Sexual relationships (AQA GCSE Religious Studies A): Revision Notes
Sexual relationships
Understanding Catholic teachings about sexual relationships is essential for grasping how the Church views marriage, family life, and human sexuality. These teachings are rooted in biblical scripture and Church doctrine, though there are varying perspectives within Christianity on some issues.
It's important to remember that while this document focuses on Catholic teachings, Christianity encompasses many denominations with varying interpretations of these same biblical texts and moral principles.
Catholic teachings on relationships
The Catholic Church has clear teachings about what types of relationships it supports and why these teachings exist. These positions form the foundation of Catholic moral theology regarding human sexuality and marriage.
Support for heterosexual relationships
The Catholic Church fully supports heterosexual relationships, particularly within marriage. This support is based on fundamental biblical teachings about the nature of marriage and human relationships.
The Church teaches that marriage creates a profound unity between husband and wife, as expressed in Genesis: "A man leaves his father and mother and is united to his wife, and they become one flesh" (Genesis 2:24). This verse establishes the biblical foundation for heterosexual marriage as God's intended design.
According to the Catechism of the Catholic Church, "In marriage the physical intimacy of the spouses becomes a sign and pledge of spiritual communion" (CCC 2360). This means that sexual intimacy within marriage is not just physical but represents a deeper spiritual bond between the couple.
Opposition to homosexual relationships
The Catholic Church does not support homosexual relationships, basing this position on biblical teachings and the Church's understanding of the purpose of sexuality.
The primary reason given is that the Church teaches the purpose of sex is procreation, as referenced in Genesis 2:24. Since homosexual couples cannot naturally have children together, the Church views this as contrary to God's design for human sexuality and marriage.
Biblical teachings also influence this position, with the Church pointing to verses such as Leviticus 18:22: "Do not have sexual relations with a man as one does with a woman; that is detestable." The Church interprets this as a clear biblical prohibition against homosexual relationships.
Catholic attitudes to homosexuality
Within Christianity, there are different perspectives on homosexuality, leading to varied approaches among believers. Understanding these different viewpoints helps explain why Catholics may hold varying personal beliefs even within the same faith tradition.
Traditional Catholic position
Traditional Catholic Perspective
Some Catholics hold firm to traditional teachings, believing that these principles are unchanging divine commands that must be followed regardless of cultural shifts or personal feelings.
Traditional Catholics maintain that:
- Sex is a gift from God that should only take place between husband and wife within marriage
- Same-sex partners cannot have children naturally, which contradicts what they see as marriage's primary purpose
- Homosexuality undermines the traditional family unit that the Church believes is central to society
Alternative Christian perspectives
Other Christians, including some Catholics, take a different approach, emphasising other biblical teachings that focus on love, acceptance, and human dignity.
Progressive Christian Perspective
These Christians often argue that the Bible's core message of love and acceptance should take precedence over specific prohibitive passages, especially when understood in their historical and cultural context.
Alternative perspectives include:
- They believe that homosexuality is natural and part of how God created some people
- They point to the teaching that all humans were created in God's image, regardless of sexual orientation
- They emphasise that love between all people, including same-sex couples, should be celebrated rather than condemned
- They highlight Jesus's teaching to "Love your neighbour as yourself" (Matthew 22:39) as a call to respect everyone
It's worth noting that UK law changed significantly in this area - homosexuality was illegal until 1967, and in 2013, the law was changed to allow same-sex couples to marry in churches if the minister agrees.
Sex before marriage
Catholic teaching on sexual relationships before marriage is clear and based on both biblical instruction and Church tradition. The Church's position emphasises the importance of marriage as the proper context for sexual intimacy.
Traditional Catholic position
The Church teaches that sexual relationships should wait until after marriage. This position is supported by St Paul's teachings that sexual relationships before marriage (often called pre-marital sex) are wrong.
Many Christians choose to take a vow of chastity, promising not to have sex until after they are married. This demonstrates their commitment to following Church teachings and their belief in the sacred nature of marriage.
Catholics also believe that procreation (having children) is a key purpose of marriage, and that marriage provides the stable, committed environment that children need to thrive.
Liberal Christian views
Some more liberal Christians take a different approach, believing that if a couple are in a long-term, committed relationship and intend to marry in the future, then a sexual relationship can be acceptable as a form of commitment, even before the formal marriage ceremony.
Sex outside marriage (adultery)
The Catholic Church teaches that adultery - having sexual relationships outside of marriage - is always wrong, regardless of circumstances. This teaching represents one of the Church's most absolute moral positions.
Why adultery is forbidden
This teaching is rooted in the Ten Commandments, where adultery is explicitly forbidden as one of the fundamental moral laws. The Church views this as a direct commandment from God that cannot be compromised.
The Bible teaches that marriage creates a sacred union between husband and wife. When couples make marriage vows, they promise to be faithful to each other. Breaking these vows through adultery violates this sacred commitment.
The Sacramental Nature of Marriage
The Catechism explains the importance of faithfulness in marriage: "The Sacrament of Matrimony enables man and woman to enter into Christ's fidelity for his Church. Through conjugal chastity, they bear witness to this mystery before the world" (CCC 2365).
Conjugal chastity refers to married couples being loyal and faithful to each other, avoiding any sexual relationships outside their marriage. This faithfulness is seen as reflecting Christ's faithful love for the Church.
Non-religious perspectives
It's important to understand that not everyone shares religious views on sexual relationships. Non-religious believers often have very different approaches to these issues, typically focusing on personal autonomy and consent rather than religious doctrine.
Secular Approach to Sexual Ethics
Non-religious perspectives generally emphasise individual freedom, consent, and harm prevention rather than adherence to religious teachings or traditional moral frameworks.
Many non-religious people argue that consenting adults should be free to have sexual relationships with whomever they choose, provided it doesn't harm anyone. They typically don't see heterosexual and homosexual relationships as different in terms of moral acceptability.
From this perspective, many non-religious people see sexual relationships outside marriage as acceptable, arguing that the commitment and love between people matters more than formal marriage ceremonies.
Key Points to Remember:
-
Catholic marriage foundation: The Church supports heterosexual marriage based on Genesis 2:24, viewing it as God's design for human relationships and the proper context for sexual intimacy.
-
Divided Christian views on homosexuality: While traditional Catholics oppose homosexual relationships citing biblical teachings and procreation purposes, other Christians emphasise love, acceptance, and Jesus's teaching to "love your neighbour as yourself."
-
Sexual purity teachings: Catholics traditionally teach that sex should wait until marriage, with some taking vows of chastity, though liberal Christians may accept committed pre-marital relationships.
-
Adultery as sacred violation: The Church views adultery as always wrong because it breaks the sacred marriage vows and violates the faithful union that marriage represents, as outlined in the Ten Commandments.
-
Scriptural authority: Catholic teachings on sexual relationships are heavily based on biblical quotations from Genesis, Leviticus, Matthew, and Church Catechism teachings that provide the theological foundation for these beliefs.