Non-Religious Worldviews (HSC SSCE Studies of Religion): Revision Notes
Non-Religious Worldviews
Introduction to non-religious worldviews
Religion is becoming less central to modern society, and holding a non-religious worldview is increasingly common. A worldview is an ideological framework for understanding the world and its people. In the 2016 Australian census, 30.1% of people reported having no religious affiliation or holding secular or spiritual beliefs outside traditional religion.
This represents a significant shift in how modern societies understand meaning, purpose, and ethics outside traditional religious frameworks.
Several distinct perspectives fall under the umbrella of non-religious worldviews, each with different philosophical foundations and approaches to questions of existence, meaning and ethics.
Atheism
Definition and origins
Atheism is the doctrine that there is no evidence for the existence of God or gods. The term derives from Greek: a (negation) and theos (God). An atheist is someone who consciously rejects belief in deities.
Key Distinction: Atheism differs from agnosticism (discussed below). While agnostics claim uncertainty about God's existence, atheists actively reject the concept based on lack of evidence.
Notable atheists
Contemporary atheists include:
- David Suzuki (environmentalist)
- Wil Anderson and Ricky Gervais (comedians)
- Jodie Foster (actor)
- Björk (singer)
- Peter Singer and Richard Dawkins (scientists)
Historical development in the West
Ancient Greece and Rome
The first signs of atheistic thinking in Western civilisation emerged with:
Epicurus (c. 340–270 BCE): A Greek philosopher who suggested that even if gods exist, they play no role in human affairs.
Lucretius (c. 100–55 BCE): A Roman poet who celebrated Epicurus' ideas. Lucretius attempted to explain all natural phenomena through human reason alone, without reference to divine intervention. He argued that:
- The soul does not exist
- Death should not be feared
- Life should focus on maximising wellbeing for oneself and others
This approach became known as humanism – a philosophy emphasising the importance of human beings. While Lucretius believed gods existed, he advocated living an atheistic life that does not consider the will of gods.
Eastern perspectives on atheism
Atheistic thinking has deep roots in Eastern philosophy:
Buddhism: Early Buddhist texts from India (c. 2500 years ago) show the Buddha debated with those who rejected gods. However, the Buddha himself was likely agnostic – gods may exist, but are unnecessary for achieving enlightenment. It is possible to be Buddhist without believing in gods.
Confucianism: China has maintained a long tradition of atheistic thought stemming from Confucius' teachings (551–479 BCE).
The atheism-as-faith debate
Some argue that atheism is itself a faith system – if one can believe in God, one can equally believe in God's non-existence.
The Atheist Response
Atheists counter this by arguing that:
- Unproven propositions (including religious claims) cannot be rationally supported
- The unprovability of God's existence does not make belief and disbelief equally likely
- Atheism is based on evidence and reason, not faith
Agnosticism
Definition and meaning
Agnosticism is the position that it is impossible to know whether God, gods or spirits exist. The term derives from Greek: a (negation) and gnosis (knowledge).
Agnostics neither believe nor disbelieve in God's existence. Unlike atheism's definite rejection of deity, agnosticism maintains that:
- The question of God's existence is unknowable
- If evidence for God were proven, agnostics would reconsider their position
- The relevance of God to daily life is questionable
Thomas Henry Huxley and the creation of the term
Thomas Henry Huxley (1869) coined the term "agnostic". Known as "Darwin's bulldog" for his vigorous promotion of evolutionary theory, Huxley believed rejecting spiritual knowledge was consistent with modern scientific progress.
Huxley explained his reasoning:
"When I reached intellectual maturity, and began to ask myself whether I was an atheist, a theist, or a pantheist; a materialist or an idealist; a Christian or a freethinker, I found that the more I learned and reflected, the less ready was the answer; until at last I came to the conclusion that I had neither art nor part with any of these denominations, except the last. The one thing in which most of these good people were agreed was the one thing in which I differed from them. They were quite sure that they had attained a certain 'gnosis' – had more or less successfully solved the problem of existence; while I was quite sure I had not, and had a pretty strong conviction that the problem was insoluble."
Intellectual Humility
Huxley argued that claims to certain knowledge about existence – whether religious or philosophical – were presumptuous. His agnosticism was rooted in intellectual humility rather than rejection of spirituality itself.
Humanism
General definition
Humanism is a philosophy of life emphasising the human spirit and the dignity of human beings. It focuses on human capacity, reason and ethics rather than divine revelation or supernatural authority.
Not all humanism is non-religious. Different types include:
- Literary humanism
- Secular humanism
- Rational humanism
- Scientific humanism
Eastern roots: Confucianism
Confucius' philosophy
Confucius (551–479 BCE) was China's greatest philosopher, living during a turbulent period in Chinese history. His system of good government appears in the Analects, a collection of questions and answers.
