The USA’s Involvement in Europe (AQA A-Level History): Revision Notes
The Marshall Plan, 1947
Context: US strategic planning by 1947
By 1947, American strategic thinking regarding Europe had evolved considerably. The USA aimed not merely to facilitate economic recovery following the Second World War, but to construct a unified, stable bloc of pro-American states across the continent. American policymakers had concluded that Western Europe could be shaped to serve US interests, accepting in the process that Europe would remain divided.
Strategic planning refers to deliberate actions and policies pursued to establish military, political or economic control in order to achieve specific outcomes.
The 'special relationship' with Britain
American engagement with Europe was facilitated through a so-called 'special relationship' with Britain. This relationship rested on mutual dependence rather than British subordination to Washington. Britain provided a politically stable and reliable entry point into mainland European affairs, functioning as the primary driving force in maintaining Anglo-American cooperation.
For Britain, American support was essential to preserve its international standing in the post-war world. The USA equally needed Britain's role and influence across Europe to advance American interests. Washington required a dependable relationship with a Western European power, and Britain proved most receptive to American overtures. Other Western European states contained left-wing socialist political groups that appeared less reliable than the British Labour government. The consensus politics prevailing in Britain meant the USA could conduct business with confidence.
Winston Churchill emphasised common identity and shared security needs between the two nations, assuming this bond would form the foundation of their political, economic and strategic relationship. However, this notion developed into something of a myth during the early Cold War years. The assumption of an unbreakable Anglo-American alliance was frequently shown not to exist in practice.
The launch of the Marshall Plan, June 1947
In May 1947, Clayton, serving as Under-Secretary of State for Economic Affairs, undertook a fact-finding tour of Western Europe. He concluded that economic failure across European states would inflict damage upon the American economy. Clayton predicted the loss of markets for American goods and consequent unemployment in the USA. His analysis conveyed urgency and alarm about these potential outcomes. Whilst exaggerating Europe's economic importance to America, Clayton's assessment illustrated Washington's growing anxiety about the nature of long-term relations with Europe.
Also in May 1947, George Kennan's Policy Planning Staff (PPS) produced a statement identifying profound communist infiltration in Western Europe as the fundamental problem. For the PPS, the real issue was the devastating impact of the Second World War upon Europe's economic, political and social structures. US aid to Europe, in the PPS view, should focus on restoring European economic strength rather than on combating communism directly.
On 5 June 1947, George Marshall unveiled his plan, officially titled the European Recovery Program (ERP), at Harvard University. In his speech, Marshall argued:
"Aside from the demoralising effect on the world at large and the possibilities of disturbances arising as a result of the desperation of the people concerned, the consequences to the economy of the United States should be apparent to all... Our policy is not directed against any country or doctrine but against hunger, poverty, desperation and chaos. Its purpose should be the revival of a working economy in the world so as to permit the emergence of political and social conditions in which free institutions can exist."
Marshall emphasised that American policy aimed to combat economic crisis rather than specific ideologies, promoting the restoration of working economies and free institutions.
Implementation and scale of the Marshall Plan
Over five years the Marshall Plan provided $13.5 billion to 16 European countries. This assistance came in the form of money and goods. Britain and France received the largest allocations, with Great Britain obtaining approximately $3,000 million and France around $2,700 million. Germany, despite its recent defeat, received substantial aid of approximately $1,400 million. Other recipients included Greece, Belgium, the Netherlands, Austria, and Italy, though in smaller amounts.
Conditions attached to Marshall Aid:
Receiving aid carried specific conditions. Recipients had to spend some of the aid on importing goods from the USA. They were also required to share economic information with Washington. The plan formed part of an American economic strategy to benefit the USA's own economy by expanding markets for American goods whilst helping Europe's economic reconstruction.
Aims of the Marshall Plan
The American vision for Europe centred on creating a single European market. Historians have argued that the Marshall Plan contributed substantially to the creation of the European Coal and Steel Community and ultimately to the existence of the European Economic Community from 1957.
The Marshall Plan served multiple purposes:
Promoting European unity: The USA envisaged a stable European bloc that would reinforce Truman's policy of containment. Integrating European economies would create economic interdependence and reduce the likelihood of future conflict.
