Positioning Strategies (AQA A-Level Business): Revision Notes
Positioning Strategies
What is a positioning strategy?
A positioning strategy is a crucial strategic choice that determines how a business competes in the market. It's about deciding where your business sits compared to your competitors and what makes you different or better.
Your positioning strategy forms part of your overall marketing strategy. The decisions you make about positioning will influence the general direction your business takes and impact every area of the business, from product development to pricing and promotion.
Different positioning strategies work for different companies. There's no one-size-fits-all approach. The right strategy depends on several factors:
- The product itself and its features
- The state of the economy
- The company's image and reputation
- Available resources (money, staff, facilities)
- The company's mission and values
Critical Warning: Choosing the Wrong Strategy
Choosing the wrong positioning strategy can be disastrous. For example, trying to sell value products at too high a price, or luxury products at too low a price, will likely lead to failure.
Competitive advantage
Understanding competitive advantage
A business has a competitive advantage when customers perceive a clear benefit to buying its products compared to competitors' products. This advantage is often built on a firm's core competences – the things the business does exceptionally well.
There are two main types of competitive advantage:
Cost advantage
A business achieves a cost advantage by selling a similar product at a lower cost than its rivals. This doesn't necessarily mean selling at a lower price – it means producing more cheaply, which gives the business flexibility in pricing.
Example: Low-Cost Airlines Strategy
Low-cost airlines like EasyJet and Ryanair use a "no frills" strategy to keep costs at an absolute minimum.
How they achieve cost advantage:
- Choose cheaper airports (like Luton)
- Eliminate travel agents' fees by using online booking systems
- Remove non-essential services to minimize costs
- Achieve high volume sales at low prices
Differentiation advantage
A differentiation advantage comes from selling better products at the same price, or slightly higher prices, than competitors.
Businesses create differentiation by offering products that consumers see as different from competitors' offerings. This makes customers think the product is better, creating what's called perceived differentiation.
Benefits of having a competitive advantage
Having a competitive advantage is valuable because it allows businesses to:
1. Achieve high sales volume and profits
- Selling a high volume of products at a low price can generate a large profit
- Alternatively, not selling enough products at a high price can still produce a large profit
- The key is having an advantage that justifies either approach
2. Build brand loyalty
- A competitive advantage helps build brand loyalty – customers associate the particular advantage with the brand
- This makes customers more likely to choose that brand in the future
- Loyal customers provide stable, repeat business
Maintaining competitive advantage is challenging
However, holding on to your competitive advantage can be tricky. Several factors can erode your advantage:
Threats to Your Competitive Advantage:
- Low-cost production might become difficult to maintain as costs rise
- Competitors can lower their prices or copy your unique features
- Consumer tastes can change, reducing demand for luxury or value products
- Changes in the economy can alter demand patterns
This means businesses need to continuously monitor both internal factors (within the business) and external factors (in the wider environment) to keep their advantage intact.
Porter's three generic strategies
Management expert Michael Porter identified three generic strategies that businesses can use to gain competitive advantage. These strategies are based on the strengths of low costs and differentiation.
1. Cost leadership
Cost leadership strategy aims to achieve the lowest cost of production for a given level of quality.
How it works:
- Big firms with large and efficient production facilities can use this strategy effectively
- These businesses benefit from economies of scale (costs per unit fall as production volume increases)
- In a price war, the firm can maintain profitability while competitors suffer losses
- If prices decline across the market, the firm stays profitable because of its low costs
Exam tip: Remember that cost leadership isn't just about charging low prices – it's about having the lowest production costs, which gives you strategic flexibility.
2. Differentiation
Differentiation strategy requires offering a product with unique attributes that consumers value, making them perceive it as better than rival products.
How it works:
- Unique products allow businesses to charge premium prices
- Businesses that are innovative and have strong branding benefit most from this strategy
- They can offer quality products that command higher prices
Risks to watch:
- Imitation by competitors who copy your unique features
- Changes in consumer tastes that make your unique features less valued
3. Focus
Focus strategy concentrates on niche market segments to achieve either cost advantage or differentiation.
