Stakeholder Needs (AQA A-Level Business): Revision Notes
Stakeholder needs
Introduction to stakeholder needs
When businesses make decisions, they must consider the various people and groups who have an interest in what the company does. These groups are called stakeholders – any individual or group who has an interest in the activities and performance of a business. Understanding what different stakeholders need and want is crucial because business decisions will affect all of them in different ways. Managers need to recognise these needs and try to balance them when making important choices.
Why This Matters
Business decisions cannot satisfy everyone equally. Effective managers must identify all stakeholder groups, understand their specific needs, and make informed choices about whose interests to prioritise. Ignoring stakeholder needs can lead to conflict, reputational damage, and business failure.
Key stakeholders and their specific needs
Every business has multiple stakeholder groups, each with their own expectations and requirements. Managing these different needs is a constant challenge for businesses.
A useful way to remember the main stakeholder groups is the mnemonic EGGS CL: Employees, Government, Government, Shareholders, Suppliers, Customers, Local communities.
Employees
Employees are the people who work for the business. Their main needs include:
- Job security – they want stable, long-term employment and to know their jobs are safe
- Good working conditions – employees expect a safe, comfortable, and pleasant working environment
- Fair pay – workers want to be paid appropriately for the work they do and for their skills
Employees are vital stakeholders because they directly contribute to the business's success. If their needs aren't met, motivation and productivity can fall, which damages business performance.
Customers
Customers buy the products or services the business offers. Their key needs are:
- Good customer service – customers want to be treated well and have their problems resolved quickly
- Value for money – they expect products and services to be worth what they pay for them
Satisfying customers is essential for any business because without customers, there would be no revenue. Happy customers are more likely to return and recommend the business to others, creating a positive cycle of growth and reputation enhancement.
Shareholders
Shareholders are the owners of the business (in a company). They have invested money and expect returns. Their main needs include:
- Capital growth – shareholders want the value of their shares to increase over time
- Dividends – they expect regular payments from the company's profits
Shareholders have significant power in businesses, particularly large companies. Managers must keep shareholders satisfied to maintain their investment and support.
Suppliers
Suppliers provide the materials, components, or services that the business needs to operate. Their needs are:
- Regular orders – suppliers want consistent, predictable business from their customers
- On-time payment – they need to be paid promptly according to agreed terms
Building good relationships with suppliers is important because reliable suppliers help ensure smooth operations. Suppliers who trust the business may offer better terms or priority service.
Local communities
Local communities include the people living and working near the business's operations. Their concerns typically involve:
- Avoidance of pollution – communities want businesses to minimise environmental damage and pollution
- Avoiding congestion – they prefer businesses not to cause excessive traffic or overcrowding
- Employment opportunities – local communities benefit when businesses create jobs in the area
Businesses that ignore community needs risk damaging their reputation and facing opposition to expansion plans or new developments.
Government
Government represents society as a whole and has regulatory oversight of businesses. The government's interests include:
- Employment creation – governments want businesses to create jobs and reduce unemployment
- Tax payment – businesses must pay various taxes (corporation tax, business rates) which fund public services
Governments can significantly influence business operations through laws, regulations, and tax policies. Maintaining a positive relationship with government is important for long-term business success.
Stakeholder mapping: Mendelow's matrix
Stakeholder mapping is a tool that helps businesses analyse and manage different stakeholder groups. One of the most useful approaches is Mendelow's matrix, which categorises stakeholders based on two factors: their power (ability to influence the business) and their interest (how much they care about the business's activities).
The matrix has four quadrants, each requiring a different management approach:
Key players (high power, high interest)
These stakeholders have both significant influence over the business and a strong interest in what it does. They are the most important group to manage.
Management approach:
- Focus major efforts on this group
- Involve them in governance and decision-making processes
- Engage and consult with them regularly
Example: Major shareholders in a plc would typically be key players because they own significant portions of the company and care deeply about its performance.
Meet their needs (low power, high interest)
These stakeholders are very interested in the business but don't have much power to influence its decisions.
Management approach:
- Engage and consult with them on areas of interest
- Try to increase their level of involvement where appropriate
- Aim to move them into the key player category if possible
Example: Employees often fall into this category – they care a lot about the business (it's their livelihood) but may have limited individual power.
Show consideration (high power, low interest)
These stakeholders have the power to affect the business significantly but aren't particularly interested in its day-to-day operations.
Management approach:
- Make use of their involvement in low-risk areas
- Keep them informed and consult on specific interest areas
- They could become potential supporters or goodwill ambassadors
- Be careful not to upset them, as they could become more interested if problems arise
Example: Large institutional investors who hold shares but don't actively engage with the company unless major issues arise.
