The Permanent Indian Frontier (AQA GCSE History): Revision Notes
The Permanent Indian Frontier
Introduction
The American government struggled to manage relationships with Plains Indians as westward expansion accelerated. During the 1840s onwards, increasing numbers of white settlers moving across the Plains created growing tensions and complications for government policy. The concept of a Permanent Indian Frontier emerged as the government's attempt to create a lasting solution to these challenges.
Early government policy and challenges
The United States government faced uncertainty about how to handle the Plains Indians effectively. As more settlers began crossing the Great Plains seeking new opportunities, conflicts between Native Americans and white Americans became more frequent and complex. The government recognised that existing approaches were inadequate for managing these growing tensions.
The Plains were initially viewed by many Americans as largely empty and worthless land, making them seem suitable for relocating Native American tribes away from areas desired by white settlers. This perception would later prove to be a significant miscalculation.
The 1830 Indian Removal Act
This crucial legislation marked a turning point in federal Indian policy. The 1830 Indian Removal Act authorised the forced relocation of Native American tribes living east of the Mississippi River to western territories. The government justified this policy by claiming that western lands would allow tribes to live separately from white Americans without interference.
However, the implementation proved devastating for Native Americans. The forced westward journey became known as the Trail of Tears due to the enormous suffering and death that occurred during the relocations.
Many Cherokee people died during their forced march, highlighting the tragic human cost of this policy. The Trail of Tears represents one of the most devastating consequences of American Indian policy, with thousands of Native Americans losing their lives during the forced relocations.
The Act reflected the government's belief that the Plains were essentially worthless and impossible for white settlers to develop, making them suitable as permanent homes for relocated tribes.
The 1834 Indian Trade and Intercourse Act
Building on the removal policy, this legislation established the framework for a Permanent Indian Frontier. The 1834 Indian Trade and Intercourse Act created a clear boundary separating Indian territory from the eastern states, with the government promising that Native American tribes could live in their designated areas without American government interference.
The policy envisioned what officials called "One Big Reservation" west of the Permanent Indian Frontier. This would theoretically allow different tribes to coexist peacefully while remaining separate from white American settlements. The government also established a series of forts along the frontier to enforce this separation and protect both relocated tribes from white settlers and settlers from potential Indian attacks.
Several forts were constructed to maintain order along this boundary, demonstrating the government's commitment to enforcing the separation policy through military presence.
Problems emerge by the 1840s
The Permanent Indian Frontier concept began to collapse as circumstances changed dramatically. The discovery of gold in western territories, particularly California, sparked massive migration movements that completely undermined the original policy assumptions.
Thousands of white settlers and gold seekers began crossing through and settling in lands that had been designated exclusively for Native Americans. The government found itself unable to maintain the promised separation as economic opportunities in the West proved too attractive for American settlers to ignore.
The original belief that Plains lands were worthless and unsuitable for white settlement proved completely wrong. As settlers recognised the agricultural and mineral potential of these territories, pressure mounted to open them for white development, breaking the promises made to relocated tribes.
Geographical context
The Permanent Indian Frontier stretched across a vast area, with different tribes assigned to specific regions. Major tribes affected included the Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw, Creek, and Seminole in the southern areas, while northern regions housed tribes like the Sioux, Crow, and Blackfoot.
The policy required tribes to abandon their traditional homelands and adapt to entirely new environments, often with different climates, terrain, and resources than they were accustomed to. This geographic displacement added another layer of difficulty to an already traumatic relocation process.
Timeline of major events
- 1830: Indian Removal Act passed, authorising forced relocation of eastern tribes
- 1834: Indian Trade and Intercourse Act established the Permanent Indian Frontier
- 1840s: Discovery of gold and increased westward migration began undermining the frontier policy
- 1840s onwards: Growing white settlement west of the frontier created ongoing conflicts
Key Points to Remember:
-
The Permanent Indian Frontier was the government's attempt to create a permanent separation between Native Americans and white settlers by relocating tribes to western lands
-
The 1830 Indian Removal Act forced eastern tribes westward, resulting in the tragic Trail of Tears where many Native Americans died during forced relocations
-
The 1834 Indian Trade and Intercourse Act established the frontier boundary and promised tribes could live without government interference in their designated territories
-
By the 1840s, gold discoveries and increased white settlement completely undermined the policy as settlers moved into lands reserved for Native Americans
-
The policy failed because it was based on the false assumption that western Plains were worthless and would never attract white settlement