War Communism (Edexcel GCSE History): Revision Notes
War Communism (1918-1921)
What was War Communism?
War Communism was an emergency economic system that the Bolsheviks introduced in 1918. This policy placed Russia's entire economy under direct government control. Lenin argued that such extreme measures were essential if the Bolsheviks were going to survive and win the ongoing Civil War against their enemies.
War Communism represented a complete departure from normal economic practices, essentially turning the entire Russian economy into a military supply operation controlled by the state.
Key features of War Communism
Agricultural control
The government took complete control over food production through a system called requisitioning. Peasant farmers were forbidden from selling their crops on the open market. Instead, the Cheka (secret police) would seize their grain at artificially low prices set by the state, leaving farmers with barely enough to survive. This led to widespread resentment, with many peasants attempting to hide their harvests. When caught hoarding grain, peasants faced severe punishment, including execution.
Industrial nationalisation
The Bolsheviks seized control of all major industries and factories, setting production targets focused entirely on military requirements. Consumer goods became almost non-existent as everything was redirected towards supporting the war effort. This meant ordinary citizens found it nearly impossible to obtain basic necessities like clothing, tools, or household items.
Suppression of freedoms
The government banned strikes and severely restricted political opposition. The Cheka used brutal methods, including what became known as the "Red Terror," to eliminate anyone who challenged Bolshevik authority. Workers lost the right to organise or protest against their deteriorating working conditions.
The Red Terror was a campaign of mass killings and political repression that demonstrated how far the Bolsheviks were willing to go to maintain power during this period.
Economic control
Money was essentially abolished, and instead of wages, workers received rations of food and basic goods. The government also introduced forced labour, compelling people to work where the state decided they were needed most, regardless of their personal preferences or skills.
"War Communism meant that everything in the economy was geared to meeting the needs of the military first."
Why did the Bolsheviks implement War Communism?
Military necessity
The Bolsheviks desperately needed to maintain control over the Red Army's supplies, ensuring soldiers had sufficient weapons and resources to fight the Civil War. Without this control, they risked losing the conflict entirely.
Economic circumstances
The Treaty of Brest-Litovsk in 1918 had devastating economic consequences, with Russia losing 40% of its industrial capacity and 60% of its major food-producing regions. The Whites also controlled other important agricultural areas, making food shortages inevitable.
The Treaty of Brest-Litovsk was Russia's separate peace agreement with Germany, which required massive territorial concessions that severely weakened the Russian economy just as the Civil War was beginning.
Transportation breakdown
Russia's transport system had collapsed, preventing industries from receiving the raw materials they required for production. This created a cycle where factories couldn't operate effectively, workers abandoned cities to find food in rural areas, and industrial output plummeted further.
Consequences of War Communism
Economic disaster
By 1920, agricultural production had collapsed to just 37% of pre-war (1913) levels. Industrial production similarly halved, and the number of factory workers dropped by 50%. This created severe food shortages that developed into full-scale famine in some regions, with reports of people resorting to cannibalism for survival.
Critical Impact: The collapse to 37% of agricultural production meant that War Communism had effectively destroyed Russia's ability to feed its own people, creating one of the worst famines in Russian history.
Social crisis
A thriving black market emerged as people desperately sought basic necessities at extremely high prices. Many urban workers either joined the Red Army or returned to their villages in search of food. Industries produced virtually no consumer goods, making life in cities incredibly difficult.
Political opposition
Factory workers, ironically the very people the Bolsheviks claimed to represent, organised protests and strikes demanding better living conditions and more food. The Kronstadt naval base, previously loyal to the Bolsheviks, experienced a major mutiny. Even Communist Party members began protesting their exclusion from important decisions. Rural areas saw significant uprisings, particularly in Tambov Province, as peasants violently resisted grain requisitioning.
As one contemporary noted: "War Communism, an economic disaster and deeply unpopular, had to be abandoned."
Timeline of key events
- 1918: War Communism introduced; Treaty of Brest-Litovsk signed
- 1918-1921: Civil War period with War Communism in effect
- 1920: Farm production reaches lowest point at 37% of 1913 levels
- 1921: Kronstadt Mutiny occurs; Tambov uprising continues
Key Points to Remember:
-
War Communism was an emergency policy designed to help the Bolsheviks survive the Civil War, not a long-term economic plan
-
Government control was total - agriculture, industry, labour, and even money were all controlled by the state
-
The policy caused massive suffering with farm production dropping to 37% of pre-war levels and widespread famine
-
It created significant opposition including the Kronstadt Mutiny and peasant uprisings like in Tambov Province
-
War Communism ultimately failed and had to be abandoned due to economic collapse and political opposition, leading to the New Economic Policy (NEP) in 1921