Least important (low power, low interest)
These stakeholders have neither significant power nor strong interest in the business.
Management approach:
- Inform via general communications (newsletters, website, mailshots)
- Minimal effort required
- Aim to move them into the "meet their needs" quadrant if beneficial
Example: Members of the general public who live far from the business's operations and don't use its products.
Stakeholders Can Move Between Quadrants
Remember that stakeholders can move between quadrants based on changing circumstances. A local community might be "least important" normally, but if the business proposes building a new factory nearby, they could quickly become "meet their needs" or even "key players" if they organise opposition. Businesses must regularly reassess their stakeholder map.
Using Mendelow's Matrix in Practice
Imagine a retail company planning to open a new store:
Step 1: Identify all stakeholders (shareholders, local residents, employees, suppliers, local council)
Step 2: Assess each group's power and interest
- Shareholders: High power (own the company), high interest (affects profits) → Key players
- Local residents: Low power (no direct control), high interest (affects their area) → Meet their needs
- Local council: High power (planning permission), low interest (one of many businesses) → Show consideration
Step 3: Develop appropriate engagement strategies for each quadrant
Step 4: Monitor and reassess as circumstances change
Conflicts and overlaps between stakeholder needs
Business decisions rarely satisfy all stakeholders equally. In fact, actions that benefit one group often create problems for another. Understanding these potential conflicts is essential for effective stakeholder management.
Common areas of conflict
Different stakeholder groups frequently have competing interests. When a business makes a strategic decision, it must recognise that not everyone will be happy with the outcome.
Example 1: Relocating Overseas
Imagine a UK manufacturing business decides to move production to Asia to reduce costs.
Potential overlaps (who benefits):
- Shareholders may benefit from lower costs leading to increased profit
- Management can achieve their objectives in terms of cost reduction and improved profitability
Potential conflicts (who loses out):
- Local community suffers impact on the local economy as money leaves the area
- Employees lose their jobs when the UK factory closes
- Government loses tax revenue from the closed operations
This example shows how a decision that makes financial sense for owners can have devastating effects on other stakeholder groups.
Example 2: Introducing New Technology
A business invests in automation technology to improve efficiency and product quality.
Potential overlaps (who benefits):
- Shareholders and management benefit from lower costs and potential profit increases
- Consumers may receive better quality products and more reliable service
Potential conflicts (who loses out):
- Employees may lose jobs as machines replace human workers
- Less employment could negatively impact the local community's economy
This scenario demonstrates the tension between efficiency improvements and job security.
Example 3: Expanding Production
A company decides to increase output to meet growing demand.
Potential overlaps (who benefits):
- Shareholders enjoy higher sales leading to increased profit
- Employees gain job opportunities through recruitment
- Customers benefit from greater availability of products
- Suppliers receive more orders for materials
- Government collects more tax from increased business activity
- Community experiences greater production and economic activity in the area
Potential conflicts (who loses out):
- Local community may face greater congestion from increased lorry traffic and pollution from expanded operations
Even decisions that benefit many stakeholders can create problems. In this case, most groups gain, but the local community faces environmental and quality-of-life issues.
Managing stakeholder conflicts
Businesses cannot always avoid conflicts between stakeholder groups, but they can take steps to minimise negative impacts and maintain positive relationships:
- Communicate transparently about decisions and their likely impacts
- Seek compromises where possible (for example, investing in cleaner technology when expanding)
- Prioritise stakeholders using tools like Mendelow's matrix
- Consider corporate social responsibility to balance profit with broader societal needs
- Build stakeholder relationships before conflicts arise, creating goodwill
Real-World Application
When major UK supermarkets like Tesco or Sainsbury's plan new stores, they often face opposition from local communities worried about traffic and competition for local shops. However, they also bring employment opportunities and tax revenue that local councils value. The businesses must carefully balance these competing needs through consultation, environmental impact assessments, and community investment programmes.
Key Points to Remember:
-
Stakeholders are any individuals or groups with an interest in a business – including employees, customers, shareholders, suppliers, local communities, and government.
-
Different stakeholders have different needs – employees want job security and fair pay; shareholders want profits and dividends; communities want to avoid pollution and congestion.
-
Mendelow's matrix helps prioritise stakeholders based on their power and interest – "key players" (high power, high interest) require the most attention and should be involved in decision-making.
-
Business decisions create conflicts between stakeholder needs – what benefits one group often disadvantages another (e.g., relocating overseas may increase shareholder profit but causes local job losses).
-
Effective stakeholder management requires balancing competing needs – businesses must recognise conflicts, communicate openly, and use stakeholder mapping to make informed decisions about whose needs to prioritise.