Consumer Laws (HSC SSCE Business Studies): Revision Notes
Consumer Laws
Introduction to consumer protection legislation
Since the 1960s, Australian consumer law has undergone significant transformation. Both federal and state governments have introduced legislation to strengthen consumer protection and clarify business responsibilities. While marketers do not need legal expertise, they must understand the laws governing their operations.
Key principle: Ignorance of the law is not a defence. Businesses must stay informed about legal changes and adapt their practices accordingly—whether that means modifying advertising campaigns, redesigning packaging, or adjusting credit policies.
The Australian Consumer Law (ACL)
In 2011, Australia introduced a unified national framework—the Australian Consumer Law (ACL)—which replaced 17 separate national, state and territory consumer laws. This reform created a single set of rules that apply uniformly across Australia, regardless of where businesses operate or consumers shop.
Benefits of the ACL:
The introduction of the ACL brought several key advantages:
- Consistent consumer rights and protections nationwide
- Simplified compliance for businesses operating across multiple jurisdictions
- Clearer understanding of rights and obligations for all parties
Implementation structure:
The ACL operates as an application law, enforced across different jurisdictions:
- Implemented by the Competition and Consumer Act 2010
- Enforced by the ACCC at Commonwealth level
- Applied by state and territory consumer agencies as local laws
- Includes mirror protections in the ASIC Act for financial services
Competition and Consumer Act 2010
The Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (CCA) represents one of Australia's most important pieces of business legislation. It serves two primary functions:
- Consumer protection: Safeguards consumers against harmful practices, including:
- Misrepresentation of product contents or origin
- Misleading and deceptive advertising
- Unconscionable conduct
- Competition regulation: Ensures multiple businesses operate in the same market to maintain healthy competition
Key term: Unconscionable conduct refers to any unreasonable business practice that is often illegal—behaviour that falls outside acceptable commercial standards.
Enforcement and penalties
The CCA applies to virtually all Australian businesses, including government commercial activities. Enforcement responsibility lies with:
- Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) - primary enforcement body
- State and territory consumer agencies
- Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) - for financial services
Penalty increases (2018):
In 2018, penalties for ACL breaches were substantially increased:
For companies, the penalty is the greater of:
- $10 million per breach
- Three times the benefit received
- 10% of annual turnover in the preceding 12 months (where benefit cannot be calculated)
For individuals:
- Increased from ``500,000 per breach]
Additional consequences:
- Consumers can sue for compensation
- Legal fees accumulate
- Significant reputational damage occurs
Infringement notices:
The ACCC can issue fines without court action for suspected breaches. Standard penalties are:
- $13,320 for regular corporations (or $\133,200 for listed corporations)
- $2,664 for individuals
The ACCC can also issue public warning notices to alert consumers about suspected illegal activity, allowing faster intervention than previously possible when court injunctions were required.
Deceptive and misleading advertising
The CCA prohibits deceptive and misleading advertising. The fundamental rule states that any representation (direct or implied) must be truthful and unlikely to mislead the target audience.
Common forms of misleading advertising
1. Bait advertising
Involves advertising products unavailable or in extremely limited quantities at reduced prices to attract customers. When advertised stock runs out, customers are redirected to higher-priced alternatives.
2. Fine print and qualifications
Important conditions written in small print that must not contradict the advertisement's overall message.
3. Comparative advertising
Comparisons to other market products can be misleading if inaccurate or inappropriate.
4. Environmental ('green') claims
Businesses making environmental claims about products must substantiate them with evidence.
5. Country of origin claims
False or misleading statements about where goods originate are prohibited.
6. Premium (credence) claims
Claims suggesting a product has added benefits compared to similar products (e.g., 'fat free', '100% recyclable') must be substantiated and not misleading.
7. Prize giveaways and competitions
Businesses must not mislead consumers about prizes offered or chances of winning. Any conditions must be disclosed upfront.
8. Dishonest advertising
Advertisements must not use deceptive language or falsely claim specific product qualities. Price reductions, specials and free-gift offers must be genuine.
