Summary: changes in power (AQA GCSE History): Revision Notes
Summary: changes in power
Introduction
Throughout British history from 1170 to the present day, the balance of power has shifted dramatically between different groups in society. Understanding these changes helps us see how Britain transformed from a mediaeval kingdom dominated by the Church and monarchy into a modern democracy where ordinary people have significant influence.
The four main groups that held power during this period were the Church, Parliament, the monarchy, and ordinary people. Each group's influence rose and fell at different times, often with one group gaining power as another lost it.
This period spans over 850 years of British history, during which the fundamental nature of power and governance changed completely. The transformation from mediaeval feudalism to modern democracy represents one of the most significant political evolutions in world history.
The Church's declining influence
Mediaeval dominance (1066-c1450)
During mediaeval times, the Church held enormous power over people's lives. Religion dominated society because Christianity was the only recognised faith, and most people were deeply religious. Church leaders like bishops accumulated great wealth and social status, making them as powerful as nobles. The Church controlled education, provided social services, and influenced political decisions.
In mediaeval Britain, the Church wasn't just a religious institution - it was effectively a parallel government with its own courts, laws, and taxation system. This made it one of the most powerful forces in society.
Early modern challenges (c1450-c1800)
The Church's authority began to face serious challenges during the early modern period. Although people remained religious and still believed that events happened according to God's will, new ideas started to emerge. The fear of what would happen after death continued to motivate many people's behaviour, but the Church's absolute control over religious interpretation was being questioned.
Industrial decline (c1800-c1900)
The Industrial Revolution brought significant changes that weakened the Church's position. While most people still attended church services and considered themselves religious, scientific discoveries began to challenge religious explanations of the world. Religious reformers started questioning traditional Church teachings, and their religious beliefs motivated them to seek social and political changes rather than simply accepting Church authority.
Modern marginalisation (c1900-present)
The twentieth century saw the Church's influence decrease dramatically. By 2001, fewer than 10% of the population regularly attended church services. People increasingly turned to Parliament and government institutions to solve social problems rather than relying on the Church. Religious faith became a personal matter rather than a dominant social force.
The decline of Church influence doesn't mean Britain became completely secular overnight. Many cultural traditions, moral values, and institutional practices still reflect the country's Christian heritage, even as formal religious observance declined.
Parliament's rise to power
Mediaeval absence (1066-c1450)
In mediaeval Britain, Parliament as we know it did not exist. The country was ruled by kings who made decisions with the help of their closest advisers and council members. These councils consisted mainly of nobles and high-ranking clergy, with no representation for ordinary people.
Early modern emergence (c1450-c1800)
Parliament began to develop during this period, though its role remained limited. The Commons gradually became a separate part of Parliament and was occasionally called upon to agree to new taxes. This gave Parliament some influence over royal decisions, particularly regarding money. During the 13th century, the king's council evolved into what we recognise as Parliament, though only nobles were involved in its proceedings.
The power to control taxation became Parliament's most important weapon against royal authority. The principle "no taxation without representation" would later become crucial in limiting monarchical power.
Industrial expansion (c1800-c1900)
The Industrial Revolution marked a turning point for parliamentary power. Parliament became increasingly powerful as people demanded greater access to political representation. Key reforms during this period included electoral reform and the expansion of the franchise (the right to vote), which became major political issues that Parliament had to address.
Modern supremacy (c1900-present)
In modern Britain, Parliament has become the primary source of political change and power. Government is now deeply involved in managing the details of people's daily lives, from healthcare and education to economic policy and social welfare. Parliament's role has expanded far beyond its mediaeval origins to become the central institution of British democracy.
Parliamentary sovereignty - the principle that Parliament is the supreme legal authority in the UK - is now the cornerstone of the British political system. This represents a complete reversal from mediaeval times when the monarch held ultimate authority.
The monarchy's transformation
Mediaeval absolutism (1066-c1450)
Mediaeval monarchs possessed almost complete power over their subjects. Land ownership was the foundation of wealth and political influence, and the monarch controlled all land distribution. Kings ruled with the belief that they had been chosen by God, giving them what was known as the divine right to rule.
