The Rivalries of Richard I and Philip II (Edexcel A-Level History): Revision Notes
The Rivalries of Richard I and Philip II
Introduction
Despite initial promises of cooperation, the relationship between King Richard I of England and King Philip II of France was fraught with tension throughout the Third Crusade. On 30 December 1189, the two monarchs met at Nonancourt and swore oaths to protect crusaders and work together. They met again at Vézelay in July 1190, agreeing to divide any spoils equally. However, beneath this surface cooperation lay several contentious issues that significantly hampered the crusade's progress and ultimately prevented the recapture of Jerusalem.
Issue 1: The betrothal of Richard and Alice
Background to the dispute
The first major source of friction between the two kings centred on Richard's engagement to Philip's sister, Alice. For Philip, this was politically sensitive - if Richard broke the engagement, it would cause significant embarrassment to the French crown and damage France's prestige. However, Richard had strategic reasons for wanting to end this arrangement.
Richard wished to marry Berengaria of Navarre instead, primarily to secure an alliance against Raymond, the Count of Toulouse, who was a longstanding enemy. Richard carefully concealed this plan from Philip until both had taken their crusade vows, fearing that revealing it earlier might provoke a war that he would be unable to fight whilst committed to the crusade in Outremer (the Crusader states in the Holy Land).
Key term - Dowry: In its archaic sense, this meant the widow's share of her husband's money. Richard sought to collect his sister's dowry to help fund the crusade.
The resolution and its cost
When Richard's engagement to Berengaria became public knowledge, Philip eventually agreed to release Richard from his commitment - but only for the substantial sum of 10,000 marks. Whilst this resolved the immediate diplomatic problem, the consequences for the crusade itself were severe.
The 10,000 marks payment represented a significant financial burden that diverted resources from crusading activities. This diplomatic resolution came at a high cost to both Richard's treasury and the crusade's progress.
Effects on the crusade
The betrothal dispute created two main problems that damaged the crusade's effectiveness:
Tension between the leaders:
- The disagreement generated mistrust and animosity between Richard and Philip
- This tension manifested in their failure to cooperate during military operations
- When Richard besieged Messina in Sicily (4 October 1190) to collect his sister's dowry and fund the crusade, Philip was present but offered no assistance
- The chronicler Ambroise even recorded that Philip's men actively defended Messina against Richard's attack
Significant delays:
- Richard felt compelled to secure his succession before departing on crusade, which meant waiting until Philip released him from the engagement to Alice
- He then had to delay further until Berengaria could reach him in Cyprus
- Richard and Berengaria finally married on 12 May 1191, causing considerable postponement of crusading activities
Timeline - Stage 1: The Third Crusade begins
- 4 July 1190: Richard and Philip departed together from Vézelay
- 4 October 1190: Richard sacked Messina in Sicily
- 6 May 1191: Richard reached Cyprus and took control of the island
- 12 May 1191: Richard married Berengaria instead of Philip's sister Alice
Issue 2: The rival claims to Jerusalem
The two claimants
The relationship between Richard and Philip became further complicated through their family connections to rival claimants for the throne of Jerusalem. Each crusade leader backed a different candidate, creating division at the highest level of crusade leadership.
Conrad of Montferrat:
- Philip's cousin
- Held the garrison at Tyre in Outremer
- Supported by Philip II of France
Guy of Lusignan:
- A feudatory of Richard in Poitou (meaning he held land from Richard under the feudal system)
- Led the siege against Acre
- Claimed the title of King of Jerusalem through his late wife Sybil, who had been Queen of Jerusalem
- Sybil was also Richard's cousin
- Supported by Richard I of England
Key term - Feudatory: A person who held land from a lord under the feudal system. For example, Richard ruled the county of Poitou, where Guy's family held its land, making Guy Richard's feudatory.
Effects on the crusade
The rival claims to Jerusalem had two significant negative impacts on crusade operations:
Increased strain on crusaders:
- Personal loyalties created practical obstacles to military cooperation
- When Richard arrived at Tyre on 6 June 1191, Conrad refused him entry to the city
- This forced Richard to sail directly to Acre without any opportunity to rest his forces
- The crusaders had to begin the siege immediately, placing additional strain on Richard's troops
Conrad's refusal to allow Richard entry to Tyre was a direct consequence of the rivalry between the two kings. This forced Richard's exhausted forces to proceed immediately to Acre without rest, significantly weakening their effectiveness at a critical moment in the crusade.
