Two of the Main Variants in Hinduism: Vaishnava and Shaiva (HSC SSCE Studies of Religion): Revision Notes
Two of the Main Variants in Hinduism: Vaishnava and Shaiva
Understanding Hindu diversity
Hinduism encompasses significant diversity in worship and practice. Two of the most important variants within Hinduism are Vaishnavism (worship of Lord Vishnu as supreme) and Shaivism (worship of Lord Shiva as supreme). Both traditions recognize other deities, but each views their primary god as the ultimate reality or Brahman.
Before exploring these variants, it is essential to understand the broader context of Hindu belief and the concept of sanatana dharma, which provides the philosophical foundation for both traditions.
Sanatana dharma: The eternal way
In the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, Hindu thinkers began using the term sanatana dharma to describe Hinduism. The word 'sanatana' literally means 'eternal' – having no beginning and no end.
Understanding dharma
The term 'dharma' has no direct equivalent in Western vocabulary. Its meaning varies depending on context and can include:
- Morality
- Virtue
- Religious merit
- Justice and right conduct
- Duty
- Good work according to rules
- Everlasting religion, truth or law
Sanatana dharma refers to the duties and religiously ordained practices of Hinduism. It represents a philosophical interpretation of the religion rather than just its external expression.
Key concepts linked to sanatana dharma include:
- Reincarnation (cycle of rebirth)
- Karma (actions and their consequences)
- Yoga practices (methods to attain connection with God)
- Stages of human life (ashramas)
The Trimurti: Three forms of one supreme reality
Many Hindus identify a supreme reality called Brahman, sometimes described as the 'great world soul'. This ultimate reality expresses itself through the Trimurti – three divine forms that represent different cosmic functions:
- Brahma – The creator god who projects the universe
- Lord Vishnu – The preserver who sustains the universe
- Shiva – The destroyer or liberator who transforms the universe
This concept represents a single deity expressing three divine functions: creation, preservation and destruction. While Brahma is not widely worshipped today, Lord Vishnu and Shiva remain the main expressions of the Trimurti in contemporary Hindu practice.
Monotheism within Hinduism
Although Hinduism appears to have thousands of gods, both Shaivas and Vaishnavas view their chosen deity as the ultimate reality (Brahman). This creates a form of monotheism – the worship of a single supreme god.
From this perspective, the many gods represent different aspects of one Supreme Being manifested in various forms. In practice, most Hindus worship a limited number of deities rather than the entire pantheon.
Vaishnava devotion: Worship of Lord Vishnu
Lord Vishnu holds a position of immense importance in Indian religion, equal to that of Shiva. Vaishnavism centers on the worship of Vishnu as the supreme deity.
Vishnu's role as preserver
Lord Vishnu is known particularly for his ability to incarnate on Earth to:
- Promote dharma (right living)
- Alleviate suffering
- Restore cosmic balance
When dharma declines or chaos threatens the world, Lord Vishnu manifests in different forms to set things right. This earns him the title of 'preserver of the universe'. These manifestations are called avatars – forms or incarnations of the divine.
The ten avatars of Lord Vishnu
The Vishnu Purana (composed around 400 CE) lists ten major avatars. Each avatar connects to a particular story or serves a specific purpose:
-
Matsya (the Fish) – Saves the first man (Manu) from a great flood in fish form
-
Kurma (the Tortoise) – Supports a mountain used by gods to churn the Milk Ocean, producing all worldly things and the nectar of immortality
-
Varaha (the Boar) – Rescues the Earth from the depths of the Cosmic Ocean
-
Narasimha (half-man, half-beast) – Destroys a terrible demon threatening the universe
-
Vamana (the Dwarf) – Wins the world back from the demon Bali through a clever request for land the size of three strides, then expanding to cover the universe in two steps
-
Parasurama (fierce warrior) – Comes to destroy oppressive warriors (Kshatriyas) who are harming society
-
Ramachandra (Rama the benevolent King) – The hero king of the great epic, the Ramayana
-
Krishna (the complete and all-pervading being) – The most popular form of Lord Vishnu and hero of the Bhagavad Gita
-
Buddha (the enlightened one) – Born as a prince, later attained enlightenment and preached Buddhism
-
Kalki – A white horse (or god on a horse) that will come at the end of this cosmic cycle to destroy the wicked and restore balance
Krishna: The most beloved avatar
Krishna represents the most famous and widely worshipped avatar of Lord Vishnu. He appears as a powerful figure in India's greatest epic, the Mahabharata.
The most significant scripture featuring Krishna is the Bhagavad Gita ('Song of the Lord'), which appears as the eighteenth chapter of the Mahabharata. This dialogue between Krishna and the warrior Arjuna takes place on a battlefield just before two great armies clash. Though only a small part of the epic, the Bhagavad Gita is often published separately and read widely as one of India's most important sacred texts.
Sources of Vaishnava tradition
The Puranas are sacred writings containing stories of the ancient past, including family histories of kings and gods. In the Vedas (earlier texts), Lord Vishnu appears as a god identified with the Sun and its three phases, described metaphorically as taking three strides across the sky.
Over time, as reflected in the Puranas, the importance of Vishnu, Shiva and Devi (the mother goddess) increased markedly from the earlier Vedic period.