The concept of divine right meant that challenging the monarch wasn't just treason - it was considered a sin against God. This religious backing made royal authority extremely difficult to question or resist.
Early modern challenges (c1450-c1800)
Although monarchs continued to wield significant power during the early modern period, their authority faced increasing challenges. Land could be bought and sold more freely, which meant that wealthy merchants and other non-nobles could gain influence. The concept of divine right to rule was being questioned, leading to political upheaval and even, for a brief period, the establishment of a republic.
Industrial adaptation (c1800-c1900)
During the Industrial Revolution, the monarchy remained an important and influential institution, but monarchs had much less real political power than their mediaeval predecessors. They became more of a symbol of national unity and tradition while elected politicians took on the day-to-day business of governing the country.
Modern symbolism (c1900-present)
Today's monarchy serves primarily a symbolic function. While the monarch remains the official head of state, their powers are largely ceremonial. Real political decisions are made by elected officials in Parliament and government, with the monarch playing a representative role in national and international affairs.
The British monarchy's transformation from absolute power to constitutional symbol demonstrates how institutions can adapt and survive by changing their role. Many other European monarchies that failed to adapt were abolished entirely.
Ordinary people's empowerment
Mediaeval powerlessness (1066-c1450)
More than 90% of mediaeval Britain's population lived in the countryside as villains (peasants tied to the land). These people had no political voice and couldn't choose where they lived or worked. They were completely dependent on their local lord and had no say in how the country was governed.
Villeinage was a form of feudal bondage where peasants were legally tied to the land and their lord. They couldn't move, marry, or even learn to read without their lord's permission. This system kept the vast majority of the population in complete political powerlessness.
Early modern mobility (c1450-c1800)
The end of villeinage around 1450 gave ordinary people more freedom to move around and seek work where they chose. Increasing numbers of people began moving to towns and cities, which provided new opportunities for social and economic advancement. However, political power remained concentrated among the wealthy and privileged classes.
Industrial transformation (c1800-c1900)
The Industrial Revolution brought dramatic changes to ordinary people's lives. More people gained the right to vote, which meant that governments had to pay greater attention to their needs and concerns. However, industrialisation also led to rapid urbanisation, and many people experienced terrible living and working conditions in the new industrial cities. Poverty became widespread among the working classes.
The Reform Acts: Expanding Democracy
The Reform Act of 1832 extended voting rights to middle-class men in towns and cities. Before this act, only about 400,000 men could vote out of a population of 24 million. The act increased this to about 650,000 voters - still a small fraction, but a significant step towards democracy.
Modern participation (c1900-present)
The twentieth century saw unprecedented expansion of ordinary people's political power. Throughout this period, more groups gained voting rights, including women. Society has moved towards greater gender and racial equality, though inequality still exists. The majority of the population now has a direct say in choosing their government and influencing political decisions.
Timeline of Major Changes
- 1066-c1450: Mediaeval period - Church and monarchy dominate, ordinary people have no political voice
- c1450: End of villeinage gives peasants freedom to move
- 13th century: King's council develops into early form of Parliament
- 14th century: Commons becomes separate part of Parliament
- c1450-c1800: Early modern period - Parliament gains some power, monarchy's divine right challenged
- Brief period: Britain becomes a republic (exact dates would need verification)
- c1800-c1900: Industrial Revolution - Parliament grows stronger, some people gain voting rights
- c1900-present: Modern democracy develops - Parliament becomes supreme, monarchy largely symbolic
- 2001: Less than 10% of population attends church regularly
Key Points to Remember:
-
Power shifted continuously: No single group maintained the same level of power throughout the entire period from 1170 to the present day.
-
Inverse relationships: As some groups gained power, others typically lost it - particularly notable is how Parliament's rise coincided with the monarchy's decline in real authority.
-
Economic factors drove change: Major economic shifts like the end of villeinage and the Industrial Revolution were key catalysts for political transformation.
-
Gradual transformation: Most changes happened slowly over centuries rather than suddenly, with the Industrial Revolution being a particularly important period of acceleration.
-
Modern democracy emerged recently: The idea that ordinary people should have a say in government is relatively new in historical terms, developing mainly over the last 200 years.