Life on the reservations (Edexcel GCSE History): Revision Notes
Life on the reservations
Introduction
The reservation system represented a fundamental transformation in how the US government controlled Indigenous peoples of the Plains. Rather than allowing Native Americans to live freely across their traditional territories, the government forced them onto designated reservation lands. This policy aimed to stop Indigenous resistance to white settlement while systematically destroying traditional ways of life that had existed for centuries.
Reservations served as more than just confined living spaces - they became tools for what the government called bringing "civilisation" to Indigenous communities. However, the reality was a deliberate campaign to eliminate Native American culture, independence, and traditional practices.
Conditions of reservation land
The government deliberately chose the worst possible locations for reservations. These areas were typically unwanted by white settlers because the soil was poor for farming and lacked valuable resources like minerals or fertile land. The harsh conditions made basic survival extremely difficult for Indigenous communities who were accustomed to following seasonal patterns and hunting across vast territories.
Many reservations were located in areas where traditional food sources were scarce or completely absent. This meant that Indigenous peoples, who had lived successfully off the land for generations, suddenly found themselves unable to provide for their families using their ancestral knowledge and skills.
Living conditions and health
Daily life on reservations was marked by severe hardship and deprivation. The government provided inadequate food rations that were often of poor quality, leading to malnutrition among reservation inhabitants. When crops were attempted, they frequently failed due to the poor soil conditions and unfamiliar farming techniques that replaced traditional food gathering methods.
Medical care was virtually non-existent on most reservations. Diseases such as measles and influenza spread rapidly through communities that had no natural immunity to these European illnesses. The combination of poor nutrition, overcrowded conditions, and lack of medical treatment resulted in devastating death rates. Many Indigenous Americans died from diseases that could have been easily treated with proper care.
Government control through agents and police
Indigenous agents
The federal government appointed special agents to oversee each reservation and control every aspect of daily life. These agents held enormous power over Indigenous communities, making decisions about food distribution, movement, and activities. Corruption was widespread among these officials, with money and supplies meant for Indigenous families often being stolen or "disappearing" before reaching those in need.
Indian agency police
Some Indigenous Americans were recruited to join the Indian Agency Police force, which was used to control their own people. While these positions offered better food, clothing, and shelter than other reservation inhabitants received, it created division within communities as Indigenous people were forced to enforce harsh government policies against their own families and neighbours.
This recruitment strategy was particularly damaging because it turned community members against each other, breaking down traditional unity and creating internal conflict within Indigenous societies.
Timeline: destruction of Indigenous leadership
The US government systematically removed power from traditional Indigenous leaders through a series of calculated steps:
1871: Chiefs were no longer permitted to sign treaties with the US government, ending their recognition as leaders of sovereign nations.
Early 1880s: Chiefs lost their authority to govern reservations, with government-appointed councils taking over these responsibilities.
1883: Indigenous Americans were placed under the jurisdiction of special courts rather than their own justice systems.
1885: Even these special courts were abolished and replaced with regular US federal law courts, completing the destruction of Indigenous legal autonomy.
This systematic removal of leadership left Indigenous communities without their traditional decision-makers and cultural guides, making resistance to government policies much more difficult.
Forced education and cultural destruction
Removal of children
One of the most devastating policies involved forcibly removing Indigenous children from their families and sending them to off-reservation boarding schools. These institutions were designed to eliminate all traces of Native American culture from the next generation.
At these schools, children faced brutal conditions and harsh punishments for speaking their native languages or practising any aspect of their traditional culture. Many children died from disease, malnutrition, or abuse. Those who survived often found themselves unable to fit into either white society, which still rejected them, or their own communities, from which they had been separated for years.
Loss of cultural transmission
By separating children from their families, the government deliberately broke the traditional way that Indigenous knowledge, languages, and customs were passed down through generations. This created a cultural break that had lasting effects on entire communities.
Prohibition of traditional practices
Ban on hunting
The government prohibited Indigenous peoples from hunting, which destroyed more than just their food source. Hunting was central to Plains Indian social structure, with specific roles and responsibilities that had organised communities for centuries. The ban affected traditional clothing production, as animal hides were no longer available, and eliminated the skills and knowledge that had defined masculine roles within Indigenous society.
Suppression of religious beliefs
Traditional Indigenous spiritual practices were banned outright. The government prohibited feasts, dances, and ceremonies that were essential parts of Native American religious life. Medicine men, who served as both spiritual leaders and healers, were stripped of their authority and influence within their communities.
Christian missionaries were brought onto reservations to replace Indigenous spiritual practices with European religious beliefs, further eroding traditional culture and community structures.
Economic dependence and de-skilling
Indigenous Americans had developed sophisticated skills in horse riding, hunting, and warfare over generations. However, reservation life made these abilities useless, as there were no horses to ride, no animals to hunt, and no enemies to fight in traditional ways.
When the government attempted to teach "white" skills such as farming, sewing, and other European trades, many Indigenous people refused to learn. This was partly due to pride in their own cultural traditions and partly because these new skills represented everything they had lost.
The result was economic dependence on government rations and supplies, which was exactly what the authorities intended. By making Indigenous peoples dependent on federal assistance, the government gained complete control over their lives and choices.
Cause and consequence
Causes: The reservation system developed from the US government's desire to:
- Clear land for white settlement and railroad construction
- End Indigenous resistance to westward expansion
- Eliminate Native American culture and independence
- Create economic dependence on federal assistance
Consequences: Life on reservations led to:
- Dramatic population decline due to disease and starvation
- Loss of traditional languages, customs, and knowledge
- Breakdown of family and community structures
- Economic dependence that lasted for generations
- Psychological trauma from cultural destruction
Key Points to Remember:
-
Systematic control: Reservations were deliberately designed as tools of cultural destruction, not just places to live - every aspect of daily life was controlled by government agents.
-
Timeline of power removal: Between 1871-1885, the US government systematically stripped Indigenous chiefs of all traditional authority through legal changes.
-
Forced dependence: By banning hunting, removing children, and prohibiting traditional practices, the government made Indigenous peoples completely dependent on federal assistance for survival.
-
Cultural genocide: The reservation system aimed to eliminate Indigenous culture entirely by separating families, banning languages and religions, and forcing European ways of life on Native Americans.
-
Long-term impact: The devastating conditions and policies of reservation life created problems that affected Indigenous communities for generations, including loss of traditional knowledge, economic dependence, and cultural disconnection.