Pragmatics (AQA A-Level English Language): Revision Notes
Pragmatics
What is pragmatics?
Pragmatics is a subfield of linguistics that examines how we use and understand language in real-life contexts. Unlike other areas of language study that focus purely on words and grammar, pragmatics is concerned with the practical aspects of communication. It explores how the meaning of what we say depends heavily on the situation we're in, who we're speaking to, and what we're trying to achieve through our words.
The field of pragmatics covers several key areas:
- Speech acts: the actions we perform through language, such as promising, requesting, or apologising
- Conversational implicature: the implied meanings that go beyond the literal words spoken
- Context-dependent interpretation: how the same words or sentences can mean different things in different situations
Understanding pragmatics is essential for grasping how children learn to become effective communicators, not just speakers of grammatically correct sentences.
Early pragmatic development
Pre-verbal communication
Before children begin using words, they are already developing pragmatic understanding through non-verbal means. This early stage is crucial for later language development and includes:
- Gestures: pointing, waving, or reaching to communicate wants and needs
- Joint attention: the ability to share focus on an object or event with another person, which forms the foundation for later conversational skills
- Pre-linguistic vocalisations: sounds like cooing, babbling, and intonation patterns that convey meaning before actual words emerge
These early communicative behaviours demonstrate that children understand the purpose of communication – to share information and achieve goals – before they have the linguistic tools to do so verbally.
Key aspects of pragmatic development
Discourse rules
As children become more proficient with language, they gradually learn the unwritten rules that govern conversations. These discourse rules include:
- Knowing when it's appropriate to speak and when to listen
- Understanding how to take turns in conversation without interrupting
- Staying on topic and making relevant contributions
- Recognising when a topic has been exhausted and when to move on
These skills develop progressively throughout childhood and require children to become aware of both their own and others' contributions to conversations.
Speech Act Theory
Speech Act Theory is a fundamental concept in pragmatics that emphasises language as action rather than just description. The theory recognises that when we speak, we are "doing" things with words, not merely "saying" things.
Children's developing ability to understand and use different language functions is a key part of their pragmatic development. These functions include:
- Questioning: seeking information or clarification
- Requesting: asking for objects, actions, or assistance
- Promising: committing to future actions
- Refusing: declining offers or rejecting suggestions
- Apologising: expressing regret or seeking forgiveness
Worked Example: Understanding Speech Acts
Consider the sentence "It's cold in here."
Depending on context, this could function as:
- A statement: simply describing the temperature
- An indirect request: asking someone to close a window or turn on heating
- A complaint: expressing dissatisfaction with the conditions
Children must learn to interpret the intended speech act based on situational cues, not just the literal words.
Understanding that the same sentence can perform different actions depending on context is a sophisticated pragmatic skill that develops over time.
Politeness theory
Politeness theory addresses how children learn to adjust their language to suit different social contexts and relationships. This is a crucial aspect of pragmatic competence that develops gradually throughout childhood.
Key elements of politeness development include:
- Learning to use polite markers such as "please" and "thank you" appropriately
- Understanding indirect requests (e.g., "Could you pass the salt?" rather than "Pass the salt")
- Recognising and using different formality registers depending on the social situation
- Adjusting language based on the relationship with the listener (e.g., speaking differently to teachers versus friends)
Children must learn not just the polite forms themselves, but when and why to use them, which requires sophisticated social awareness.
Narrative skills
The development of narrative skills represents another important milestone in pragmatic progression. This refers to a child's ability to tell or understand a story with a coherent, logical sequence.
Narrative development involves:
- Organising events in a temporal order
- Including relevant details whilst omitting unnecessary information
- Understanding cause and effect relationships
- Creating coherent connections between different parts of a story
- Adjusting the narrative based on the listener's needs (e.g., providing more background information to someone unfamiliar with the events)
Strong narrative skills are essential not just for storytelling but for many academic and social situations where extended discourse is required.