Delays in decision-making:
- The dispute over succession caused paralysis in crusade leadership
- After Acre surrendered on 12 July 1191, it took until 28 July to resolve who would rule the Kingdom of Jerusalem
- A compromise was eventually reached: Guy would be king, but after his death, Conrad would inherit the title
- These 16 days of negotiation represented crucial time lost when the crusade should have been advancing
Timeline - Stage 2: The siege of Acre
- 20 April 1191: Philip reached Acre and helped strengthen the siege against Saladin's occupation
- 6 June 1191: Richard reached Tyre, but the garrison refused him entry
- 8 June 1191: Richard reached Acre and joined the siege
- 12 July 1191: Acre surrendered and was retaken by Philip and Richard
Issue 3: European politics
Philip's departure and conspiracy
Philip II sailed back to France on 31 July 1191, before the Third Crusade was completed. His departure extended the rivalry between the two kings back into Europe and created new problems for Richard whilst he remained in Outremer.
Philip's early departure from the crusade was controversial and left Richard as the sole principal leader of the Christian forces. This departure occurred just weeks after the fall of Acre, at a time when unified leadership was crucial for advancing towards Jerusalem.
Threats to Richard's kingdom
In April 1192, Richard received disturbing news that Philip was threatening the border of his territory in Normandy. This was followed in May 1192 by even more alarming intelligence: Philip had been openly conspiring against Richard with Richard's own brother, John.
Impact on the crusade
This political interference from Europe had profound effects on Richard's capacity to continue the crusade:
Psychological impact:
- Richard was deeply troubled by the threat to his kingdom
- He was powerless to defend his territories whilst committed to the crusade in the Holy Land
- This created a severe dilemma between his crusading vows and his duty to protect his realm
Strategic consequences:
- The political pressure from Europe became one of the key reasons why Richard ultimately chose to withdraw rather than besiege Jerusalem in July 1192
- Richard could not risk prolonged military operations in the Holy Land whilst his kingdom faced immediate threats
- This effectively ended any realistic chance of recapturing Jerusalem during the Third Crusade
Philip's conspiracy with Richard's brother John placed Richard in an impossible position. While bound by his crusading vows to remain in the Holy Land, he faced the very real threat of losing his entire kingdom in Europe. This political manoeuvring proved to be one of the most decisive factors in ending the Third Crusade without achieving its primary objective.
Timeline - Stage 3: The crusade ends
- 31 July 1191: Philip sailed back to France
- 7 September 1191: Saladin's troops were defeated at a battle north of Arsuf
- October 1191: Richard began to march towards Jerusalem and recaptured Jaffa
- 13 January 1192: Richard ordered a retreat from Jerusalem to Ascalon
- 7 June 1192: Richard marched towards Jerusalem again
- 27-31 July 1792: Saladin attacked Jaffa, but Richard drove his troops back
- 4 July 1192: Richard began withdrawal and returned to Acre
- 2 September 1192: A truce was signed with Saladin
Analysis of the rivalry's overall impact
The rivalries between Richard I and Philip II fundamentally undermined the Third Crusade's chances of success. What should have been a united Christian effort was repeatedly hampered by:
- Personal disputes over marriage alliances and family honour
- Political divisions over the succession to Jerusalem
- European power struggles that distracted from crusading objectives
- Lack of trust between the two principal leaders
- Failure to cooperate in military operations
These problems caused both immediate tactical difficulties (such as delays and refusals to cooperate) and strategic failure (the inability to recapture Jerusalem). The Third Crusade ultimately ended in a truce with Saladin rather than victory, with Jerusalem remaining in Muslim hands.
Remember!
Key Points to Remember:
-
The betrothal dispute: Richard's desire to marry Berengaria instead of Philip's sister Alice cost 10,000 marks, created tension between the leaders, and caused significant delays to crusade operations.
-
Rival claims to Jerusalem: Richard supported Guy of Lusignan whilst Philip backed Conrad of Montferrat, leading to Conrad refusing Richard entry to Tyre and a 16-day delay in deciding the succession after Acre's fall.
-
European political interference: Philip's return to France and his conspiracies with Richard's brother John forced Richard to abandon plans to besiege Jerusalem and ultimately withdraw from the crusade.
-
Cooperation vs. competition: Despite initial oaths to work together, personal and political rivalries between Richard and Philip consistently undermined the Third Crusade's effectiveness.
-
Ultimate failure: The rivalries between the two kings were a major factor in the Third Crusade's failure to recapture Jerusalem, ending instead in a truce with Saladin in September 1192.