Preventing communist expansion: The Marshall Plan was designed to address the risk that continued post-war economic stagnation could lead to communist regimes being democratically elected by desperate populations. Washington feared such regimes would then fall under Soviet influence, reversing the trend of Western democratic stability.
Ensuring political stability: The USA was profoundly concerned about political and economic stability, particularly in France and Italy. The French Communist Party had 1.7 million members in 1947. Continuing economic crisis could generate growing support for communist movements, potentially resulting in the Soviet Union gaining influence in Western Europe.
To achieve stability, the Marshall Plan was offered to all European states, including the Soviet Union. This comprehensive offer aimed to demonstrate American goodwill whilst recognising that Soviet acceptance was unlikely.
Soviet reaction and rejection
The Soviet Union interpreted the Marshall Plan as transparent American economic imperialism. Soviet leaders believed US influence would spread into Eastern Europe, undermining their sphere of influence and security. By 1947, Czechoslovakia and Hungary had not yet come fully under communist control and retained communist-dominated coalition governments with some interest in receiving Marshall Aid.
Had these states accepted American assistance, they would have committed themselves to restoring market economies and integrating their economies with Western European member states of the Organisation of European Economic Cooperation (the organisation responsible for allocating Marshall Aid). Through this process they would have been brought under the economic influence of the stronger Western capitalist economies, loosening Soviet control.
In July 1947, the Soviet Union walked out of the Paris Peace Conference. By September, Moscow had established Cominform (the Communist Information Bureau), designed to coordinate communist parties across Europe and tighten Soviet control. Czechoslovakia and Eastern European states that had expressed interest in Marshall Aid were ordered by Stalin to reverse their decisions.
The Soviet Union's position proved inflexible. Greater tightening of Soviet control over Eastern Europe became necessary to counter what Moscow perceived as American strategic encroachment. Andrey Vyshinsky, Soviet Deputy Foreign Minister, articulated this position in a speech to the United Nations in September 1947:
"The United States government has moved towards a direct renunciation of the principles of international collaboration and concerted action by the great powers and towards attempts to impose its will on other independent states, while at the same time obviously using the economic resources distributed as relief to individual needy nations as an instrument of political pressure... The implementation of the Marshall Plan will mean placing European countries under the economic and political control of the United States and direct interference by the latter in the internal affairs of these countries."
Vyshinsky's speech accused Washington of abandoning international cooperation, imposing American will on independent states, and using economic relief as political leverage to control European countries.
Consequences and significance
The Marshall Plan accelerated the division of Europe. Rather than undermining Soviet control in Eastern Europe or promoting cooperation between the superpowers, it further entrenched the impossibility of international relations based on consensus between the USA and USSR. The plan simply reinforced the partition of Europe and eliminated prospects for some degree of cooperation between the two superpowers.
The Marshall Plan represented a concrete manifestation of American commitment to European recovery and containment of communism. It demonstrated that Washington was prepared to invest substantial financial resources to prevent Soviet expansion and to create a stable, pro-American Western Europe. The economic reconstruction it facilitated helped to stabilise Western European democracies and laid foundations for future European integration.
From the Soviet perspective, the Marshall Plan confirmed American intentions to extend economic and political influence across Europe, justifying Stalin's decision to consolidate control over Eastern Europe through Cominform and the rejection of American aid.
Remember!
Key Points to Remember:
-
The Marshall Plan (European Recovery Program) was announced by George Marshall in June 1947, providing $13.5 billion over five years to 16 European countries for economic reconstruction.
-
The plan served multiple purposes: restoring European economies, preventing communist expansion through economic desperation, promoting European unity, and creating markets for American goods.
-
Recipients had to purchase American goods and share economic information with Washington, demonstrating how the plan served American economic interests alongside humanitarian goals.
-
The Soviet Union rejected the Marshall Plan as American economic imperialism, walked out of the Paris Peace Conference in July 1947, and established Cominform in September 1947 to tighten control over Eastern Europe.
-
The Marshall Plan accelerated the division of Europe, reinforcing the impossibility of US-Soviet cooperation and entrenching the partition between Western and Eastern Europe that characterised the Cold War.