The Vishnu Purana describes Vishnu as the most powerful of the gods, who:
- Wakes from slumber between cosmic cycles
- Becomes the creator god Brahma to project the universe
- Sustains the universe as Lord Vishnu
- Changes into Rudra (another name for Shiva) to withdraw the universe back into its potential phase
Shaiva devotion: Worship of Lord Shiva
Shiva represents both a single supreme god and a deity intimately connected to a whole family of gods. He has become immensely important as both a local deity and a universal deity.
Shiva's primary characteristics
Understanding Shiva requires recognizing three key aspects of his nature:
Three Key Aspects of Shiva's Nature:
-
Force of transformation – Shiva primarily represents transformation, which includes both destruction of one form and its reappearance as something else. Since matter is never truly destroyed but simply changes form, Shiva associates with both death and rebirth.
-
The ascetic ideal – Shiva represents the inversion of the universe and the ascetic ideal of renunciation. While Lord Vishnu represents the ideal householder who preserves society, Shiva represents withdrawal from worldly life. However, Shiva is also depicted as married with children, showing his complex nature.
-
Transcendence of duality – Shiva often appears in androgynous form, combining masculine and feminine principles. This represents the Hindu understanding that God ultimately transcends gender, though deities are typically presented in masculine form.
Iconographic representations of Shiva
Shiva appears in several distinct forms, each emphasizing different aspects of his nature:
The Lord of Yoga
Shiva is pictured in deep meditation, removed from the world high in the Himalayas. The goddess Ganga (representing the Ganges River) flows through his hair, symbolizing his control over powerful natural forces.
The family man
Shiva appears with his wife Parvati and his sons Skanda (also known as Murugan or Karthikeya, popular in South India) and Ganesha (the elephant-headed god). The sacred bull Nandi accompanies them as Shiva's vehicle, representing the principle of dharma or right living.
Shiva Nataraja (Lord of the Dance)
This famous image shows Shiva eternally dancing the dance of the universe. The depiction demonstrates both his boundless energy and the constantly moving energy of the cosmos.
The Lingam
Shiva appears as a lingam – a symbolic stone set in a vagina-like dish called the yoni. This representation symbolizes generation and the creative power of the universe.
Shiva as destroyer and regenerator
Shiva's role as 'destroyer' must be understood within the Hindu concept of cyclical time. Hindus believe the cosmos undergoes endless cycles of:
- Sristhi (evolution or emergence)
- Pralaya (involution or dissolution)
Indian understanding of time is cyclical rather than linear. Every end leads to a new beginning. The Trimurti of Brahma, Lord Vishnu and Shiva personify the threefold universal energy of projection, sustenance and dissolution.
They represent three functional aspects of a personal deity, most commonly understood as forms of either Shiva or Lord Vishnu (depending on whether one is a Shaiva or Vaishnava).
Comparing Vaishnavas and Shaivas
While both traditions share much in common, they differ in their understanding of ultimate reality:
Key Theological Difference:
- Vaishnavas view Lord Vishnu as Brahman (the supreme reality)
- Shaivas view Shiva as Brahman (the supreme reality)
Both perspectives are recognized within formal Brahmanism.
However, it is important to remember that Hinduism encompasses enormous variety. Many Hindus in remote or tribal areas predominantly worship local deities and follow local traditions rather than adhering strictly to either Vaishnava or Shaiva practice.
The relationship between preservation and transformation
The contrast between Lord Vishnu and Shiva represents complementary aspects of cosmic order:
- Lord Vishnu preserves the universe and maintains dharma through his avatars
- Shiva transforms the universe through cycles of destruction and renewal
Despite their different emphases, both deities work to maintain cosmic balance. Followers of each tradition may see their chosen deity as supreme, yet both recognize the importance of the other gods within the broader Hindu pantheon.
Contemporary Hindu practice
Hindu temples in Australia
Numerous Hindu temples exist across New South Wales, particularly in the western suburbs of Sydney. These temples typically identify as either Shaiva or Vaishnava, though many contain statues of multiple deities to accommodate the devotional preferences of local worshipers.
Hindu festivals in Australia
Major Hindu festivals are celebrated in Australian cities with significant Hindu populations:
Divali (Festival of Lights) – Celebrated in parks and public spaces, often with local council support. The celebrations in and around Parramatta are particularly spectacular.
Ganesh Festival – Held annually around September at the Sri Ventakeshwara Temple in Helensburgh, southern Sydney. This festival appeals to both Shaivites and Vaishnavites since Ganesha is Shiva's son. The celebration culminates in a ritual at Stanwell Beach, where a large statue of Ganesh is paraded along the beach and cast into the sea with music, chanting and celebration.
Remember!
Key Points to Remember:
-
Vaishnavism and Shaivism are the two main variants in Hinduism, focusing on Lord Vishnu and Shiva respectively as the supreme deity
-
The Trimurti represents Brahman expressed in three forms: Brahma (creator), Vishnu (preserver) and Shiva (destroyer/transformer)
-
Lord Vishnu manifests in ten avatars to restore dharma when chaos threatens; Krishna is the most popular avatar
-
Shiva represents transformation and appears in multiple forms including the Lord of Yoga, Nataraja (Lord of the Dance), and the lingam
-
Both Vaishnavas and Shaivas practice forms of monotheism, viewing thousands of gods as aspects of one supreme reality
-
Despite theological differences, both traditions coexist within Hinduism and share core concepts like sanatana dharma, karma and reincarnation