Criminal Law and Civil Law (VCE SSCE Legal Studies): Revision Notes
Criminal Law and Civil Law
Introduction to types of law
Australian law can be classified in different ways. One important way is by looking at what type of behaviour the law regulates and what happens if someone breaks it. This classification gives us two main types of law: criminal law and civil law. Both types work together to maintain order in society, but they serve different purposes and have different outcomes.
Criminal law
What is criminal law?
Criminal law is the area of law that protects society as a whole by defining what behaviours are prohibited and setting out penalties for people who commit these offences. When we talk about criminal law, we're talking about actions (or failures to act) that harm not just individuals, but society at large.
A crime is an act someone does, or something they fail to do, that breaks the law. Crimes are considered harmful to both individuals and the community, and the state has the power to punish people who commit them. Common examples include murder, theft, and assault.
Consequences in criminal law
What makes criminal law distinctive is what happens when someone commits a crime. If a person is found guilty of a criminal offence, the court imposes a sanction (a penalty). Sanctions vary in severity:
- Minor sanctions: Small fines for less serious offences
- Severe sanctions: Imprisonment (being locked up in prison) for serious crimes
The type of sanction depends on how serious the crime is and other factors the court considers, such as the offender's criminal history, whether they showed remorse, and any mitigating circumstances.
Parties in criminal cases
Criminal cases involve two parties:
-
The prosecution: This is the legal team representing the state or Crown. They bring the case against the person accused of the crime. Their job is to prove that the accused person committed the crime.
-
The accused: This is the person charged with committing the crime. Note that this term is used before the person is found guilty. If they are found guilty or plead guilty, we then call them an offender.
Being accused doesn't mean guilty – a person is only an offender once guilt has been established. This distinction is fundamental to the principle of "innocent until proven guilty" in our justice system.
Examples of criminal offences
Criminal law covers many different types of offences:
- Crimes against the person: assault, manslaughter, murder
- Crimes against property: theft, property damage, robbery, deception
- Drug offences: trafficking, use, and possession of drugs
- Public order offences: disorderly conduct, public nuisance
- Justice procedure offences: breaching court orders
Key criminal law terminology
When reading about criminal cases, you'll encounter specific terms:
- Prosecution/prosecutor: The party bringing the case on behalf of the state
- Accused: The person charged with an offence
- Offender: Someone found guilty or who pleaded guilty
- Suspect: A person suspected of committing a crime (before being charged)
- Guilty/not guilty: The possible outcomes of a criminal trial
- Charge: The formal allegation by police that someone committed a crime
- Sanction: The penalty imposed by the court
- Conviction: A guilty verdict that goes on the person's criminal record (though courts sometimes choose not to record a conviction)
Real case example: DPP v Bednar
Worked Example: DPP v Bednar (2023)
This Victorian Supreme Court case illustrates how criminal law works in practice. A 53-year-old man was charged with murdering his 78-year-old mother.
Case Details:
- The accused had a troubled relationship with his mother and declining mental health
- Prior to the murder, he had engaged in threatening behaviour (turning off her power, smashing her window)
- The prosecution used modern evidence: data from the victim's Fitbit watch showed her sleep pattern and the moment of the attack
- The accused pleaded not guilty and tried to blame someone else
- The jury found him guilty quickly
- The judge noted his lack of remorse and described his actions as "shocking and callous"
- He was sentenced to 29 years imprisonment
What this case demonstrates:
- The state prosecuted on behalf of society
- Evidence was presented to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt
- A significant sanction was imposed to punish the offender and protect the community
Civil law
What is civil law?
Civil law is quite different from criminal law. It's the area of law that regulates disputes between individuals, groups, or organisations. Civil law seeks to enforce people's rights when harm has occurred in private matters.
Civil disputes are private disputes. The police aren't usually involved (unless the state itself is a party to the dispute). Instead, two private parties are in disagreement about rights and responsibilities.