Deixis
Deixis is a crucial concept in child language development that refers to words whose meaning depends entirely on context. These deictic expressions include:
- Spatial deixis: "this", "that", "here", "there" (location depends on speaker's position)
- Temporal deixis: "now", "then", "yesterday", "tomorrow" (time depends on when the utterance is made)
- Personal deixis: "I", "you", "we", "they" (reference depends on who is speaking and who they're addressing)
Children must understand the shifting nature of these words and learn to interpret them based on the context in which they're used.
Worked Example: Understanding Deixis
Consider the word "here":
- If Sarah says "Put the book here" while standing at her desk, "here" means Sarah's desk
- If Tom says "Put the book here" while standing at the shelf, "here" means the shelf
- The same word has different referents depending on who says it and where they are
Similarly, "yesterday" refers to:
- Monday if said on Tuesday
- Saturday if said on Sunday
- A different date depending on when the conversation takes place
Mastering deixis is challenging because it requires children to understand perspective-taking and to recognise that language is anchored to the immediate context of communication.
Grice's Maxims
Grice's Maxims are a set of four principles that describe how people typically behave in cooperative conversations. Understanding these maxims is essential for effective communication.
The four maxims are:
1. Maxim of Quantity: provide just enough information – not too much, not too little. Say as much as is required for the current purposes of the conversation.
Example of Quantity Maxim
If asked "Where do you live?", responding with just "London" might be sufficient for a casual conversation, but providing "23 Oak Street, London, SW1 2AB" might be too much information unless specifically needed.
2. Maxim of Quality: be truthful and avoid saying things you believe to be false or for which you lack adequate evidence.
Example of Quality Maxim
When asked "Have you finished your homework?", a child should respond truthfully rather than saying "yes" when they haven't, as this would violate the maxim of quality.
3. Maxim of Relevance: stay on topic and make contributions that are relevant to the current conversation.
Example of Relevance Maxim
In a discussion about weekend plans:
- Relevant response: "I'm going to the cinema on Saturday"
- Irrelevant response: "My favourite colour is blue"
4. Maxim of Manner: communicate clearly and unambiguously. Avoid obscurity and ambiguity, be brief, and be orderly in your contributions.
Children gradually internalise these principles as they develop pragmatic competence. They learn not only to follow these maxims themselves but also to recognise when others are flouting them, which can create humorous or ironic effects.
Both social and cognitive factors influence pragmatic development
A child's growing pragmatic awareness is shaped by both their cognitive development and their social experiences. As children mature cognitively, they become better able to take others' perspectives and understand implied meanings. Simultaneously, their social interactions provide opportunities to practice and refine these skills in real-world contexts.
Ongoing development
It's important to recognise that pragmatic development is not complete in early childhood. Rather, it is a continuous process that extends into adolescence and beyond. As individuals encounter new social situations and relationships, they continue to adjust to changing social expectations and language use conventions.
Teenagers and adults continue to refine their pragmatic skills as they navigate increasingly complex social environments, professional settings, and diverse cultural contexts. What counts as appropriate or effective communication can vary significantly across different contexts, requiring lifelong learning and adaptation.
Exam tips
Exam Preparation Guidelines
- When analysing children's language for pragmatic development, look beyond just what they say to consider how they use language in context
- Be prepared to identify examples of different speech acts, politeness strategies, or violations of Grice's Maxims in transcripts or examples
- Remember that pragmatic development is closely linked to cognitive and social development – children need both the mental capacity to understand others' perspectives and the social experience to learn appropriate conventions
- Consider the difference between pragmatic competence (what children know about appropriate language use) and pragmatic performance (how they actually use language in real situations)
Remember!
Key Points to Remember:
-
Pragmatics focuses on language in context: it's about how we use language appropriately in different situations, not just grammatical correctness
-
Early pragmatic development begins before speech: infants communicate through gestures, joint attention, and pre-linguistic sounds before using words
-
Key pragmatic concepts include:
- Discourse rules (turn-taking, topic maintenance)
- Speech Act Theory (language as action)
- Politeness theory (formal vs informal register)
- Deixis (context-dependent words like "this", "here", "now")
-
Grice's Maxims (Quantity, Quality, Relevance, Manner) describe the cooperative principles that guide effective conversation
-
Pragmatic development is lifelong: children, teenagers, and adults continue to refine their pragmatic skills as they encounter new social situations and expectations throughout life