Case Study: Samsung Galaxy phones (2019)
In 2019, the ACCC initiated proceedings against Samsung for allegedly deceiving consumers about the water resistance of various Galaxy phones. Samsung's advertising led consumers to believe their phones would continue working when exposed to all water types, when this was not the case. These misleading claims appeared in more than 300 advertisements.
Case Study: Voltaren fine (2020)
The makers of Voltaren admitted breaching the ACL and paid $4.5 million in penalties for making false and misleading representations. The company marketed Osteo Gel as more effective than Emulgen (which is 33% cheaper) for treating osteoarthritis, despite the products being essentially identical.
Case Study: Empower Institute (2019)
The Federal Court ordered Empower Institute to pay $26.5 million in penalties for ACL breaches and repay over $56 million to the Commonwealth. The Court found Empower engaged in systematic unconscionable conduct when enrolling consumers in VET FEE-HELP funded courses by:
- Targeting vulnerable and disadvantaged consumers
- Making false or misleading representations
- Offering inducements such as free Google Chromebooks
Case Study: Volkswagen emissions scandal (2019)
Volkswagen AG was ordered to pay $125 million—the highest total penalty ever for consumer law contraventions. The company admitted that when requesting approval to import over 57,000 vehicles into Australia between 2011 and 2015, it failed to disclose two-mode software that concealed true nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions.
How the deception worked:
- Mode one: Activated during emissions testing, producing lower NOx emissions
- Mode two: Operated during normal road driving, producing higher NOx emissions exceeding permitted limits
Volkswagen engineers designed this software in 2006 and kept it secret until discovery in 2015. The company also made false representations when applying for vehicles to appear on the government's Green Vehicle Guide website.
Price discrimination
Price discrimination involves charging different customers different prices for identical products or services based on what sellers believe customers will pay. Sellers determine prices based on customer demographics or perceived product value.
Legal status in Australia
Price discrimination is generally legal in Australia. The original prohibition in the 1974 Trade Practices Act was eventually repealed. However, price discrimination may breach section 46 of the CCA if it:
- Substantially reduces competition
- Represents misuse of market power
- Provides favoured treatment to some customers while denying it to others
How price discrimination works
Modern price discrimination relies heavily on data collection and algorithms. For example:
Uber's dynamic pricing:
Uses 'route-based pricing' to charge customers based on predicted willingness to pay:
- Considers variables including location, time of day, traffic patterns and user history
- Even factors in phone battery level—users with low battery are more likely to accept surge pricing because they need immediate transportation
Airline pricing:
Airlines and intermediary platforms employ two levels of price discrimination:
- Airline level: Dynamic pricing with higher prices for popular flights
- Intermediary level: Travel agents and comparison websites add further price variation
Techniques used:
- Websites create cookies tracking user interactions
- Tags and beacons collect information about browser type and device
- If users repeatedly check specific flights, providers may increase prices (assuming commitment) or decrease them (to secure the booking)
Consumer strategies to minimize price discrimination:
- Clear cookies regularly
- Use search engines that don't share search history (e.g., DuckDuckGo)
- Shop around using comparison services
Legal limitations
Price discrimination faces two main constraints:
1. Discrimination laws: Charging different prices based on protected characteristics (e.g., charging women with Italian surnames more) violates the Racial Discrimination Act
2. Reputational risk: Social media backlash can cause significant reputational damage. Amazon issued statements denying price discrimination after customer complaints about differential pricing.
Implied conditions and consumer guarantees
Implied conditions are unspoken and unwritten contract terms assumed to exist regardless of explicit mention. These conditions form the foundation of consumer guarantees.
Consumer guarantees under the ACL
When introduced in 2011, the CCA established consumer guarantees—automatic rights providing consumers with remedies when purchased goods or services fail to meet ACL standards. These guarantees cannot be excluded by businesses.
If products or services don't meet expectations, consumers have automatic rights regardless of written contracts.
