The Influence of Preachers (Edexcel A-Level History): Revision Notes
The Influence of Preachers
Introduction: The role of preachers in crusade recruitment
In medieval Europe, before the existence of mass media, newspapers, or widespread literacy, preachers played a vital role in communicating the pope's call for crusade to the wider population. These preachers were typically influential religious figures who travelled extensively across countries, visiting major towns, villages, and cities to spread the crusading message and recruit participants.
Medieval communication relied entirely on personal contact and word-of-mouth. In a world without printing presses, radio, or television, the only way to reach large numbers of people was through travelling speakers who could deliver messages directly to gathered crowds.
The work of preachers transformed the pope's religious appeal into a physical reality by organising recruitment events where local people could formally commit to becoming crusaders. Without effective preaching, crusades would have struggled to attract sufficient numbers of knights and soldiers. Preachers served as the essential link between papal authority and popular participation in the crusades.
Case Study: Archbishop Baldwin's Welsh Campaign
Archbishop Baldwin of Canterbury undertook a preaching tour across Wales in 1188. According to contemporary chronicles, his tour successfully enlisted approximately 3,000 crusaders, demonstrating the significant impact a skilled preacher could have on recruitment numbers.
How the recruitment process worked
When a preacher arrived in a town or city, the recruitment process typically followed an established pattern that combined religious ceremony with public appeal.
The recruitment ceremony
Local people from the surrounding areas would gather in a large open space to hear the preacher's message. The event included several religious elements:
- A mass (Catholic religious service) would be celebrated
- A homily (sermon) would be delivered, explaining the religious significance of the crusade
- The main ceremony involved a public invitatio – a formal appeal for people to take the cross and become crusaders
Taking the crusader's vow
Men who wished to join the crusade would come forward during the invitatio to receive a cloth cross. This cross would be pinned or sewn onto their clothing as a visible symbol of their commitment. By taking the cross, they made a crusader's vow – a solemn religious promise to complete the crusade. They were required to wear this cross until they had fulfilled their vow, making their commitment publicly visible to their community.
This ceremony was powerful because it transformed an abstract religious idea into a concrete, physical commitment that could be seen and witnessed by the entire community. The cloth cross became a permanent, visible reminder of the vow that carried both religious and social obligations.
Preaching techniques and strategies
As crusading developed throughout the 11th and 12th centuries, preachers refined various methods to attract as many noble and knightly recruits as possible. Five key techniques emerged:
Choosing the right day
Preachers learned to time their arrival strategically to coincide with holy days and religious festivals. Pope Urban II established this tradition during his preaching tour of 1095-96.
Strategic Timing: Urban II at St Gilles
Urban II deliberately arrived at St Gilles on the feast day of its patron saint, St Giles. This timing meant the town was already gathered for religious celebrations, creating a receptive audience predisposed to think about spiritual matters.
Gathering in outdoor locations
Preachers selected large outdoor venues to ensure maximum space for audiences. These locations were carefully prepared and arranged for dramatic effect.
Development: By the 1190s, preachers became even more sophisticated, standing in front of large canvas paintings that depicted the Muslim threat to Jerusalem. These visual aids helped create an atmosphere similar to a modern festival or major public event, with crowds gathering around the preacher.
Maximising the quality of the audience
While all Christians were theoretically welcome at crusade preaching events, preachers particularly targeted wealthy knights and noblemen. These individuals had the financial resources, military training, and social influence necessary for successful crusading.
Optimal Audience: Bernard at Vézelay
When Bernard of Clairvaux preached at Vézelay in 1146, his audience included King Louis VII of France and most of the French nobility – the ideal group for crusade recruitment.
Creating a pious mood
Preachers understood that people were more likely to take the crusader's vow if they felt spiritually motivated. They therefore created an atmosphere of religious devotion before making their appeal.
Spiritual Incentives: Urban II at Angers
During Pope Urban II's visit to Angers in 1096, he organised a special feast and promised that anyone who attended would receive an indulgence (forgiveness) for one-seventh of their sins. This spiritual incentive helped create the right mood for crusade recruitment.
Encouraging participation through miracles
Preachers used reports of miracles to energise audiences and make them feel that God was actively supporting the crusade. These miracle stories helped convince people that taking the cross was divinely approved.
Miraculous Events: Bernard in Germany
During Bernard of Clairvaux's preaching tour of Germany, chroniclers reported that 235 disabled people were miraculously restored to health. Whether or not these miracles actually occurred, the reports created excitement and enthusiasm that encouraged crusade recruitment.