How it works:
- This strategy suits firms with fewer resources who can't target mass markets
- The business targets customers with specific needs
- A firm using this strategy usually builds loyal customers, making it very hard for other firms to compete
- The narrow focus means the business can meet customer needs precisely
Exam tip: Focus can be combined with either cost leadership (cost focus) or differentiation (differentiation focus) – it's about the market scope, not the type of advantage.
Porter's strategic matrix
Porter's strategic matrix is a tool that helps businesses choose their positioning strategy based on two factors:
- Their competitive advantage (cost or differentiation)
- Their market scope (broad or narrow)
The four quadrants
The matrix creates four strategic positions:
1. Cost leadership (broad market scope + cost advantage)
- Targeting the mass market with cheaper products than competitors
- Strategy works best with efficient operations and economies of scale
Example: Cost Leadership in Action
Accessorize sells jewellery products to a broad market at relatively low prices, demonstrating successful cost leadership in the mass market.
2. Differentiation (broad market scope + differentiation advantage)
- Offering unique, quality products to the mass market
- Premium pricing for superior products
- Requires strong brand and innovation capabilities
3. Cost focus (narrow market scope + cost advantage)
- Targeting a niche market with cost-efficient products
- Serving specific segments with good value
- Lower resource requirements than broad market strategies
4. Differentiation and focus (narrow market scope + differentiation advantage)
- Offering unique, quality products to a niche market
- Premium positioning in specialized segments
Example: Differentiation and Focus
Tiffany & Co. sells high-quality jewellery at premium prices to a narrow, wealthy market segment. This focused differentiation strategy allows them to command premium prices while serving a specific customer base.
Bowman's strategic clock
Bowman's strategic clock provides a more detailed framework for understanding positioning strategies. It shows different strategic positions based on two variables:
- Price (from low to high)
- Perceived added value or benefits (from low to high)
The clock demonstrates that some positioning strategies are more likely to be successful than others.
The eight positions
Position 1: Low price, low added value
- Strategy of low-price products with minimal added value
- Only successful if products sell in a high volume
- Risky position that requires significant sales
Position 2: Low price
- Corresponds to the cost leadership strategy in Porter's matrix
- Can be successful with efficient operations
Position 3: Hybrid
- The hybrid area combines modest prices with relatively high perceived added value
- Balances affordability with quality
- A middle-ground approach that can be very effective
Position 4: Differentiation
- Corresponds to the differentiation section of Porter's strategic matrix
- High perceived value justifies higher prices
- Strong competitive position
Position 5: Focused differentiation
- Corresponds to the differentiation and focus section of Porter's matrix
- Premium products for specific market segments
- Highly sustainable with loyal customer base
Positions 6-8: The Grey Area (Strategies Destined to Fail)
These positions combine a high price with fairly low perceived added value. Unless a company has a monopoly, adopting these positioning strategies will ultimately fail. Customers won't pay high prices for products they don't perceive as valuable.
Position 6: Increased price, standard value
Position 7: Increased price, low added value
Position 8: Low added value, standard price
Using the strategic clock
The strategic clock can be used to analyse the competitive position of a company. It's similar to Porter's strategic matrix but goes into more detail about pricing and value combinations.
Exam tip: When analysing a company's position, consider both where they currently are on the clock and whether that position is sustainable. Positions 3, 4, and 5 are generally the safest strategic choices.
Key Points to Remember:
-
Positioning strategy is a strategic choice that affects all areas of the business and determines how you compete in the market.
-
Two types of competitive advantage exist: cost advantage (producing at lower costs) and differentiation advantage (offering better or unique products).
-
Porter identified three generic strategies: cost leadership, differentiation, and focus. These can be combined in different ways depending on market scope.
-
Maintaining competitive advantage is challenging – businesses must monitor internal and external factors continuously to protect their position.
-
Not all positioning strategies succeed – Bowman's strategic clock shows that high prices with low perceived value (positions 6-8) will generally fail unless you have a monopoly.