Assessing the Controversy

Why did controversy arise from the siting of a new university at Coleraine?

• The decision to place the new university in Coleraine was considered discriminatory by the Catholic community, especially those in Derry/Londonderry.

  • Many felt that Derry/Londonderry, as the second-largest city and economically disadvantaged, was more deserving of the university.
  • The nationalist community believed the decision was politically motivated and intended to favour the Protestant-dominated area of Coleraine.

• The decision highlighted the ongoing economic and social neglect of the western, predominantly Catholic regions of Northern Ireland.

• Protests erupted in Derry/Londonderry, with locals feeling betrayed and further marginalised by the government's choice.

• The controversy fed into the broader civil rights movement, which was already gaining momentum in response to perceived injustices.

• The issue deepened sectarian divides, as nationalists saw the decision as part of a pattern of unionist policies aimed at maintaining Protestant dominance.

Why was Coleraine, instead of Derry, chosen as the site of a second university in NI?

• The Lockwood Committee, tasked with deciding the site, recommended Coleraine due to its perceived neutrality and potential for expansion.
• Coleraine was seen as more politically stable and less divisive than Derry/Londonderry, which had a history of sectarian tension.
• The committee argued that Coleraine offered a more conducive environment for academic development, away from the political pressures in Derry/Londonderry.
• There were concerns that placing the university in Derry/Londonderry might exacerbate existing sectarian conflicts in the city.
• Unionists within the government and influential groups like the "Faceless Men" likely supported Coleraine to avoid strengthening the nationalist influence in Derry/Londonderry.
• Practical considerations, such as the availability of land and the potential for future expansion in Coleraine, also influenced the decision.
• The recommendation aimed to avoid making Derry/Londonderry a focal point for nationalist aspirations, which could threaten the unionist status quo.

What was the impact of choosing Coleraine as the site of Northern Ireland's second university?

• The decision to site the university in Coleraine led to widespread protests in Derry/Londonderry, deepening sectarian tensions.
• Nationalists viewed the decision as further evidence of discrimination and marginalisation, fuelling the civil rights movement.
• The controversy contributed to a growing sense of alienation and anger in the Catholic community, exacerbating political unrest.
• The choice reinforced the economic divide between the Protestant-dominated east and the predominantly Catholic west of Northern Ireland.
• The backlash against the decision weakened the position of Prime Minister Terence O'Neill, contributing to his eventual resignation.
  • The controversy over the university became a symbol of the broader struggle for equality and fair treatment in Northern Ireland.
  • The decision had long-term implications for Northern Irish politics, as it highlighted the deep-rooted issues of discrimination and inequality that would eventually lead to the Troubles.