Parties in civil cases
Civil cases involve:
-
The plaintiff: This is the person (or organisation) who makes a legal claim. They believe their rights have been violated and they're seeking a remedy.
-
The defendant: This is the person (or organisation) being sued. The plaintiff alleges that the defendant has infringed their rights in some way.
Areas of civil law
Civil law covers many different areas:
-
Tort law: This includes negligence (when someone's carelessness causes harm), defamation (damaging someone's reputation), trespass (entering someone's property without permission), and nuisance (interfering with someone's use of their property)
-
Contract law: This governs agreements between parties and what happens when agreements are broken
-
Consumer law: Including tenancy agreements, sale of goods and services, and advertising regulations
-
Property law: Including wills, planning laws, and real estate transactions
-
Industrial and workplace laws: Covering occupational health and safety, working conditions, and workplace agreements
The aim of civil law
The main purpose of civil law is to remedy (fix or compensate for) a civil wrong. The goal is to return the person whose rights were violated to the position they were in before the wrong occurred.
This is achieved through remedies. The most common remedy is damages – a sum of money paid by the defendant to the plaintiff to compensate for the harm suffered. Other remedies include injunctions (court orders requiring someone to do something or stop doing something).
Key civil law terminology
Civil cases use different language from criminal cases:
- Plaintiff: The person bringing the dispute
- Defendant: The person defending against the claim
- Sue: To take civil legal action against someone
- Compensation: What the plaintiff is seeking
- Damages: Money awarded to compensate for harm
- Injunction: A court order to do or not do something
- Tort: A civil wrong
- Defamation: Claiming your reputation has been damaged
- Negligence: Claiming injury resulted from someone's careless actions
Real case example: Wilson v Bauer Media
Worked Example: Wilson v Bauer Media (2017)
This high-profile case demonstrates how civil law works in practice.
The Dispute: Australian actor Rebel Wilson sued Bauer Media (a magazine publisher) for defamation. Bauer had published articles about Wilson in 2015 that she claimed contained false statements. Wilson argued that these articles damaged her reputation and cost her acting opportunities.
The Case Process:
- Wilson (plaintiff) sued Bauer Media (defendant)
- Bauer Media denied the claims
- The case went to trial before a jury, lasting three weeks
- In June 2017, the jury found in favour of Wilson – she had been defamed
- In September 2017, Justice Dixon awarded Wilson over $4.5 million in damages
- Bauer Media appealed the damages amount
- On appeal, the damages were reduced to $600,000
- Wilson tried to appeal to the High Court but was unsuccessful
What this case demonstrates:
- It was a private dispute between two parties
- The plaintiff had to prove her case (that she was defamed and suffered loss)
- The remedy was damages (compensation in the form of money)
- Civil cases can go through multiple stages of appeal
The distinction between criminal law and civil law
While both areas of law regulate behaviour, they differ in fundamental ways.
Different aims
Criminal law aims to:
- Protect society as a whole
- Punish wrongdoers who commit crimes
- Deter others from committing similar crimes
Civil law aims to:
- Regulate conduct between parties in disputes
- Remedy (fix) wrongs that have occurred
- Restore the plaintiff to their original position
Different consequences
In criminal cases:
- If the accused is found guilty, they face a sanction
- Sanctions include fines, imprisonment, community correction orders, and other penalties
- The focus is on punishment and deterrence
In civil disputes:
- If the defendant is found liable, they must provide a remedy
- The most common remedy is damages (money)
- Other remedies include injunctions
- The focus is on compensation and restoration
Different parties and procedures
Understanding the different terminology used in criminal and civil law is essential for reading and discussing legal cases correctly.
