Discursive Essay (Grade 10 NSC Matric English FAL): Revision Notes
Discursive Essay
Understanding discursive essays
A discursive essay is a type of writing where you explore multiple perspectives on a particular topic or issue. The main goal is to present different viewpoints in a fair and balanced way. Unlike persuasive essays where you try to convince the reader of one side, in a discursive essay you examine both sides of an argument before sharing your own conclusion.
The word "discursive" comes from "discuss," which means you need to have a thorough conversation about the topic, looking at it from different angles. This type of essay helps develop critical thinking skills because you must understand and explain arguments you might not personally agree with.
Developing the ability to understand and articulate viewpoints you disagree with is a valuable life skill that extends beyond essay writing. It helps you become a more empathetic listener and a more persuasive communicator in debates and discussions.
Essential features of a discursive essay
A successful discursive essay must demonstrate five key characteristics that work together to create a balanced and credible piece of writing:
Balanced discussion
This means you must explore both sides of the topic fairly and give equal attention to different viewpoints. You cannot focus only on the side you agree with. For example, if discussing whether school uniforms should be compulsory, you need to present strong arguments both for and against uniforms, even if you personally have a preference.
Formal tone
Your writing must maintain a neutral and objective tone throughout. This means avoiding emotional language, slang, or personal anecdotes. Instead of writing "I really hate uniforms because they're boring," you would write "Some students argue that uniforms limit personal expression and creativity."
Logical structure
All your ideas must be well-organised and presented in a clear, easy-to-follow manner. Each paragraph should connect smoothly to the next, and your arguments should build upon each other logically. Readers should be able to follow your thinking from start to finish without confusion.
Evidence-based arguments
Every claim you make must be supported with facts, examples, statistics, or logical reasoning. You cannot simply state opinions without backing them up. For instance, instead of saying "Many students dislike uniforms," you might write "According to a 2022 survey of 500 learners, 65% reported feeling that uniforms restrict their ability to express themselves."
Notice how specific evidence strengthens an argument. The concrete statistic (65% of 500 learners) is far more convincing than a vague claim about "many students." Always aim for this level of specificity in your own writing.
Impartial approach
An impartial approach means you stay neutral for most of the essay. You explore different viewpoints objectively without revealing your personal bias. Your own opinion should typically appear only at the end, in the conclusion, after you have thoroughly discussed both sides. This shows that you have carefully considered all perspectives before forming your viewpoint.
The impartial approach is what distinguishes a discursive essay from a persuasive essay. Revealing your bias too early or showing favouritism toward one side will weaken your essay and reduce your credibility as a balanced thinker.
Structure of a discursive essay
Every discursive essay follows a standard three-part structure that helps organise your ideas effectively.
Introduction
The introduction serves three important purposes. First, it introduces the issue or topic you will be discussing. Make sure your reader understands exactly what question or problem you are exploring.
Second, explain why this topic matters. Why should readers care about this issue? What makes it important or relevant to society, education, or daily life?
Third, provide a brief overview of the different perspectives you will examine. This gives your reader a roadmap for what to expect in the body of your essay. For example: "This essay will explore arguments both supporting and opposing compulsory school uniforms before presenting a concluding viewpoint."
Body paragraphs
The body of your essay is where you present the different arguments in detail. You should aim for at least two to three well-developed paragraphs:
First body paragraph presents arguments supporting one side of the topic. For example, if your topic is school uniforms, this paragraph might discuss how uniforms promote equality, create a sense of belonging, and eliminate distractions related to fashion.
Second body paragraph presents arguments supporting the opposite viewpoint. Continuing with the uniform example, this paragraph might explore how uniforms can be expensive for families, limit students' freedom of expression, and may not actually improve discipline as claimed.
Third body paragraph (optional) can provide further discussion, explore additional perspectives, or examine the issue from a different angle. For example, you might discuss how the uniform debate varies across different cultural contexts.
Each paragraph must include specific examples, facts, or supporting evidence to strengthen your arguments. Simply listing opinions is not enough. Use concrete details to make your points convincing and credible.
Conclusion
Your conclusion brings your essay to a close effectively. First, summarise the key points you have discussed in the body paragraphs. Briefly remind readers of the main arguments from both sides.
Second, clearly state your own viewpoint based on the discussion you have presented. Which side do you find more convincing, or do you believe there is a middle ground? Your opinion should feel like a natural result of the evidence and reasoning you have explored.
Avoid introducing new arguments in the conclusion. This section is for summarising and concluding, not for adding fresh information that has not been discussed earlier. New arguments belong in the body paragraphs only.
Steps to writing a discursive essay
Follow this five-step process to produce a well-crafted discursive essay:
Step 1: Choose a topic
Select an issue that is controversial or debatable. The topic should have clear arguments on both sides, not an obvious right or wrong answer. Good discursive essay topics often involve moral dilemmas, policy decisions, or social debates.