Product guarantees
Products must meet several standards:
1. Acceptable quality
Products must be:
- Safe, lasting and fault-free
- Visually acceptable
- Capable of performing all normal expected functions
The acceptable quality standard considers product type and cost—expectations for a $50 appliance differ from those for a $500 appliance.
2. Additional product requirements
Products must:
- Match descriptions from salespeople, packaging, labels, promotions and advertising
- Match demonstration models or samples requested
- Be fit for purposes stated by the business or made known before purchase
- Carry no hidden debts or additional charges
- Meet extra performance, condition and quality promises (e.g., lifetime guarantees, money-back offers)
- Have spare parts and repair facilities available for reasonable periods post-purchase (unless otherwise stated)
Service guarantees
Services must be:
- Provided with acceptable care, skill and technical knowledge
- Delivered with all necessary steps taken to avoid loss and damage
- Fit for stated purposes or deliver agreed results
- Completed within reasonable timeframes when no specific end date exists
Claiming remedies
For products:
Consumers can claim remedies from retailers (not manufacturers) if products don't meet guarantees. Retailers cannot redirect consumers to manufacturers or importers.
For services:
Consumers can claim remedies from service suppliers if services fail to meet guarantees. Available remedies include service cancellation and, in some cases, compensation for damages and losses.
Case Study: Jetstar Airways (2019)
Jetstar was ordered to pay $1.95 million for making false representations about consumer guarantee rights. The Federal Court found Jetstar's website misleadingly claimed some fares were non-refundable. However, passengers may be entitled to refunds under consumer guarantees when flights are cancelled or significantly delayed.
Case Study: Sony PlayStation (2020)
Sony paid $3.5 million in penalties for false representations to four consumers who purchased faulty PlayStation games. Customer service representatives incorrectly stated customers weren't entitled to refunds if games were downloaded or if 14 days had passed since purchase. Under the ACL, consumers are entitled to remedies when products fail to meet guarantees, and these rights don't expire after 14 days.
Warranties
A warranty is a business promise to correct defects in goods produced or services delivered—essentially a commitment to repair or replace faulty products.
Purpose and marketing value
Warranties serve multiple functions:
- Provide customer protection if products are faulty or services lack proper care and skill
- Act as marketing tools—longer warranties than competitors suggest superior quality
- Demonstrate business confidence in product quality
Legal requirements
Government legislation requires businesses to state warranty terms and conditions clearly and simply. The CCA prohibits false or misleading statements about:
- Warranty existence
- Warranty exclusions
- Warranty conditions
Refunds and exchanges
Legal refund obligations
Businesses must offer refunds when products:
- Are faulty
- Don't match descriptions or samples
- Fail to perform their intended function
No refund obligation exists when:
- Customers change their minds
- Customers find cheaper prices elsewhere
- Damage occurs after purchase
Accurate refund signage
Misleading signs like 'no refunds given' or 'no refunds on sale items' are meaningless under the CCA. More accurate signs state:
- 'No refunds given if you change your mind'
- 'No refunds or exchanges unless your purchase is defective'
Remember!
Key Points to Remember:
-
The Australian Consumer Law (ACL) introduced in 2011 created a single national framework, replacing 17 different laws and ensuring consistent consumer rights across Australia
-
The Competition and Consumer Act 2010 protects consumers from undesirable business practices and maintains market competition. Penalties for breaches can reach $10 million or more for companies
-
Deceptive and misleading advertising is illegal. Common violations include bait advertising, misleading fine print, false comparative claims, unsubstantiated environmental claims, and dishonest prize promotions
-
Price discrimination (charging different customers different prices) is generally legal in Australia but may breach the Act if it substantially reduces competition or represents misuse of market power
-
Consumer guarantees provide automatic rights that products must be of acceptable quality, match descriptions, be fit for purpose, and that services must be provided with acceptable care and skill within reasonable timeframes
-
Warranties are business promises to repair or replace faulty products. Businesses must offer refunds for faulty products, those not matching descriptions, or those failing to perform their intended function—but not for change of mind