The impact of settlement (Edexcel GCSE History): Revision Notes
The impact of settlement
Growing tensions with Indigenous peoples
As American settlers moved westward during the mid-19th century, their expansion created increasing conflicts with the Indigenous peoples of the Plains. The US government faced a challenging situation: it wanted to encourage westward expansion to develop new territories, but it also needed to manage relations with Native American tribes who had lived on these lands for generations.
The government's dilemma was complex - how could they support American expansion while maintaining peaceful relations with Indigenous peoples who had established territories and ways of life that would be disrupted by settlement?
The government's solution was to try keeping Indigenous peoples and settlers separate through various policies and treaties. However, these efforts ultimately created more problems than they solved, leading to decades of conflict and tension.
Timeline of key events (1830-1851)
Understanding how settlement impacted Indigenous peoples requires looking at the key government policies that shaped this relationship:
1830: The Indian Removal Act
This law forced Indigenous peoples in eastern states to move west of the Mississippi River. The government relocated 46,000 eastern tribe members to make room for white settlers. At this time, Americans considered the western lands to be the "Great American Desert" - worthless territory that nobody wanted.
1834: The Indian Trade and Intercourse Act
The government established a "Permanent Indian Frontier" that was supposed to divide Indian Territory from the eastern states. This frontier was designed to prevent settlers from crossing over into Indigenous lands, theoretically protecting both groups from conflict.
The "Permanent Indian Frontier" was based on the assumption that western lands would remain undesirable to American settlers - an assumption that would prove completely wrong within just a few decades.
1848: Victory in the Mexican-American War
When the USA won this war, everything changed. Suddenly America controlled vast new territories in the West, and instead of being a worthless desert, these lands became valuable for settlement. The old idea of keeping Indigenous peoples separate in Indian Territory no longer worked because the territory was now right in the middle of expanding America.
The Mexican-American War fundamentally changed the government's approach to Indigenous relations. What had been seen as worthless "desert" land suddenly became prime territory for American expansion, making the existing separation policies obsolete.
1851: The Fort Laramie Treaty and Indian Appropriations Act
These agreements marked a major shift in policy. The Fort Laramie Treaty established specific territories for Indigenous peoples and allowed settlers to travel through Indian Territory. The Indian Appropriations Act provided government funding to pay Plains tribes to give up valuable lands that settlers wanted, moving them instead to smaller areas called "reservations".
Government support for westward expansion
The federal government actively encouraged Americans to move west for several important reasons. First, it needed US citizens living in the new western territories to establish American control over these lands. Second, people needed to be able to travel safely across Indigenous territories to reach these new areas.
To make westward movement possible, the US Army played a crucial role in forcing Indigenous communities away from major travel routes. The army also worked to prevent attacks on travellers moving from east to west. This military involvement showed that the government prioritised settler expansion over Indigenous rights to their traditional lands.
The use of military force to clear Indigenous peoples from travel routes represented a clear government choice: American expansion was more important than respecting established Indigenous territories and rights.
The consequences of these policies became clear quite quickly. Although the "Permanent Indian Frontier" was supposed to create a permanent boundary with Indigenous lands, settlers were now allowed to cross this frontier freely. This effectively ended the idea of keeping the two groups completely separate.
The reservation system
The Indian Appropriations Act of 1851 represented a completely new approach to managing Indigenous peoples. By the 1850s, many tribes had already been moved west into Indian Territory during the 1830s, but now settlers wanted access to these same lands.
The government's solution was to use federal funds to pay Indigenous peoples on the Plains to give up the lands that settlers wanted most. In exchange, tribes would move to much smaller areas called "reservations". These were typically areas of land that the federal government would manage and control.
The reservation system marked a fundamental shift from trying to keep settlers and Indigenous peoples separate to actively controlling where and how Indigenous peoples lived, while opening up their traditional lands to American settlement.
The government had several goals with this reservation system. Officials hoped that by placing Indigenous peoples on reservations, white settlers could teach them "new ways of living" - essentially forcing them to abandon their traditional lifestyles and adopt American farming and social customs. The government also saw reservations as a way to control where Indigenous peoples lived and what they did, making it easier to prevent conflicts with settlers.
However, this system created many problems. It forced Plains tribes to give up their traditional way of life, which often involved following buffalo herds across large areas. Being confined to small reservations made this impossible and created economic hardship for many Indigenous communities.
The reservation system didn't just change where Indigenous peoples lived - it made their traditional economic and cultural practices impossible, forcing entire communities to abandon ways of life that had sustained them for generations.
Consequences of settlement policies
The impact of these settlement policies was enormous and long-lasting. Most importantly, they marked the end of any real attempt to keep settlers and Indigenous peoples in separate areas. The "Permanent Indian Frontier" became meaningless as settlers were not only allowed but encouraged to cross into what had been Indigenous territory.
These policies also established a pattern where Indigenous peoples were consistently forced to give up valuable land whenever American settlers wanted it. Each time this happened, tribes were pushed onto smaller and less desirable areas, creating a cycle of displacement that would continue for decades.
This pattern of displacement became a template for future government policies: whenever American settlers wanted Indigenous lands, the government would find ways to force tribes to relocate, often using payments or treaties that appeared voluntary but were backed by military threat.
The shift to the reservation system fundamentally changed how Indigenous peoples lived. Traditional ways of life that had worked for generations became impossible under the restrictions of reservation life. This created not just economic problems, but also cultural and social disruption that affected entire communities.
Key Points to Remember:
-
Government policies from 1830-1851 laid the groundwork for later conflicts by first removing Indigenous peoples from eastern states, then allowing settler expansion into their western territories.
-
The "Permanent Indian Frontier" failed because of westward expansion - what started as a boundary to keep groups separate became meaningless when settlers wanted to move west.
-
The 1851 Fort Laramie Treaty and Indian Appropriations Act introduced the reservation system - forcing Plains tribes to give up large territories in exchange for government-controlled smaller areas.
-
Settlement created a pattern of displacement - whenever settlers wanted Indigenous lands, government policies forced tribes to move to less desirable areas.
-
These policies prioritised American expansion over Indigenous rights - the government consistently chose to support settler interests rather than protect established Indigenous territories.