Change and unrest, 1919-23 (AQA GCSE History): Revision Notes
Change and unrest, 1919-23
The early years of the Weimar Republic were marked by significant political instability and violent challenges to Germany's new democratic system. Between 1919 and 1923, the government faced serious threats from both extreme left-wing and right-wing groups who fundamentally opposed the democratic approach that had been established after Germany's defeat in World War One.
Extreme opposition to Weimar democracy
The new democratic government encountered fierce resistance from three main political groups, each representing different ideological positions but all united in their rejection of parliamentary democracy.
The Spartacists
The Spartacists represented the extreme left-wing challenge to Weimar democracy. This communist group emerged from the Independent Socialist Party and drew inspiration from the recent Bolshevik Revolution in Russia. The movement was led by two prominent figures: Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht, both dedicated revolutionaries who believed that Germany needed a complete socialist transformation similar to what had occurred in Soviet Russia.
The Spartacists operated primarily from Berlin and received backing from the Soviet Union, which hoped to spread communist revolution westward across Europe. Their ultimate goal was to overthrow the moderate Social Democratic government and establish a workers' state based on the Russian model.
The Freikorps
At the opposite end of the political spectrum, the Freikorps posed a significant right-wing threat to the republic. These paramilitary units consisted mainly of former soldiers who had retained their weapons after Germany's military defeat. The organisation was substantial, numbering approximately 250,000 men by March 1919.
What made the Freikorps particularly dangerous was their military experience and organisation. Led by regular army officers, these units maintained military discipline and effectiveness. They represented the old order's resistance to democratic change and harboured deep resentment about Germany's defeat and the terms of the Treaty of Versailles.
The National Socialist German Workers' Party (Nazis)
The Nazi Party emerged as another right-wing extremist group during this period. Under Adolf Hitler's leadership, the party developed a distinctive ideology that combined extreme nationalism with anti-democratic and anti-communist beliefs. The Nazis wanted to establish a strong, authoritarian government with a powerful military component.
The party built up its own paramilitary force called the SA (Sturmabteilung), which served as both a propaganda tool and a means of intimidating political opponents. This showed how extremist groups were willing to use violence to achieve their political goals.
Major challenges to democracy
The Spartacist revolt (January 1919)
The first major test of the new republic came in January 1919 when the Spartacists attempted to seize control of the government. The rebels took over key facilities in Berlin, including newspaper offices and the telegraph bureau, and tried to organise a general strike throughout the city.
The Spartacist Revolt: A Critical Moment
Step 1: The uprising begins
- Spartacists seize key facilities in Berlin (newspaper offices, telegraph bureau)
- General strike organised throughout the city
Step 2: Government response
- Weimar government lacks reliable military force
- Makes controversial decision to employ Freikorps units
Step 3: Violent suppression
- Street fighting continues for several days
- Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht killed while in custody
The Weimar government, lacking a reliable military force of its own, made the controversial decision to employ Freikorps units to suppress the communist uprising. This created an ironic situation where the democratic government had to rely on right-wing extremists to defeat left-wing extremists.
The revolt was brutally crushed, with street fighting continuing for several days before order was restored. The conflict ended tragically with the deaths of Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht, who were shot while in custody. This violent suppression had long-term consequences, as it deepened the divide between moderate and radical socialists, weakening the left-wing support base that the republic needed.
The Kapp Putsch (March 1920)
Just over a year later, the republic faced an equally serious challenge from the right wing. In March 1920, Freikorps units, fearing unemployment as Germany was forced to reduce its military forces, decided to march on Berlin under the leadership of Wolfgang Kapp.
The situation became critical when Ebert, the head of the government, asked the regular army to resist the Freikorps advance, but the army chief refused to intervene. This left the government virtually defenceless against the attempted coup. Dr. Wolfgang Kapp was temporarily installed as the new leader, and the legitimate government was forced to flee the capital.
The Kapp Putsch: How Democracy Survived
The Crisis:
- Freikorps march on Berlin under Wolfgang Kapp
- Regular army refuses to defend the government
- Legitimate government forced to flee the capital
The Solution:
- Government calls for general strike
- Trade unions respond massively
- Economic chaos and paralysis result
- Kapp unable to govern effectively
- Putsch collapses after several days
However, the putsch ultimately failed due to an unexpected source of resistance. The government called for a general strike, and German trade unions responded massively. The strike created such economic chaos and paralysis that Kapp found himself unable to govern effectively. After several days, he was forced to flee, and the legitimate Weimar government returned to power.
The Munich Putsch (November 1923)
The economic crisis of 1923, particularly the devastating hyperinflation, created conditions that extremist groups sought to exploit. Adolf Hitler and the Nazi Party, inspired by Mussolini's successful march on Rome in Italy the previous year, decided to attempt their own seizure of power in Germany.
On November 8, 1923, Hitler and approximately 600 SA members, along with 2,000 volunteer supporters, marched into Munich with the intention of declaring Hitler as the new President of Germany. They initially gathered at a beer hall where the Bavarian government was meeting, attempting to force local government leaders to support their cause.
However, the putsch quickly collapsed when it met organised resistance. State police confronted the Nazi marchers, and in the resulting chaos, shots were fired. Hitler's supporters scattered, and key Nazi leaders, including Hitler himself, were arrested. Ludendorff, a respected World War One general who had joined the Nazi cause, was also taken into custody.
Long-term consequences and significance
Although the Munich Putsch failed as an immediate political action, it had several important long-term effects that would prove significant for German history. Hitler's subsequent trial gave him a national platform to publicise his political views and racial ideology. Rather than receiving a harsh sentence, he was given only a short prison term of nine months.
During his imprisonment, Hitler wrote "Mein Kampf" (My Struggle), a book that outlined his political and racial theories and became central to Nazi ideology. The failure of the putsch also taught Hitler an important strategic lesson: he realised that he would need to gain power through legal, electoral means rather than through violent revolution.
Critical Learning Point: The failure of the putsch taught Hitler an important strategic lesson - he realised that he would need to gain power through legal, electoral means rather than through violent revolution. This tactical shift would prove crucial to his eventual rise to power.
The Nazi Party ban was lifted by 1925, allowing Hitler to rebuild his organisation with new tactics focused on winning popular support through elections rather than attempted coups.
Timeline of major events
January 1919: Spartacist Revolt
- Communist uprising in Berlin led by Luxemburg and Liebknecht
- Freikorps units suppress the revolt
- Spartacist leaders killed
March 1920: Kapp Putsch
- Freikorps march on Berlin
- Wolfgang Kapp temporarily takes power
- General strike forces collapse of the putsch
November 8, 1923: Munich Putsch begins
- Hitler enters beer hall in Munich with 600 SA supporters
- Bavarian government meeting disrupted
- Declaration of Hitler as President attempted
November 9, 1923: Putsch continues
- Hitler leads march with 1,000 SA and 2,000 volunteer supporters through Munich
- State police resistance encountered
November 11, 1923: Putsch fails
- Hitler found hiding and arrested
- Nazi leadership captured
- Movement collapses
Key Points to Remember:
-
The Weimar Republic faced violent challenges from both extreme left (Spartacists) and extreme right (Freikorps, Nazis) between 1919-1923
-
The government's reliance on Freikorps to defeat the Spartacists created dangerous precedents and weakened democratic legitimacy
-
The Kapp Putsch demonstrated both the fragility of the republic and the power of organised workers when they supported democracy through strike action
-
Hitler's failed Munich Putsch taught him to pursue power through legal electoral means rather than violent revolution
-
These early crises showed that German democracy was under constant threat from groups that rejected parliamentary government entirely