Confucius neither accepted nor denied gods and spirits, viewing them as irrelevant to society's proper functioning. A famous exchange from the Analects (11.12) illustrates this:
The Analects on Spirits and Death
Chi-Lu asked how the spirits of the dead and the gods should be served.
The Master said, 'You are not even able to serve man. How can you serve the spirits?'
'May I ask about death?'
[Confucius replied] 'You do not even understand life. How can you understand death?'
This demonstrates Confucius' focus on practical human concerns over metaphysical speculation.
The concept of ren
Confucius taught that ren (loving kindness) should guide society. The wise and educated should use ren to create social harmony. Importantly:
- Ren does not derive from deity
- It is simply the most effective approach to governance
- It draws on wisdom of ancient sages adapted to present circumstances
This represents early humanist thinking – creating good society through human wisdom and compassion rather than divine command.
European Enlightenment
Transmission from East to West
From the 1500s, Jesuit missionaries sent reports about Chinese philosophy back to Europe. Europeans were fascinated by the humanistic nature of Confucian thought. Chinese ideas merged with Classical humanism from Greece and Rome.
Voltaire and the Age of Reason
Voltaire (1694–1778) was the outstanding figure of the European Enlightenment. He celebrated both:
- Confucius' open, humanistic attitude
- Classical humanism from Greece and Rome
The Enlightenment period experienced:
- Decreased religious fanaticism and superstition
- Increased rationalism and humanism
- Growing atheism
Rational humanism
Core principles
Rational humanism (often identified with secular humanism) emphasises human reason as the source of answers to life's questions. Key features include:
Reason over revelation: Rational humanists prioritise human reasoning over religious revelation. They accept God and religion only if arrived at through rational thought.
Human-centred ethics: Rational humanists live moral lives not because of belief in God or religious rules, but because of respect for human life and dignity.
Emphasis on human thought: All aspects of life, including belief and behaviour, should be guided by rational reasoning.
Moral foundation
Positive behaviour is encouraged because:
- Human beings have inherent importance
- Treating others well demonstrates respect
- Rationally and reasonably, ethical behaviour is the best approach
This represents a shift from religiously-motivated morality to ethics grounded in human reason and mutual respect.
Scientific humanism
Definition and approach
While rational humanism prioritises reason over revelation, scientific humanism asserts that reality can only be discovered through scientific research and experimentation.
Julian Huxley (T.H. Huxley's grandson) argued it is futile to seek answers about life's meaning using terms like "cause," "creation," "ultimate" or "reality" – concepts typically central to religion. Instead, people should adopt a scientific-based philosophy.
Core beliefs
Scientific rationalism/humanism holds that:
- Reality consists only of what can be touched, measured or numbered
- Intangible things (emotion, beauty, thought) should not be regarded as knowledge or truth
- Observable, testable phenomena are the only valid sources of understanding
Carl Sagan's perspective
Carl Sagan (1934–1996), a prominent scientific rationalist, accepted the possibility of spirituality by comparing it to breath, which he regarded as "matter." He stated:
"Science is not only compatible with spirituality; it is a profound source of spirituality … The notion that science and spirituality are somehow mutually exclusive does a profound disservice to both."
Ethical foundation
Scientific humanism views ethical behaviour as emerging from:
- Proven patterns of behaviour over time
- Experimentation and experience showing ethical conduct benefits individuals and humanity
- Observable outcomes rather than religious motivation
Important consideration
Ethics and Scientific Progress
As science explores new fields, ethical considerations must not be overridden by what is scientifically possible. Scientific capability does not automatically justify scientific action.
Key distinctions between worldviews
The following table summarizes the key differences between non-religious worldviews in terms of their stance on deity, ethics, and sources of knowledge:
| Worldview | Position on God/gods | Basis for ethics | Knowledge source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Atheism | Active rejection; no evidence for God's existence | Human dignity and reason | Reason and evidence |
| Agnosticism | Cannot know if God exists; question is unknowable | Human dignity and reason | Recognition of knowledge limits |
| Rational humanism | Accept only if proven by reason; may or may not be religious | Respect for human life and dignity | Human reasoning |
| Scientific humanism | Focus on material reality rather than divine questions | Proven patterns from experimentation | Scientific method |
Remember!
Key Points to Remember:
-
Atheism actively rejects belief in God based on lack of evidence; has roots in both Western (Epicurus, Lucretius) and Eastern (Buddhism, Confucianism) philosophy
-
Agnosticism maintains that God's existence is unknowable; term coined by T.H. Huxley in 1869 as a position of intellectual humility
-
Humanism emphasises human dignity, reason and ethics over divine authority; Eastern traditions (especially Confucianism with its concept of ren) developed humanistic thought independently
-
Rational humanism prioritises human reason over religious revelation as the source of knowledge and ethical behaviour
-
Scientific humanism limits valid knowledge to what can be measured, tested and observed through scientific methodology; ethical behaviour derives from proven patterns rather than religious commands