Results of the crisis (AQA GCSE History): Revision Notes
Results of the Cuban Missile Crisis
Introduction
The Cuban Missile Crisis in October 1962 brought the world dangerously close to nuclear war. This tense standoff between the United States and Soviet Union over missiles in Cuba became a crucial turning point in the Cold War. The crisis forced both superpowers to recognise the devastating consequences of nuclear conflict and led to significant changes in their relationship.
The Cuban Missile Crisis lasted only 13 days but fundamentally changed how the superpowers approached nuclear diplomacy and conflict resolution.
Short-term results of the crisis
Communist Cuba's survival
Following the crisis, President Kennedy provided assurances that the United States would not invade Cuba again. This guarantee allowed Fidel Castro's communist government to remain in power, maintaining Soviet influence just 90 miles from the American mainland. Cuba effectively became a permanent communist ally of the USSR in the Western Hemisphere.
This proximity made Cuba a particularly sensitive strategic location for both the US and USSR throughout the remainder of the Cold War.
Soviet missile withdrawal and American concessions
The USSR publicly removed its missiles from Cuba as part of the agreement to end the crisis. However, what many people didn't know at the time was that America also secretly agreed to withdraw its Jupiter missiles from Turkey. This secret deal helped both leaders save face with their domestic audiences while resolving the immediate threat.
The secret nature of the American concessions in Turkey had significant political consequences, particularly for Soviet leadership who appeared to have gained nothing from the crisis.
Impact on Soviet leadership
The crisis damaged Khrushchev's reputation within the Soviet Union because the withdrawal made the USSR appear weak on the world stage. Many Soviet officials were unaware of America's secret concession to remove missiles from Turkey, so they only saw Khrushchev backing down to American pressure. This weakened position contributed to his removal from power in 1964, when he was replaced by Leonid Brezhnev.
Strengthening of peace movements
The terrifying prospect of nuclear war energised peace activists, particularly in America. The US peace lobby gained significant influence as ordinary citizens demanded their government work harder to avoid such dangerous confrontations in the future.
The dangerous moments during the crisis
Kennedy's assessment of the risks
President Kennedy later admitted to his brother Robert that the American response had been an enormous gamble. The crisis demonstrated how quickly diplomatic tensions could escalate into potential nuclear warfare, with leaders making life-or-death decisions under extreme pressure.
Kennedy's admission reveals how nuclear crises involve massive risks that leaders may only fully appreciate in retrospect.
Castro's aggressive stance
Fidel Castro ordered Soviet forces stationed in Cuba to prepare for battle, showing his willingness to fight American invasion forces. On October 23, 1962, Soviet naval vessels approached the American blockade in what became a test of nerves between the superpowers.
The brink of nuclear war
Several incidents nearly triggered military action:
- On October 25, a Soviet ship approached Cuba and encountered the US Navy. Although the ship was allowed through after refusing to cooperate, Kennedy chose not to provoke Khrushchev further
- On October 26, over 120,000 US troops assembled in preparation for a potential invasion of Cuba
- The same day, Khrushchev sent a letter offering to withdraw missiles if America promised not to invade Cuba
Critical incidents on October 27
The Most Dangerous Day: October 27, 1962
October 27, 1962, became the most dangerous day of the crisis with multiple near-catastrophic incidents:
Morning: A US Navy destroyer spotted a Soviet submarine near Cuba and fired depth charges to force it to surface. The submarine captain initially intended to retaliate but was prevented by a senior Soviet officer aboard.
Afternoon: A US U2 spy plane was shot down over Cuba, killing the pilot.
Evening: Another U2 plane accidentally entered Soviet airspace over Alaska and was fired upon.
Late Evening: Khrushchev sent a second letter with the agreed terms for ending the crisis.
Long-term results and détente
Movement towards improved relations
The Cuban Missile Crisis marked the beginning of détente - a period of reduced tension between East and West. Both superpowers recognised that nuclear war would be catastrophic for humanity and began seeking ways to manage their rivalry more safely.
The Hotline Agreement (1963)
A direct communication link was established between Washington and Moscow, allowing leaders to communicate instantly during future crises. This "hotline" helped prevent misunderstandings that could escalate into military action.
The hotline was initially a teletype connection, not a telephone as often portrayed in popular culture.
Limited Test Ban Treaty (August 1963)
Both the USA and USSR agreed to prohibit nuclear weapon testing except for underground tests. This treaty represented the first major arms control agreement of the Cold War and demonstrated both nations' commitment to reducing nuclear dangers.
Kennedy's new approach
In 1963, President Kennedy delivered a speech emphasising the need to work with the Soviet Union on issues of mutual interest. This marked a significant shift from the purely confrontational approach that had characterised earlier Cold War policies.
Soviet military buildup
Humiliated by having to withdraw from Cuba, the USSR was determined to achieve nuclear parity with the United States. By 1965, Soviet nuclear capabilities had dramatically improved, leading to the concept of Mutually Assured Destruction (MAD) - the idea that nuclear war would be so devastating that both sides would avoid it at all costs.
MAD became a cornerstone of Cold War nuclear strategy, creating a "balance of terror" that paradoxically helped maintain peace through the threat of mutual annihilation.
Further arms control agreements
The crisis led to additional treaties:
- Outer Space Treaty (1967): Limited the deployment of nuclear weapons in space
- Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (1968): Prevented nuclear weapons from being given to other countries
Timeline of key events and consequences
- October 1962: Cuban Missile Crisis occurs
- 1963: Hotline Agreement established
- August 1963: Limited Test Ban Treaty signed
- 1963: Kennedy's speech about cooperation with USSR
- 1964: Khrushchev removed from power, replaced by Brezhnev
- 1965: USSR achieves nuclear parity with USA
- 1967: Outer Space Treaty signed
- 1968: Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty signed
Key Points to Remember:
-
The crisis was a turning point: It marked the beginning of détente and more cooperative East-West relations, as both sides realised how close they had come to nuclear war
-
Secret deals mattered: The USA's secret agreement to remove missiles from Turkey helped end the crisis but also contributed to Khrushchev's downfall when Soviet officials learned of his "weakness"
-
Multiple agreements followed: The crisis led to the Hotline Agreement (1963), Limited Test Ban Treaty (1963), Outer Space Treaty (1967), and Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (1968)
-
Both sides changed: Kennedy moved towards cooperation with the USSR, while the Soviets accelerated their nuclear programme to achieve parity with America
-
MAD became reality: By 1965, both superpowers had enough nuclear weapons to destroy each other, creating a balance of terror that actually helped prevent war