Criminal law:
- The prosecution (representing the state) brings the case
- They bring it against the accused
- Police are involved in investigating and charging
- The prosecution must prove the case
- Common terms: guilty, innocent, sentence, conviction, arrest, bail
Civil law:
- The plaintiff brings the case
- They bring it against the defendant
- Police are not usually involved (it's a private dispute)
- The plaintiff must prove the case
- Common terms: sue, compensation, liability, damages, litigation
Comparison table
| Feature | Criminal Law | Civil Law |
|---|---|---|
| Aim | Protect society and sanction offenders | Regulate conduct and remedy wrongs |
| Examples | Murder, assault, theft, fraud, arson | Negligence, defamation, breach of contract |
| Consequences | Sanctions (fine, imprisonment) | Remedies (damages, injunction) |
| Person bringing action | Prosecution (on behalf of state/Crown) | Plaintiff |
| Person defending | Accused | Defendant |
| Burden of proof | Prosecution | Plaintiff |
| Police involvement | Yes | No |
| Common terms | Accused, guilty, sentence, crime, arrest | Sue, compensation, damages, dispute, liable |
The relationship between criminal law and civil law
Although criminal law and civil law are distinct, they're not completely separate. The same action can sometimes give rise to both criminal and civil cases.
Same behaviour, different consequences
Consider someone who physically assaults another person:
Criminal law aspect:
- The police can charge the person with the crime of assault
- If found guilty by a court, they face a sanction (possibly imprisonment or a fine)
- This is the state punishing the offender for harming society
Civil law aspect:
- The victim (as plaintiff) can sue the attacker (as defendant) for the tort of assault
- If successful, the defendant may have to pay damages to compensate for injuries
- This is the victim seeking compensation for personal harm
The same punch has led to two separate legal proceedings with different purposes and outcomes. The criminal case protects society and punishes the offender, while the civil case compensates the victim for their injuries.
Suing third parties in civil law
Sometimes civil law allows victims to sue people who didn't commit the actual crime but may be responsible for the circumstances that allowed harm to occur.
Worked Example: Negligence Case
Leonardo was waiting in line at a nightclub when a fight broke out inside. Security removed the fighters and left them on the street near the queue. The fight continued, and Leonardo was struck and seriously injured, even though he wasn't involved. He suffered a broken jaw, neck injury, broken teeth, bruising, and psychological trauma.
Two separate legal proceedings:
Criminal Law:
- The people who attacked Leonardo were charged with assault
Civil Law:
- Leonardo sued the nightclub owner and security company for negligence
Leonardo's civil law argument: The nightclub and security company owed him a duty of care and breached it by:
- Ejecting fighters near the queue without moving them away
- Failing to protect people waiting in line
- Not doing enough to prevent the fight continuing where it could harm others
What this demonstrates: Civil law can hold parties accountable even when they didn't commit the criminal act themselves, if they contributed to the harm through negligence or breach of duty of care.
Why both areas of law matter
The relationship between criminal and civil law ensures:
- Society is protected (criminal law punishes offenders)
- Victims are compensated (civil law provides remedies)
- Different types of responsibility are recognised (criminal guilt vs. civil liability)
- Multiple pathways exist for addressing wrongs
Don't confuse criminal and civil proceedings. They have different parties, different aims, different consequences, and different standards of proof. The same event may trigger both types of legal action, but they remain separate proceedings with distinct purposes.
Remember!
Key Points to Remember:
-
Criminal law protects society by defining crimes and imposing sanctions like fines and imprisonment. The prosecution (representing the state) brings cases against the accused.
-
Civil law regulates disputes between private parties and provides remedies like damages. The plaintiff sues the defendant to seek compensation for harm.
-
Key differences: Criminal law aims to punish and protect society; civil law aims to compensate and remedy wrongs. Criminal cases can result in sanctions; civil cases result in remedies.
-
The same act can result in both criminal and civil cases. For example, an assault can lead to criminal charges by police AND a civil lawsuit by the victim.
-
Important terms: In criminal cases use accused, prosecution, sanction, guilty. In civil cases use plaintiff, defendant, damages, liable.