Examples of suitable topics include: "Should social media be banned in schools?" or "Is climate change the biggest threat to humanity?" Notice how both questions can be answered in different ways with valid reasoning.
Step 2: Plan your essay
Before you start writing, take time to plan thoroughly. Use a mind map or table to organise arguments for and against your topic. Draw a line down the middle of your page and list supporting arguments on one side and opposing arguments on the other.
Research and gather facts, examples, and statistics to support both sides. Even if you already have a personal opinion, you must find credible evidence for the opposing view as well.
Finally, arrange your arguments in a logical order. Decide which points to present first and how they will flow into each other. Strong planning makes the actual writing much easier.
Planning Tip:
Spend at least 10-15 minutes planning before you begin writing. Time spent planning is never wasted—it will save you time during the writing and editing stages, and it will result in a more coherent, well-structured essay.
Step 3: Write the first draft
Begin with a strong introduction that clearly introduces the issue you will discuss. Make sure your opening captures the reader's attention and explains why the topic matters.
Use clear and structured paragraphs to present the different viewpoints. Each paragraph should focus on one main idea with supporting details. Use topic sentences to introduce each paragraph's focus.
Throughout your draft, maintain a formal and objective tone. Avoid words like "I think" or "in my opinion" until the conclusion. Instead, use phrases like "Some argue that..." or "Research suggests that..."
Step 4: Edit and proofread
Once your first draft is complete, review it carefully for errors. Check your spelling, grammar, and punctuation. Read your essay aloud to catch awkward phrasing or run-on sentences.
Ensure that both sides of the argument are presented fairly. Have you given equal attention and strong evidence to each perspective? If one side is much weaker than the other, your essay will seem biased.
Improve the clarity and coherence of your arguments. Do your paragraphs flow smoothly? Are your transitions effective? Does each point connect logically to the next?
Step 5: Write the final version
Make any final corrections and adjustments based on your editing. Polish any sentences that still sound unclear or awkward.
Ensure your essay meets the word limit requirement of 250-300 words. Count your words carefully. If you are over the limit, cut unnecessary words or repetitive information. If you are under the limit, add more detail or examples where needed.
Finally, cross out your draft and submit the neat final version. Make sure your handwriting is legible if writing by hand, or that your formatting is clean if typing.
Example topic breakdown
Let's examine how you might approach the topic: "Should school uniforms be compulsory?"
Worked Example: Structuring a Discursive Essay on School Uniforms
Introduction: Your introduction would present the ongoing debate about school uniforms. You might mention that this issue affects millions of learners worldwide and touches on questions of equality, self-expression, and school culture.
Body paragraphs:
- Arguments for uniforms might include: uniforms promote discipline and focus on learning, they reduce peer pressure related to clothing and fashion, and they create a sense of school identity and belonging.
- Arguments against uniforms might include: uniforms limit self-expression and individuality, and they can be expensive for some families who struggle to afford specific items.
Conclusion: After presenting both sides, you would state your own viewpoint based on the discussion. You might conclude that uniforms have benefits but schools should consider affordability for all families, or you might argue for a different approach that balances structure with personal expression.
Quality checklist for your discursive essay
Before submitting your essay, use this checklist to ensure you have met all the requirements:
-
Does your essay discuss both sides of the issue fairly? Check that you have given equal space and strong evidence to both perspectives.
-
Are examples and evidence used to support your arguments? Ensure every major point is backed up with facts, statistics, examples, or logical reasoning.
-
Is the structure clear with an introduction, body, and conclusion? Your essay should follow the standard format with each section serving its proper purpose.
-
Does your writing maintain a formal and neutral tone? Remove any overly emotional language, slang, or personal stories that do not fit an academic essay.
-
Are grammar, punctuation, and spelling correct? Proofread carefully to eliminate errors that can distract from your arguments and reduce your credibility.
Exam Success Tip:
Avoid being overly emotional or biased in your writing. Your goal is to present facts and reasoning, not to passionately argue for one side while dismissing the other. A calm, analytical approach will earn higher marks than an emotional, one-sided argument. Think of yourself as a balanced journalist presenting different viewpoints rather than a campaigner trying to win people over to your side.
Key Points to Remember:
- A discursive essay explores different viewpoints on a controversial issue in a balanced and fair manner.
- You must present both sides of the argument with equal attention and strong evidence before stating your own opinion in the conclusion.
- Maintain a formal, neutral, and objective tone throughout—avoid emotional language and personal anecdotes.
- Follow the standard structure: introduction (present the issue), body (arguments for and against), and conclusion (summarise and state your viewpoint).
- Always support your claims with facts, examples, statistics, or logical reasoning—never rely on unsupported opinions.
- Your essay should be 250-300 words and demonstrate clear organisation, proper grammar, and correct spelling.