Evolution of preacher selection and control
The way popes managed crusade preaching became increasingly sophisticated over time, moving from uncontrolled enthusiasm to carefully directed campaigns.
Early problems with uncontrolled preaching
When Pope Urban II launched the First Crusade with his preaching tour of 1095-96, there was little papal control over who else preached the crusade. This created significant problems.
The Peter the Hermit Problem
Popular preachers like Peter the Hermit attracted large followings, but they recruited the wrong type of participants. Instead of trained knights and wealthy nobles, they enlisted poor people, elderly individuals, and women – groups that popes did not want on crusades because they lacked military capability and financial resources.
This demonstrated the danger of uncontrolled preaching: it could mobilise large numbers of people, but not necessarily the right people for military campaigns.
Papal control mechanisms
Learning from these early problems, later popes took direct control over who was authorised to preach crusades.
Controlled Preaching: The Second Crusade
In 1146, Pope Eugenius III personally ordered specific preachers to promote the Second Crusade at the Council of Reims. This gave him direct control over the crusading message and ensured only approved preachers were active.
Use of papal legates
From 1173-74 onwards, popes increasingly used papal legates (official representatives of the pope) to preach crusades. These were trusted churchmen who carried papal authority and could be relied upon to deliver the correct message.
This system reached its full development during the Fourth Crusade, when papal legates became the primary means of crusade preaching, ensuring consistency and control across different regions.
Case study: Bernard of Clairvaux
Bernard of Clairvaux represents one of the most successful and influential crusade preachers of the 12th century. His work for the Second Crusade demonstrates how effective preaching could mobilise major rulers and transform papal appeals into military campaigns.
Bernard's background and authority
Bernard was an exceptionally powerful and influential figure in the medieval Church. He had previously served as the teacher of Pope Eugenius III, which gave him special authority when the pope ordered him to preach the Second Crusade at the Council of Reims in 1146.
Bernard's recruitment campaign
Bernard undertook an extensive promotional campaign for the Second Crusade:
- He went on preaching tours across Flanders and Germany
- He wrote letters to churchmen and nobles throughout Europe
- He personally recruited some of the most important political leaders of his time
Bernard's notable successes
Bernard's most significant achievement was recruiting royal participation in the Second Crusade:
- King Louis VII of France took the cross following Bernard's preaching
- King Conrad III of Germany also committed to the crusade through Bernard's influence
These royal commitments transformed the Second Crusade from a religious appeal into a major military expedition led by two of Europe's most powerful secular rulers. This demonstrates how skilled preachers like Bernard could convert religious motivation into practical military action.
Bernard's methods
Bernard's success came from combining religious authority with practical persuasion. His preaching emphasised the spiritual rewards of crusading while also appealing to the honour and duty of knights and nobles. By targeting the highest levels of society first, he created a cascade effect where lesser nobles followed their rulers' example.
Exam focus: Analysing the importance of preachers
When answering exam questions about crusade recruitment, consider:
For explanation questions (20 marks):
- Explain how preachers converted papal appeals into actual crusade armies
- Link preaching techniques to the social and religious context of medieval Europe
- Show development over time from uncontrolled to controlled preaching
For evaluation questions (30 marks):
- Compare the importance of preachers with other factors (papal bulls, political circumstances, religious motivation)
- Consider both successes (Bernard recruiting kings) and limitations (Peter the Hermit recruiting unsuitable participants)
- Assess how preaching effectiveness changed across different crusades
Common Pitfall to Avoid
Don't just describe what preachers did – explain why their methods were effective in the medieval context (illiteracy, strong religious faith, social hierarchy). Examiners want to see analysis of the relationship between preaching techniques and the specific conditions of medieval European society.
Summary
Key Points to Remember:
-
Preachers were essential for spreading the crusading message in an age before mass media, transforming papal appeals into physical recruitment campaigns
-
The recruitment process followed an established pattern: gathering crowds, celebrating mass, delivering sermons, and conducting the invitatio ceremony where people took the cross
-
Preachers developed five key techniques: choosing holy days, using outdoor locations, targeting wealthy audiences, creating pious moods, and reporting miracles to encourage participation
-
Papal control over preaching evolved from uncontrolled (1095-96) to carefully managed (by 1146), with increasing use of papal legates from 1173-74 onwards
-
Bernard of Clairvaux exemplifies successful crusade preaching, recruiting both King Louis VII of France and King Conrad III of Germany for the Second Crusade in 1146, demonstrating how preachers could mobilise the highest levels of medieval society