Texts that Argue or Persuade (AQA GCSE English Language): Revision Notes
Texts that argue or persuade
Understanding argumentative and persuasive writing
Many texts you'll encounter in your GCSE reading exam are designed to argue a point or persuade readers to take action. While these two purposes might seem different, they actually share many similarities in how writers craft their language and structure their ideas.
Understanding the difference between arguing and persuading is crucial for analysing texts effectively. Both techniques use similar language strategies, but their end goals differ significantly.
The connection between arguing and persuading
Writers who want to argue a point are trying to make you agree with their opinion. They'll use clear and forceful language to present their viewpoint, often backing up their arguments with facts and figures to make their case more convincing.
Persuasive writing, on the other hand, aims to get you to do something specific - perhaps support a charity, change your behaviour, or buy a product. Writers achieve this by using emotive language designed to make you sympathise with their cause or feel strongly about their message.
When writers want to persuade you, they can sometimes be quite sneaky about their true intentions. They might present their opinion as if it's an obvious fact, using phrases like "It is clear that..." to make their viewpoint sound more authoritative than it actually is. This technique makes their writing appear informative when it's actually trying to persuade you.
Language techniques in argumentative and persuasive texts
Rhetorical devices
Writers frequently employ rhetorical devices to make their arguments more powerful and memorable. Understanding these techniques helps you analyse how writers influence their readers.
Common Rhetorical Devices:
- Hyperbole: Exaggerated statements that emphasise a point
- Repetition: Repeating key words or phrases to reinforce the message
-
- Rhetorical questions: Questions that don't require an answer but make the reader think
Analysing language choices
When examining how writers use language to influence readers, you should consider several key aspects:
Facts and figures: Writers often include statistics and data to support their arguments and make them appear more credible and authoritative.
Emotive vocabulary: Words are carefully chosen to create emotional responses in readers, making them more likely to agree with the writer's viewpoint.
Personal connection: Writers use personal pronouns like "you" and "we" to establish a direct relationship with readers, making their message feel more relevant and personal.
Worked Example: Breakfast Article Analysis
Consider how a writer might argue for the importance of eating breakfast:
Step 1: Compelling opening They could start with a headline like "Why bother with breakfast?" to immediately engage readers.
Step 2: Establishing credibility The writer presents facts confidently, positioning themselves as knowledgeable about nutrition and health.
Step 3: Using rhetorical questions They might ask: "Are we too busy commuting, getting the kids ready for school, blow-drying our hair?" to address readers' potential objections directly.
Step 4: Creating personal connection By using "you" throughout, the writer makes readers feel personally addressed.
Step 5: Emotional language Describing skipping breakfast as "reckless and irresponsible" uses emotive adjectives to encourage an emotional response rather than just presenting logical arguments.
Step 6: Framing the message The writer challenges readers' actions without seeming confrontational by presenting advice rather than criticism.
Identifying persuasive techniques
When analysing persuasive texts, look for how writers employ these strategies to influence their audience. The most effective persuasive writing combines logical arguments with emotional appeals, making readers both think and feel strongly about the writer's message.
Key Strategies to Identify:
- Present their opinions as facts
- Use authoritative language to sound knowledgeable
- Include emotional appeals alongside logical arguments
- Address readers directly to create personal connection
- Choose specific vocabulary to influence how readers feel about the topic
Key Points to Remember:
- Argumentative texts want you to agree with an opinion, while persuasive texts want you to take action
- Writers use clear, forceful language combined with emotive vocabulary to influence readers
- Rhetorical devices like repetition, hyperbole, and rhetorical questions make arguments more memorable
- Personal pronouns create connection between writer and reader
- Effective persuasive writing presents opinions as facts and uses authoritative language to build credibility