Thematic Purpose
The repeated mistaken identities serve a crucial dramatic function: they expose characters' true natures, particularly how they treat those they believe to be social inferiors. When Marlow thinks Kate is a barmaid, his true personality emerges—confident, even bold—contrasting sharply with his bashful behaviour around women of his own class. The comedy thus becomes social critique.
Wit
Wit represents an important theatrical tradition from the Restoration period onwards, appearing prominently in the works of William Wycherley, John Dryden, John Vanbrugh, and George Farquhar.
Definition and Origins
Wit derives from the ancient Greek verb oida, meaning I know. Originally an intellectual concept, wit refers to:
- Intelligence and cleverness
- Facility of understanding
- Quick, perceptive thinking
This intellectual foundation explains wit's connection to humour and laughter in theatrical contexts. Wit wasn't simply about making jokes—it demonstrated mental agility and cultural sophistication.
Rhetorical techniques: Wit often employs specific devices:
- Pithy phrases: Brief, cleverly worded statements
- Antithesis: A rhetorical device creating pointed contrasts
Dramatic Example: Marlow's Witty Antithesis
In Act 2, Marlow demonstrates wit through antithesis:
"An impudent fellow may counterfeit modesty, but I'll be hanged if a modest man can ever counterfeit impudence."
This statement reveals character whilst entertaining through its clever construction—the contrast between impudence and modesty, and the reversal of who can imitate whom. The wit lies not just in the words themselves, but in the logical paradox they present: confidence can fake humility, but true humility cannot convincingly pretend to be confident.
Notice how the statement is both self-aware (Marlow recognises his own modesty as genuine) and self-revealing (he doesn't realise his behaviour with lower-class women contradicts his claim).
Literary significance: Wit served as both entertainment and social commentary in 18th-century comedy, allowing playwrights to make serious points through humorous language.
Key Points to Remember:
-
Country versus city: The play contrasts traditional rural values (Mr Hardcastle) with urban sophistication (Mrs Hardcastle), reflecting broader social tensions in 18th-century England.
-
Social class: Class distinctions drive the plot, particularly through Kate's strategy of stooping (lowering her social position) to conquer Marlow's affections.
-
Generational conflict: Young characters like Tony Lumpkin and Constance Neville rebel against parental authority, whilst parents sometimes deceive their children to maintain control.
-
Mistaken identity: The play's central comedic device—Marlow mistakes the Hardcastle home for an inn, Kate disguises her identity, and confusion reigns—exposes characters' true natures and social prejudices.
-
Wit: Intellectual cleverness expressed through pithy phrases and rhetorical devices like antithesis, connecting the play to Restoration comedy traditions whilst providing both humour and insight.