Multinational Corporations (AQA A-Level Business): Revision Notes
Multinational Corporations
What are multinational corporations?
A multinational corporation (MNC) is a business that operates in multiple countries simultaneously. Unlike a business that simply exports products abroad, a multinational has physical operations spanning different nations.
Key characteristics include:
- A head office located in one country, which coordinates all global activities
- Branches or departments established in other countries
- Offices or factories in various locations that provide services or manufacture goods
The scale of multinational corporations can be enormous. Some of the largest multinationals now have annual turnovers that exceed the GDP (gross domestic product) of entire countries. This gives them significant economic power and influence on a global scale.
Multinationals can utilise the different locations of their factories to produce goods in the most cost-effective way possible. This strategic positioning has significantly increased the level of international trade worldwide.
How multinationals benefit developing countries
When multinational corporations expand into developing countries, they can bring several important advantages that support economic development and improve living standards.
Employment opportunities
Multinationals create job opportunities for local populations in countries where they establish operations. This is particularly valuable in developing countries where unemployment may be high and formal employment opportunities limited.
Improved standard of living
Although employees in developing countries typically earn less than workers in developed nations, multinational employers often offer better pay and conditions compared to local companies in the same country. This relative improvement can raise the standard of living for workers and their families.
Inward investment
Multinationals inject capital into the host country through inward investment. They spend money constructing factories and building essential infrastructure such as roads and transport networks.
This type of investment is called foreign direct investment (FDI), which brings long-term benefits to the developing economy. FDI represents a commitment to the local economy that goes beyond simply exporting goods, as it involves building physical assets and creating lasting economic relationships.
Economic growth
Multinationals contribute to economic growth in each country they expand into. The GDP of the host country increases due to additional spending in the economy. This spending occurs through various channels, including increased travel to the area by business people and tourists, and greater demand for hotel rooms from visiting businesspeople.
Tax revenue
When multinationals locate in developing countries, they pay taxes to the local government. This generates increased government income, which can be invested in public services such as schools and hospitals.
Tax payments may include:
- Taxes on land purchases
- Taxes on the wages paid to local employees
- Taxes on the profits generated
- Taxes on products exported abroad
Ethical business practices
Some ethical multinationals actively try to benefit the countries where they locate by paying fair wages rather than exploiting workers. Whilst this increases costs for the business, companies that highlight their ethical trading practices may find that consumers are willing to pay slightly higher prices for their products. This demonstrates that ethical behaviour and profitability can coexist.
How multinationals can exploit developing countries
Despite the potential benefits, some multinational businesses exploit developing countries to maximise their profits, often at significant cost to local workers, communities and environments.
Low wages and poor conditions
Some multinationals deliberately establish production facilities in countries with low wages to reduce their costs. They may set up sweatshops – factories where employees work long hours in difficult and sometimes dangerous conditions for minimal payment. This exploitation prioritises profit over worker welfare.
Child labour
A multinational might locate in a country with less strict employment laws in order to reduce costs by employing child labour. This forces young people to work long shifts, often operating safety equipment they are not trained to use, which can have devastating consequences.
Products failing to meet safety standards
Some multinationals sell products to developing countries that don't meet EU or American safety standards. This double standard puts consumers in poorer countries at risk from unsafe goods that would be prohibited in wealthier nations.
Unsustainable extraction of natural resources
A multinational might extract large quantities of unsustainable natural resources such as oil, gas or minerals from developing countries. When these resources run out, there may be nothing left for future generations. Additionally, some companies fail to redevelop the landscape after extraction, leaving environmental damage behind.
Weak environmental laws
In some developing countries, environmental laws are less strict than in developed nations. Multinationals might take advantage of this by polluting or damaging the environment in ways they would not be permitted to do elsewhere. This allows them to minimise their environmental impact costs whilst maximising profits.
Government oversight issues
The governments of developing countries might overlook unlawful behaviour by multinational businesses. This occurs because governments rely heavily on the tax income generated by these companies, making them reluctant to enforce regulations that might cause the business to relocate elsewhere.
Corporate social responsibility
It's important to note that many multinational companies are increasingly committed to Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR). As a result, exploitation is less common than it used to be, though problems still exist in some industries and regions.
Why multinationals locate in developed countries
Whilst developing countries offer certain advantages, multinationals also have strong reasons for establishing operations in developed countries.
Stable and growing economies
Developed countries typically have stable and growing economies, which makes them attractive locations for multinationals. These markets contain plenty of potential customers with disposable income to purchase products and services.
Market access without manufacturing
Rather than setting up production facilities, multinationals often simply sell their products in developed countries. This approach helps them keep distribution costs low whilst accessing wealthy consumer markets.
Tax advantages
Producing goods in the country where they're sold can help companies avoid some taxes, particularly import duties. This makes local production financially attractive even in higher-cost developed countries.
European Union advantages
Many global multinationals maintain factories and distribution centres in at least one country that is a member of the European Union (EU). This strategic positioning allows them to sell their products to all EU countries without having to pay import tax.
Real-World Example: Japanese Car Manufacturers
Toyota and Honda (both Japanese car manufacturers) have factories in the UK for distribution within the EU. This strategic location enables them to:
- Manufacture vehicles within the EU market
- Avoid import taxes when selling to other EU countries
- Access the entire European market efficiently
- Reduce overall distribution costs across Europe
Political, economic and legal restraints on multinationals
Multinationals face various controls and limitations designed to regulate their behaviour and protect national interests.
Government coordination
As multinational corporations operate in many different countries, each with its own laws and regulations, governments sometimes coordinate their approaches to control and manage the activities of multinationals. This cooperation helps prevent multinationals from exploiting gaps between different national regulations.
EU harmonisation
The European Union has attempted to standardise employment laws across member states. These include equal opportunities legislation and health and safety standards. This ensures that multinational corporations operating within the EU must meet minimum standards wherever they locate.
This process of creating common standards is known as harmonisation. It helps create a level playing field for businesses while protecting workers' rights across all member states.
Protectionist policies
Governments sometimes implement protectionist policies such as tariffs (taxes on imports) and quotas (limits on import quantities) to protect their own economies. These measures can restrict multinational corporations' ability to import products freely, encouraging them to produce goods locally instead.
Pressure groups
Pressure groups sometimes attempt to influence government policy regarding multinational organisations. These groups may campaign to persuade governments to impose tighter controls on how multinationals from one country operate in other countries. For example, they might push for regulations preventing multinationals from using child labour in foreign countries.
Transfer pricing
Transfer pricing occurs when a multinational business buys and sells products between different parts of the company located in different countries. This practice can make it very difficult for governments to control the taxes a multinational pays.
Through transfer pricing, companies can manipulate their accounts to make all the profits appear to belong in a country with very low tax rates. This reduces the amount of tax the multinational pays overall. However, this practice might conflict with any Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) commitments the business has made, as it reduces the tax contribution to countries where they operate.
Remember!
Key Points to Remember:
-
Multinational corporations operate in multiple countries with a head office coordinating global activities, and some have turnovers larger than entire countries' GDP.
-
Multinationals can benefit developing countries through employment, better wages, infrastructure investment (FDI), economic growth, and tax revenue for public services.
-
However, multinationals may exploit developing countries through low wages, poor conditions, child labour, unsafe products, resource extraction, and taking advantage of weak environmental laws.
-
Multinationals locate in developed countries for stable economies, wealthy customer bases, tax advantages, and EU market access without import duties.
-
Governments regulate multinationals through coordination, EU harmonisation of standards, protectionist policies, pressure group influence, and monitoring of transfer pricing practices.